KotOR Mafia - game thread

[Darth Caesar]

Vote: DaveShack seems like the best bet right now.

 

[topsecret]

vote:mechaerik He jumped on the wagon immediately, and seemed way to eager. I think jumping on Dave is ridiculous.

 

[johnhughthom]

vote:mechaerik He jumped on the wagon immediately, and seemed way to eager. I think jumping on Dave is ridiculous.

Oh really? Why is that then?

 

[topsecret]

STOP.

We've done this a hundred times. We all know what happens next. There will be a ridiculouswagon on DaveShack (perhaps fairly so) but there will be no discussion and we will waste our time.

This is still a round where we can accuse and discuss. If you're going to ridiculouswagon Dave, then please, pretend he's already dead and start accusing the next person in line.

The town is at its strongest right now. Why wait until we're weak and being forced to rely on inactive folks to defeat the scums? Most everyone is alive now. Discuss now. point fingers now.

You don't get this opportunity later on.

Vote Dave if you absolutely must, but also nominate someone for death tomorrow. Or, let's say, for a vigilante to kill.

Those are the reasons, although I must add this. Do you really think I would protect Dave and show myself as mafia this obvious? No, and Dave will more than likely be lynched. But he could be important to the town. He may be scum for all I know, but blind lynching bothers me.

 

[Verarde]

Even if Dave has dark-side ties, that doesn't necessarily mean he is scum. Revan was a Sith, yet (if you go Light) he becomes a Jedi once more. I'm not willing to jump on the bandwagon just yet.

I'll eat some crow if Dave turns up scum, but I'm not willing to contribute to a bandwagon on Day 2. There's likely some scum hiding among the wagoners...

x-post with topsecret. I agree with him.

 

[johnhughthom]

Those are the reasons, although I must add this. Do you really think I would protect Dave and show myself as mafia this obvious? No, and Dave will more than likely be lynched. But he could be important to the town. He may be scum for all I know, but blind lynching bothers me.

WIFOM defence and quoting Askthepizzaguy usually = , so I guess I'll let it go.

 

[Jarrema]

Even if Dave has dark-side ties, that doesn't necessarily mean he is scum. Revan was a Sith, yet (if you go Light) he becomes a Jedi once more.

True. Thats why I described my exact result, not just said 'he is scum'. But I still believe that even if he is not mafia (and he probably is), he is not a pro-town role either

 

[Zack]

Could you be more specific, Jarrema? Is Dave...

- susceptible to dark side
- practitioner of dark side
- connected to dark-siders
- renounced dark-sider

Or something else?

 

[johnhughthom]

Could you be more specific, Jarrema? Is Dave...

- susceptible to dark side
- practitioner of dark side
- connected to dark-siders
- renounced dark-sider

Or something else?

Seems he already answered this.

True. Thats why I described my exact result, not just said 'he is scum'. But I still believe that even if he is not mafia (and he probably is), he is not a pro-town role either

Just 'connection with Dark Side of the force'.

 

[Zack]

It was a crosspost.

 

[johnhughthom]

It was a crosspost.

I know, hence my posting without making fun of you.

 

[Zack]

It would be canonical for Revan to start as dark side, then he can forge his own path after he dies (or "dies").

Unvote, Vote: DaveShack

There aren't any other decent leads, and this one is more than decent. The odds for Dave being an important town role are slim.

 

[johnhughthom]

I dunno, the wording makes it sound more like cult susceptibility to me.

 

[Jarrema]

I dunno, the wording makes it sound more like cult susceptibility to me.

I will add one bit of info: in the description of my ability it is written that it is alignment scan.
Of course, in some games alingnment may mean something different than mafia/town split

 

[Zack]

Maybe if it said susceptible. But "connections" sounds like someone already involved with the dark side. We'll find out soon enough.

EDIT: cross post with Jarrema; his post makes it pretty clear DaveShack is a scumbag.

 

[johnhughthom]

I'm probably thinking too deeply, but Jarema said 'connection' not 'connections'. The former would indicate a potential for becoming dark side, the latter that the character is already attuned to the dark side.

 

[Zack]

Well he just said it's an alignment scan. Meaning Dave is currently attuned to the dark side of the Force.

 

[dragonprobably]

Vote: Zack Zack, IMO, is acting very suspicious. I don't see any scummy behavior in DaveShack and I'm a bit skeptical about Jarrema. Jarrema, what is your character name?

 

[JohannaK]

Ufff... well, the case is clear: if DaveShack is Mafia, then we're all good. Also, surely one can act town-ish when being Mafia, or not? Surely, I'm a bit skeptical about Jarrema, but one can never be sure about one until he's dead.

 

[Zack]

Vote: Zack Zack, IMO, is acting very suspicious. I don't see any scummy behavior in DaveShack and I'm a bit skeptical about Jarrema. Jarrema, what is your character name?

Arm of Suspicion: MartinLuther