civplayah's experimental mafia

[Kennigit]

Because the time would be right.

Anyways, if I may brag, my very first Pm was to the GM saying that as a mafia I would serve faithfully, but of course, it would be tough as everyone else would have the same role as me. 13 players all instructed they are the lone mafia.

And thanks to takhisis and zack for confirming it .

/brag

 

[Takhisis]

Yeah... I was the one who pissed civplayah off by finding weaselly ways to twist the role Pm and win without too much effort... hence his in-thread post.

 

[choxorn]

I guessed that this was the set-up on around day 1, but wasn't sure until some of the posts acted exactly like that, and then Myth straight-out saying he was the mafia a few hours ago.

 

[Takhisis]

I didn't catch on that fast until day2, after civplayah again didn't confirm the dead person's alignment. That's why I kept insisting on bandwaggoning abstain.

 

[mythmonster2]

Oh wait. That was serious? We are all Mafia? Whoa...

 

[wideyedwanderer]

Um...I don't know how many mafia there are, but I'm not one.

 

[choxorn]

Interesting.

LYNCH THE NON-MAFIA! LYNCH HIM!

 

[classical_hero]

Yeah lets lynch everyone who claims to be non mafia, or mafia.

 

[civplayah]

Yeah... I was the one who pissed civplayah off by finding weaselly ways to twist the role Pm and win without too much effort... hence his in-thread post.

Oh, no, that wasn't about you. It was about Kennigit. Although we worked it out.

 

[civplayah]

Good job everyone, then the remaining people are let go, and civplayah gets all upset.

Although I really wanted to end this game. But looks like you guys are all too clever for me. Catharsis actually figured it out within an hour of him receiving his role PM. Kennigit also did, but it was a joke. This is what he said, although it doesn't make much sense:

Yessir.

And I'm sure all 10 of us are mafia, nay? Each instructed to survive until the end. No kills, no ability, simply lies to each other, eh?

So I'll give

Catharsis
Kennigit
mythmonster2

And everyone else should feel proud of themselves for getting extremely paranoid.

Oh, and, I love this setting, so I think I'll do a NotW based on it.

So, I want critique. My last two games either lacked GM skills or RP or both. What do you think of this one?

 

[Zack]

Wait, Kennigit - When did you ever say I was mafia?

LYNCH WIDEYEDWANDERER!!!

EDIT: Crosspost. Curse you civplayah, I thought no discussion of game mechanics extended to the GM as well.

 

[civplayah]

Well the game's over, Zack. Everyone figured it out, so it's pointless now.

 

[Zack]

No, that's not what I meant. I thought I couldn't discuss game mechanics with you either, as it seems so many people did.

 

[Tee Kay]

Wow, to be honest the thought never cross my mind.

 

[civplayah]

No, that's not what I meant. I thought I couldn't discuss game mechanics with you either, as it seems so many people did.

Well, as long as I don't tell anyone else then you could send your ideas to me (but I'd prefer you stay clueless )

 

[civplayah]

Wow, to be honest the thought never cross my mind.

Well, I mean, if you look at the PM, it explains in detail why this game is hard- something unnecessary. Plus, if you look at the mafia info thread I finished the whole game in two days.

 

[Zack]

Did Domination just make up his Personal Goal to kill Kennigit?

 

[civplayah]

Yep. I have no idea why though.

 

[Kennigit]

IT WAS NOT A JOKE.

I sent a bunch of stuff to you zack to see how you reacted, because although I suspected, I was not 100% sure. I became 100% sure based off you and takhisis's reactions. Also domination3000 said he had "no abilities" and that sealed the deal.

I thought everyone was mafia, but I thought there might still be abilities despite my PM to civplayah. So when you were very weasily about talking about how the game could be experimental and how you shyed away from ability talk, I felt confident enough.

Also good job catharsis. You devil trying to get people to abstain.

edit- and that PM makes perfect sense! what fun is a game without crypting stuff. I clearly identify that I thought there were 10 of us (I forgot you added 3), each one instructed to survive until the end as a mafia. And we were instructed to make a "cover role" when we needed to (hence the lies)---and there are no kills and abilities.

As far as the "yessir" goes, that's just saying I would carry out my mafia duties faithfully. You gave me instructions, and I shall follow them my master GM.

Lastly, this game was fun but if you never disclose any info about the dead, people get suspicious. I would have liked more "fake" stuff, as in fake night attacks (like say, Kennigit was injured during the night), or even say Domination3000 was a neutral or something.

EDIT EDIT FINAL TING I SWARES: also, I think I pointed this out to zack, but by having an update where you said the last man standing would get a big reward WHICH I STILL WANT THAT REWARD gives away it's not mafia vs innocent, since innocents would win when all mafia die or mafia win when they mathematically would beat the innocents.

Being instructed to be the "lone" mafia seems that the game would be ruined if say, when 10/13 people were alive the one mafia got lynched.

 

[Takhisis]

I'm not sure what it counts as, if we were all mafia then my record is 4.