Leader depiction elimination thread

[LMT]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24 (23 + 1). Very serene addition to the leaders. Language, actions, overall nicely done.
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 10 (13 - 1). I honestly thought about picking someone different here. But to me, she is by far the most cartoonish of what's left. Even my kids make fun of her.
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[Ondolindë]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 29 (28+1) I feel I could tell him anything he's so trustworthy looking.
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7 (10-3) Why isn't she happier looking? These royals and their moods.
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[WillowBrook]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 17 (20 -3) very well made, but his very-pleased-with-you look is starting to annoy me in my current game
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 29
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 14 (13+1) my favorite umbrella-wielding queen needs some love

 

[Za01phod]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 17
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 30 (+1) Muy simpático. The first time I met him I had a hard time declaring war on him.
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 11 (-3) Depicted as a kind old lady, in fact one of the most intolerant and undemocratic women my country brought forth.

 

[The_Quasar]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 18 (+1) So well done, he seems one of the most realistic in many ways
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22 (-3) Mega-annoying, he makes me want to crush him most times he speaks
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 11

 

[Vasire]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 26 (25+1) A very expressive and articulate model for this leader
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 18
Lautaro - 20 (23-3) I may be missing the weight of symbology here but having a perfectly good sword and still carrying a big stone axe on your belt looks a bit stupid.
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 11

 

[Ozymandias9891]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18 - 3 = 15 He looks strange. I preferred Civ V Genghis better.
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 18
Lautaro - 20 + 1 = 21 Haven’t played as him yet, nor have I met him yet in any of my R&F games, but I love his music theme.
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 11

 

[Timodelphia]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 18
Lautaro - 20
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31 (30+1) Pretty much running away with this. Very well done overall.
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 8 (11-3) Too much Mary Poppins

 

[nzcamel]

Note: I normally vote 6-7 hours earlier than this, so my next vote will appear to be early.

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16 (15+1) I think this is the best portrayal of Temujin yet. Yeah...he may be a bit chubbier than is likely for a guy a who campaigned till he died - even one with large appetites; but other than that... A+
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 24
John Curtin - 15 (18-3) I suppose to be fair, most Prime Ministers (one obvious one aside) will always be dull entries in the series, as their role has come into existance in a world in which we want leaders who are constrained, and who are there on merit, which tends to cull plenty of eccentricity. So it's a good thing that you're MEH.
Lautaro - 21
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 8

Philip II - 11 - 3 = 8 Still don't know why he's stuck around as long as he has...

Cos he adds a lot of atmosphere to the game! Moreso than some of the blander leaders that remain...

 

[DWilson]

I'm pretty sure Cyrus should be at 18, as several pages back he was given a -1, rather than a -3.

 

[Wolle68]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 13 (12 + 1) - I love the Norse
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21 (24 - 3) - I just think he's way too smug
John Curtin - 15
Lautaro - 21
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 8
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 7
Wilhelmina - 8

I'm pretty sure Cyrus should be at 18, as several pages back he was given a -1, rather than a -3.

It was fixed in the post just following the mistake.

 

[KayAU]

I'm pretty sure Cyrus should be at 18, as several pages back he was given a -1, rather than a -3.

If you are referring to JonyDrake's post on page 9, that was fixed by the next poster.

EDIT: Woops, didn't get a notification that Wolle86 had posted before me. I have updated the scores below.

Today's vote from me:
Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 13
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 15
Lautaro - 21
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9 (8 + 1) I actually agree about many of the criticisms, but I still just like the way he looks.
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 22
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 4 (7 - 1) Treats me poorly, then acts all insulted and horrified at how terrible I am.
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[nzcamel]

I'm pretty sure Cyrus should be at 18, as several pages back he was given a -1, rather than a -3.

If you are referring to JonyDrake's post on page 9, that was fixed by the next poster.

I think KayAU is right cos in my spreadsheet Cyrus is on 20...

 

[Guandao]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - (13-3)=10 Portrayed as Pagan, when he actually was a Christian. Sometimes his expressions look stupid, like when you become friends with him.
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 15
Lautaro - 21
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - (22+1)=23 For his first portrayal in a Civ game, he seems great. Everything seems spot on about him.
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 4
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[Weraptor]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 10
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 15 - 3 = 12 To me, he seems a bit bland.
Lautaro - 21
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 23
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 4 + 1 = 5 C'mon. She isn't that bad.
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[JonyDrake]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 10
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 12
Lautaro - 21 + 1 = 22 / Love his theme.
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 23
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 5 - 3 = 2 / Begone England, the land belongs to scotts. Jokes aside I don't like her model.
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[Cooleatack]

Catherine de' Medici - 16 (15+1) I am also a fan of the language twists she uses, especially when she declares war.
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 10
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 12
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 23
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - ELIMINATED (2-3= -1) I bid you farewell Disney Queen.
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[Siptah]

Catherine de' Medici - 16
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 10
Hojo Tokimune - 30 (29+1) just for the look he gives you when you decline a trade offer
Jadwiga - 19 (22-3) I really dislike the way she looks (which is also not too close to the picture they used as reference). Her voice acting is one of the worst in the game. Her lines are neither very immersive, nor funny or cool.
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 12
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 9
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 23
Tomyris - 10
Wilhelmina - 8

 

[BrotherInJah]

STATS 2

After 174 (2 disallowed) votes here comes update on who you are and what you prefer..

But before that, please welcome new joiners:

Za01phod
The_Quasar
Wolle68

all three joined our game no more than 10 votes ago..

1. Chart.. i'll skip that, after that many entries it looks very chaotic..

2. Leader stats:

Most beloved ones according to your votes (TOP 5.. 7):

Spoiler :

[table=head]
leader|upvotes
Pou |14
Lau |11
Cat |10
Git |10
Cyr |9
Ama |9
Hoj |9
[/table]

R&F guys, both native american tribes are getting a lot of attention from you.

Leaders that we can't stand (Top 5.. 8 again due to ties)

Spoiler :

[table=head]
leader|downvotes
Ama |10
Phi |9
Cle |9
Tam |8
Mve |8
Gil |8
Fre |8
Vic |8
[/table]

Don't be fooled with Ama score.. just wait for combined score..

Most Popular

Spoiler :

[table=head]
leader|popular
Ama |19
Cat |16
Phi |15
Pou |15
Lau |14
Vic |14
[/table]

.. told you

Most pounded leaders (leaders with highest downvote streak)

Spoiler :

[table=head]
leader|dvstreak
Ale |4
Mve |3
Gan |3
[/table]

You all took your chance when opportunity came to take out Alex..

3. Voters stats

Most active voters

Spoiler :

[table=head]
voter|votes
Weraptor |11
Kimiimaro |11
Nzcamel |10
WillowBrook |9
Morningcalm |8
Katakanja |8
[/table]

Blood thirst voters (leader was left with less than 5 point after dvote)

Spoiler :

[table=head]
voter|bloodthirst
Kimiimaro |7
KayAU |6
God of Kings |4
JonyDrake |3
Weraptor |3
Guandao |3
[/table]

Pay attention to third place.. as all 4 of his near end blows where final ones..what's wrong with you..?

(as final blow list looks like this, there is God of Kings on top and then 12 ties i have combined both cathegories.. thanks God, and again what's wrong with you?)

Savior (upvote leader which hat less than 5 points before that vote)

Spoiler :

[table=head]
voter|savior
Weraptor |3
Conorbebe |1
Nzcamel |1

[/table]

and bonus stat..

Spoiler :

who have affection to whom (only most active)

Weraptor
Cyr

Kimiimaro
Cyr

Nzcamel
Cle (4.. can't blame)

WillowBrook
Wil

Morningcalm
Joh (4 upvotes.. hmm..)

 

[LMT]

Thanks for the stats, now back to it...

Catherine de' Medici - 17 (16 + 1). Yes, her "games" statement can be a bit annoying, but overall, I like the mischievous looks she gives you.
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 16
Gitarja - 26
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 10
Hojo Tokimune - 30
Jadwiga - 19
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 12
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 31
Robert the Bruce - 6 (9 - 3). Reminds me a bit too much of a cartoon version of Fat Bastard from Austin Powers.
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 23
Tomyris - 10
Wilhelmina - 8