JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Such a powerful reasoning, Nedim... 
KotOR Mafia - game thread
- Thread starter Takhisis
- Start date
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Such a powerful reasoning, Nedim...
Perfectly good reasoning. He's been terribly inactive, and needs to go.
Vote: TheBlackKnigh
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Oh, yes. But if you take a look at his post, no reasoning at all is no valid reason.
No, TheBlackKnigh is just a poor choice. First, your vote won't matter today because he won't be lynched, it's a distancing tactic at best. Second, what specific reason makes him a better choice than several bandwagoners like Red Spy, who have provided no reasons on their votes and on why they think townies should die over bounty hunters? Voting Buddhafish would of course be the best move for the town, he's darkside and a reasonable chance of being scum, but otherwise at least vote in a way you can be held accountable, like voting against me with the reasons as you understand them.
What people should see is that Winston is directly lying with a made up story. Look at my posts that he's lying about. I said nothing to him on Day 1. Night 1 another confirmed townie told me he was suspicious of Winston, and Winston has turned out to be a neutral criminal. Likewise, Zack was suspected by numerous townies before and besides me and by the next day scanned as darkside as was also made clear by a known townie. It's not just nonsense reasons that people were suspicious of either of them, even if part of the problem was abilities were misleading or wrong the reasons were given publicly.
If Winston is telling the whole truth about talking to Jarrema, and I doubt it but Jarrema never told me of hearing from Winston, it is his misfortune that was the only townie he talked to. Jarrema's dead and can't confirm anything about that, seems no other trustworthy townies can either, and now Winston's been harming the town. I can't stop him wagering his own life against mine but taking him out soon will still be the necessary move for the town as a neutral who can't be trusted.
Also,
I'm not sure if you simply mixed up the wrong name (maybe meant to say Mergle?), or are missing major relevant information entirely. Ninjacow has not claimed a scan result or anything like that, at all. So of course Ninja cannot be criticized for that, and he's not pushing the wrong bandwagon at all anymore which is another thing in his favor, but certainly don't go after him for something completely inaccurate.
What people should see is that Winston is directly lying with a made up story. Look at my posts that he's lying about. I said nothing to him on Day 1. Night 1 another confirmed townie told me he was suspicious of Winston, and Winston has turned out to be a neutral criminal. Likewise, Zack was suspected by numerous townies before and besides me and by the next day scanned as darkside as was also made clear by a known townie. It's not just nonsense reasons that people were suspicious of either of them, even if part of the problem was abilities were misleading or wrong the reasons were given publicly.
If Winston is telling the whole truth about talking to Jarrema, and I doubt it but Jarrema never told me of hearing from Winston, it is his misfortune that was the only townie he talked to. Jarrema's dead and can't confirm anything about that, seems no other trustworthy townies can either, and now Winston's been harming the town. I can't stop him wagering his own life against mine but taking him out soon will still be the necessary move for the town as a neutral who can't be trusted.
Also,
I'm not sure if you simply mixed up the wrong name (maybe meant to say Mergle?), or are missing major relevant information entirely. Ninjacow has not claimed a scan result or anything like that, at all. So of course Ninja cannot be criticized for that, and he's not pushing the wrong bandwagon at all anymore which is another thing in his favor, but certainly don't go after him for something completely inaccurate.
Mat93
Emperor
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,104
And now I'm listed as voting for someone I didn't vote for. Now it's slightly annoying.
On Winston's defence, again, if hes making backroom deals with townie, whats to say he isn't with scum as well. I know thats a bad reason to lynch him, but losing him working for us isn't the worst result we could possibly have. His claim is believable, but nothing that makes me say we should avoid lynching no matter what. I would prefer an Earthling or Buddha lynch over him.
Although now he has said he won't do a deal with the town, the scum will contact him, and we will probably have to lynch him later to stop him causing damage.
I don't think anyone is suggesting a lynch of Winston right now. That includes me, still strongly for Buddhafish and tomorrow I think we could do better than Winston, and since I do think he is neutral and not Sith, I agree it'd be too much of a waste of time and lynches the town needs.
I am recommending Winston is nightkilled or vigilante'd in any way a townie can organize. That's what should be effective and fairly simple because he shouldn't be defended against nightkills. Don't need a neutral continuing to give votes, or items, money, anything else in favor of the mafia.
I am recommending Winston is nightkilled or vigilante'd in any way a townie can organize. That's what should be effective and fairly simple because he shouldn't be defended against nightkills. Don't need a neutral continuing to give votes, or items, money, anything else in favor of the mafia.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Put a bounty on his head. 
OK, I'm back. And now I can tell you that Earthling has scanned lightside. If this lynch on him goes ahead, and he flips darkside, my scan info is not worth the electrons its written in - but assuming he flips light (and I have other reasons to believe the scan results I'm passing on here) you know the scan info on buddhafish is equally reliable. Also, guys, pay attention to how the votes went today. The sith may have been forced to show their hand in the Earthling votes. (Of course, disregard vote changes after this post as I've pointed it out).
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
We'll see how the Bhudda vote goes, then we'll see. But you're probably right.
dragonprobably
The Poster Formerly Known as MartinLuther
*reads the last couple of pages* Did I just accidently walk in to /b/?
Vote: Zack I'm not going to follow the 2 other ridiculous wagons. I have a feeling his scum buddies voted for Sam so he wouldn't be lynched. Plus his roleclaim is ridiculous. As for "I have someone who can prove I'm not scum" well why hasn't he spoke up. He can PM me if he feels like he would become a target. If he does, I'll repay him.
herpderp
Vote: Zack I'm not going to follow the 2 other ridiculous wagons. I have a feeling his scum buddies voted for Sam so he wouldn't be lynched. Plus his roleclaim is ridiculous. As for "I have someone who can prove I'm not scum" well why hasn't he spoke up. He can PM me if he feels like he would become a target. If he does, I'll repay him.
herpderp
Takhisis and I would prefer more than one post per phase and a vote every day from everyone please. Night actions are good, but posting is what makes the game!
johnhughthom
Emperor
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2009
- Messages
- 1,450
johnhughthom
Emperor
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2009
- Messages
- 1,450
Ah yes, the rules:
First rule is: The laws of Germany
Second rule is: Be nice to mommy
Third rule is: Don't talk to commies
Fourth rule is: Eat kosher salamis
Nothing there about Askthepizzaguy creating alts.
Dead guy spam = finished, doesn't want to pee off the hosts while replacements are being considered.
First rule is: The laws of Germany
Second rule is: Be nice to mommy
Third rule is: Don't talk to commies
Fourth rule is: Eat kosher salamis
Nothing there about Askthepizzaguy creating alts.
Dead guy spam = finished, doesn't want to pee off the hosts while replacements are being considered.
No one can talk to me?
Similar threads
