Fix the 5th trash game

the latest update ...

i have 7 out of 8 votes. i have not voted, i did not play, and am tabulating votes instead. if we end up with a tie i'll study up and break it i suppose.

the votes that have come in so far, we are not at a tie. but, the margin between the top two is close enough that the remaining vote could change that. so, there is some suspense ;). not to put any pressure on our friend who has yet to weigh in, it's merely the fate of our civilization that rests on your hands.

happy easter y'all! tomorrow is one of my favorite holidays, along with february 15th and november 1st. that's when i celebrate "half-price leftover candy day" :woohoo: [party] :clap: :woohoo:
 
The reason why I don't think OR is such a hot civic at this point is because 1) there's only so much infrastructure to build at this point - granary and library and 2) it involves adopting a state religion. Assuming you can spread hinduism to all of the other cities, you'll still be adopting a religion that's contrary to what Cyrus (he won't hate you that much) and Brennus have (he'll loathe you). Brennus can play like a mini-Izzy at times, so I think it's a pretty big gamble to be running a contrary state religion. However, Brennus' preferred civic is OR, so you may be able to negate the bad state religion bonus with a "you run our fav. civic" bonus if Brennus goes into OR also.

I guess it's just sounding like a cost/benefit analysis at this point :lol: To each his own :) I will try an early OR in my next game to see how it plays out.

I was also thinking about going for organised religion quickly. You are right that we might not spend that much production power on buildings at this stage in the game and the 25% bonus on building construction is the main strength of the civic. I must say that I usually build a granary and barracks in some of my cities at this stage of the game, but I also spend a lot of hammers to build workers and settlers.

However, another strength of organised religion is the ability to build missionaries without a monastery. So we can spead our own religion to the rest of our cities which means that we won't need monuments anymore to expand the borders and we can send a missionary to Berlin. This early in the game, that might help ensure a German ally. You don't even have to adopt a religion for these effects of organised religion.

Yes, this is a problem. I played a couple of turns on an a barb axe monstered the gold city.

Eek, I didn't want to know that. There's a good chance that your save will be chosen as best (don't know how everyone voted, but I could see your save winning) and now I know that I will lose a city if your save is chosen. Not funny. ;)

regarding the placement of Madras. Yes it is weak. I see from your dot mapping that you like to use all the available good tiles. My city placement is at the stage of grabbing resources,and blocking out the AI only.

Yes, I don't like to lose good tiles. But my city placement probably isn't appreciated by players who don't want overlapping tiles between their cities. To each his/her own.

But doesn't grabbing a bit of gold early on give a big advantage? I mean early tech muscle can pay big dividends, even though the city will not reach full potential. Then there's the happiness from forges.

It's a moot point as I think this city will really die to Barbs

I agree. Early in the game this city is very interesting. If I were to encounter a similar settling spot in 1500AD while already owning two dozen cities, then I wouldn't be that interested anymore. It would be just another city. The early science bonus however is quite large.

shyuhe, i'm not sure if "Dutch jury" is a phrase meaning something other than simply a jury from the Netherlands. Roland will have to tell us.

As a non-native English speaker, I must say that I didn't mean to add a second meaning. I hope there isn't some hidden second meaning. I'm from the Netherlands as you can see in my profile.

Öjevind Lång;5299407 said:
One of the ways a religion spreads is along coasts. We have Hinduism in one coastal city (the one near Berlin) and will hopefully have it in the other coastal city too before long. Also, I do think we should try to build the Colossus; it's a fairly cheap, early Wonder that lasts a long time and gives lots of flokarinos. Er... money, that is.

With copper, the colossus is rather cheap, I agree. But we need to use quite some coastal/ocean tiles to get back the investment and I'm not planning to use that many coastal/ocean tiles in the near future. I might build it, but it is not a priority for me at this moment. If it is still available after I've done the stuff that has a higher priority (according to me), then I might build it.

Religion does spread along the coast. The major reason is that early trading happens by using coastal waters. So you need coastal trading and open borders for that to work well. I often go for that as well.

I must note that by building one single road connecting the capital with the river would connect the capital to the coastal waters. That connection would also lead to a coastal trading network. It's not known to many that trading road-river-coast works that nicely.
 
I didn't realize you were from the Netherlands Roland (I don't pay too much attention to the "from" column). You Europeans constantly amaze me with your proficiency in English... It makes me ashamed that I can barely speak Spanish (my second language that I learned in high school).
 
ok the verdict is in ... i looked back in the thread and i see that FB is off at the beach this weekend, and will not get back until monday night! so, he expected to be skipped. our game will go on using mice's game as the best round :) the save is back up in post #117. i'm not sure how long we're playing to this time.

no roland i didn't mean there was any meaning *giggle*. i just wondered if it had some particular meaning over there, that we're not familiar with over here. i love phrases/sayings that we just use without ever thinking about them, then someone that's not a native speaker hears it and wonders what it means. and you have to really think about why it means that! or some are exactly the same as another but expressed differently. my typical example is in spoken english, we say "i missed the boat". in american sign language (the grammar is totally different from spoken, it's a language believe me) we state it as "train go sorry". same bottom line, you missed your chance.

i have some very long-term, quite close online friends from the netherlands, we've been together in three MMOs over the years. i've picked up some dutch along the way, can't follow it worth a bean when spoken but in writing i can understand like a 4-year-old's level maybe. i never get the grammar right when typing it tho ;). i was in WoW once on the european server, and two guys were talking in an inn about how to do a quest, they were typing in dutch. i knew the area very well, and from context i had a ton of clues and knew what the quest was, so i answered them, but in english. they laughed at that, but appreciated the help!

i'm curious: my default pronunciation of your name is the far more uncommon way in the US, because my uncle pronounces it that way, starting out kind of like "raw" meat but not exactly. most people pronounce it "roll" like a ball. which is more common over there?
 
Congratulations Mice :goodjob: - credit to both you and Roland for nabbing the 'Golds' spot which I agree will place us well for the remainder of the game. We have to start hooking up some of those resources now! :)

I felt that there were many strong entries this time - even the games that I didn't personally 'go for' had several good elements about them.

I think the next few rounds will be where we really start to make progress with some challenging decisions to be 'nutted out' and maybe a nation or two to :borg:. We will start to better shape our strategy - look at leveraging our Philosophical trait, and start focussing on diplomacy and religion. Do we make bee-lines or cover all basic technologies first? Will we grow to the north or the south? Questions! Questions!

Personally I found it was difficult to nit-pick others' games - some went after Iron Working, others after Writing ... both great choices and neither especially wrong. For me, I took the Writing path so we could start catching up technologically and perhaps look at popping our first :gp:s, but revealing Iron resource tiles changed the dynamic of the game and respective cities' roles.
 
Yike! The first time my save has been selected in a trash game ever , and for best save. But ... I'm really sure that Bangalore will go to Barbs. It's just not defended well enough at Monarch level, and no way to defend it that I can see. I over extended. This will mean a loss of all those hammers. So in effect there will be some trash to fix in this round too.

Oh well, cant do anything about it now .

Ive been thinking, we should start to leverage the philosophical trait soon.


update; I managed to save Bangalore in my game playing on. It involves some "sacrifice"
 
Congrats Mice! I hope your comment about Bangalore going to barbs isn't true... it's time to defend the gold!

Cabert - what is our end date for this set?
 
I on the other hand managed to lose Bangalore in 700bc. Not a good start.
 
Congratulations Mice! Your save looked good in my opinion, so a good choise. And I must agree with Cam_H that there were several good games and each had its own strong points.

What should we do with the information that Bangalore is going to fall within a few turns. It has been communicated freely without any spoiler tags. On the other hand, it is something that is going to happen in a few turns and we shouldn't actually know about it.

Of course, it is clear that the city is vulnerable. But I will make other choices if I know the city is going to be attacked within a few turns, then if I don't know about that.

To KMadCandy:

The next time that you're the one collecting the votes, I'll vote in Dutch. We'll see how good your Dutch is. If someone gets 3000 votes, then we know something went wrong in translation (or that I try to cheat). :D

Roland Johansen is only my online name. So pronounce it however you like. The name sounds a bit scandinavian in origin. So if you want to find some original pronounciation, you could find it in those languages. I don't know any of the scandinavian languages, so I guess it doesn't matter at all. :)

How should I pronounce your online name? :D
 
well, my real name starts with a K, and can be a boy's name or a girl's name. i went to a mostly male school and got sick of getting resume response letters addressed to Mr! so, i started using KMadeleine as my email and online name, since it's all girly (even tho it never got used on resumes). i picked it for one of my favorite authors, Madeleine L'Engle, but i use the shortened version for games where you end typing the name for instant messages and stuff. then one game let me pick a last name too and i have a sweet tooth, so, that was easy ;) some games i lots of alt characters, they tend to be similar but different, and almost always have K names. i've had KMad, KMadness, KBad, KBadness, stuff like that. once i was Kaelee. so usually folks just call me K *giggle*.

if you do pronounce the whole KMadeleine part, it must rhyme with sin, not with wine. this is crucial. i have red hair and do not like the Madeline books, since that little girl has red hair and wears a yellow raincoat. i have hair clashage issues, i have all my life. my mother used to dress me in red and yellow. she meant well, but those pictures horrify me to this day.

i didn't mean my dutch is good!!!!! but it's good enough to know those numbers were french :crazyeye:. and in the WoW conversation i'd done what they were typing about so many times myself that it was simple. and, it was *typed* not spoken, otherwise, never in a million years :lol:
 
What should we do with the information that Bangalore is going to fall within a few turns. It has been communicated freely without any spoiler tags. On the other hand, it is something that is going to happen in a few turns and we shouldn't actually know about it.

But it's a bit like knowing where the copper is when you didn't find it yourself.
Hard to know how to play then.

It was bad form giving out this information. I got the jitters.

Strategies won't change though, just some tactics.
 
Pfew! Caught you up! I think I'll not go to the beach anymore. You guys write too much! Took me... 45 minutes to "fast read" :blush: all the posts.

Mice! Congratulations on your save being picked! Do enjoy the feeling of being picked first as a good game. I know it's good. ;)

@everyone that wrote about my save: I know it was poor. Take out of it all the turns I wasted on researching Priesthood and I'd have gotten IW as Roland and shyuhe. I'm too used to Prince level. Forgot this was monarch. The Pyramids would have been a biiiiiiig boost into this game, but the gold site was way more important. About not building a monument at Madras: I got our religion there first. It would pop the borders before I even built the monument. I wished Bombay got the religion, not Madras! And I agree about all that jungle. You guys jacked my fishing research so badly that I thought a coastal city there was a :nono:. So, that spot would be the only one good enough.

Enough about the past. Let's go on with the new. And, Mice, you don't have to consider using some "sacrifice" as a spoilerish thing. "Volunteers" are ALWAYS too good to pass. :D
 
Re spoiler about Bangalore's barb. Its spoiled in that you know its likely to happen; on the other hand mice posted that he'd saved the city and I posted that I hadn't so the outcome is not pre-ordained.

Edit: At this point in the game we should be working on the assumption that barbs are going to be around and planning accordingly.
 
ok the verdict is in ... i looked back in the thread and i see that FB is off at the beach this weekend, and will not get back until monday night! so, he expected to be skipped. our game will go on using mice's game as the best round :) the save is back up in post #117. i'm not sure how long we're playing to this time.

Congratulations, Mice! I do think this was the right verdict. :)

So we play as usual and hand in our saves Saturday night at latest?
 
Öjevind Lång;5304437 said:
Congratulations, Mice! I do think this was the right verdict. :)

So we play as usual and hand in our saves Saturday night at latest?
the usual is friday midnight east coast = saturday afternoon australian time
congrats mice:king:
 
I am definitely in the group that didn't get the crazy axe barb

Spoiler :
Re-arrange some builds at the start of the set, whip out a granary in Delhi before going back to the settler. Whip a monument out in the other city. Next turn, I see a barb axe north of Bangalore - swap production to archer and send the worker to chop the forest, but the barb heads to Munich instead. Phew! :D

Munich absorbs some serious barb attacks and as a result, our gold mine is untouched. I send the settler from Delhi to grab the horse site by founding SW of the horses in an attempt to block off Brennus and to leave space for a city in the jungle later. It's unhealthy at size 1 though :(

I finish researching writing, then set to alphabet as I know Brennus has IW (mine on grassland but no copper in sight), and he doesn't have alphabet. The AI all go for Monarchy instead, and so I backfill IW, fishing, and HBR with alphabet. Brennus later offers math for HBR, which I take. Judaism also spreads to one of my cities so I swap religions. Now Bismarck is the only non-Jew on the continent as he founded Confucianism.

Construction will be done in 2 turns. A push after Bismarck would be nice to free up some non-jungle land and to grab his wonders. Plus, he has no horses or ivory whereas Brennus and Cyrus have both (I did lots of scouting of enemy lands during my set). I also find out the secret to Cyrus' crazy research. 2 gold mines + FP in his capital!
 
Here's my save:

http://forums.civfanatics.com/uploads/61698/Trashy_gandhi_jevind_125AD.CivWarlordsSave

Spoiler :
My priorities were to get proper troops, build infrastructure, increase research, get Organized Religion.
875 BC: sent archer in Delhi to Madras, freegoing archer to Bangalore, building new archer in Delhi and then finish settler there. I would have done that under all circumstances; you can't defend a city with just warriors this late in the game.
800 BC: Rushed settler in Delhi, building archer.
750 BC: Brennus offered Open Borders agreement. I consented.
750 BC:Writing researched. Started to research Monotheism
725 BC: Oracle BIAADL.
I offered Open Borders agreement with Cyrus. He consented.
700 BC: Monument finished in Bangalore. Started building library.
675 BC: Founded Calcutta near horse tile.
650 BC: Finished Fast Worker in Madras, now building barracks there.
Finished granary in Delhi, building axeman.
500 BC: Hinduism spreads in Berlin.
Confucianism founded in a distant land (Germany, actually.)
450 BC: Bismark converts to Hinduism
Brennus converts to Judaism
400 BC: Hinduism has spread to Ecbatana
325 BC: Hinduism has spread in Madras
300 BC: Bismarck is Pleased, Cyrus is Cautious, Brennus is Annoyed at us.
275 BC: Built library in Delhi, started on axeman.
200 BC: Hinduism has spread to Cologne, which has been built between Bombay and Delhi. No worries; we can make it flip.
Finished researching Monotheism, adopted Organized Religion. Started to research Iron Working.
175 BC: Began to build Parthenon in Delhi. (there is also a science specialist in Delhi.)
75 BC: Whipped fast worker in Bombay, started to build monument.
50 BC: Great Prophet born in Berlin.
75 BC: Christianity founded in a distant land. So that's how Bismarck probably used his prophet.
Judaism spread in Calcutta.
125 AD: Finished Hindu missionary in Madras, sending him to Bombay.

Notes: Bangalore was attacked by a barbarian axeman, but only after I had got an archer there. I repeat that getting archers to all outlying cities would have been a priority for me under all circumstances.
Parthenon good for culture bomb to flip Cologne, but we also need a Great Prophet to build Hindu shrine.
 
Mice! Congratulations on your save being picked! Do enjoy the feeling of being picked first as a good game. I know it's good. ;)

Tinged with regret a bit because I screwed up building a city and not defending it properly, and then giving out info which should have been in a spoiler.
But there's no point flagellating oneself. I enjoy this team and thread so much. I just want to get on with the game.

Fbelin, I thought your Madras was well placed but I know Shyuhe mentioned that is was a bad spot because of the jungle work needed. It's that question of balancing short term with long term, but what is the answer?
 
Fbelin, I thought your Madras was well placed but I know Shyuhe mentioned that is was a bad spot because of the jungle work needed. It's that question of balancing short term with long term, but what is the answer?
there is no answer

higher levels make short term more important, but the argument against jungle cities can be turned the other way (high level = low happiness cap = no need for 20 workable squares).
I think land based cities are essential for the eraly game, when you don't start with fishing and when you plan to build up your cities for space.
Other than that, you need commerce cities and production cities.
The position is certainly arguable, but I think that a late production city needs :
- food
- a few resources
It is better on a river too.
Commerce cities need gold/gems/silver or cottageable rivers.
 
Back
Top Bottom