Don't be a jerk. God of All Creation is a good pantheon for basically any scenario, so long as the map you are playing has at least 8 players. Its great with tradition, you end up so far ahead in culture. It makes sitting on just your capital really appealing, I don't think you need to build settlers unless you want to settle horses or rush a monopoly bonus.
I recently had a game as tradition Maya where I'm very confident the correct play was to take GoAC and skip religion. The other pantheons would have given me like 4 or 5 yields the turn I founded, it gave me 16. It takes a very long time for pantheons that are linked to terrain to catch up to GoAC in total yields, and they require a lot of work. I think its better than some of the Celtic pantheons, like Ogma (and Ogma isn't bad).