Leader depiction elimination thread

[Guandao]

Amanitore - 8
Catherine de' Medici - 13
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 24
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Mvemba a Nzinga - 1-3=0 Eliminated! I don't mind his look (it was either this or a more European style garb, which could tick off certain people). It's mainly his/and Kongo's portrayal as being incapable of founding a religion I have some issue with. Plus the leader background portrays Mbanza Kongo as some flimsy huts in a swamp....
Peter the Great - 24
Philip II - 13
Poundmaker - 29
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - (20+1)=21 I liked how they modeled his facial appearance on his Zulu miniseries actor. I prefer his clean shaven look over the bearded look they gave him in Civ5. And he laughs sometimes too.
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 15

 

[Victoria]

Amanitore - 8
Catherine de' Medici - 13
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 24
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 24
Philip II - 10 (-3) - ****
Poundmaker - 30 (+1) - looks a lot like eagle pursuit
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 15

 

[WillowBrook]

Amanitore - 8
Catherine de' Medici - 13
Chandragupta Maurya - 21+1=22 The only gorgeous model I haven't up-voted yet.
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 24
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 24 - 3 = 21 His animations do give him personality, but he doesn't deserve to be nearly as high as he is atm.
Philip II - 10
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 15

 

[Mr.JamblesAlpha]

Amanitore - 8 -3 = 5 ( I don't like how she insults me when her city look like **** and I have like 5 wounder and 6 districts in like 4 of my cites and it is not even the info era)
Catherine de' Medici - 13
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 24+1 = 25 ( I just love everything about this model + the civ is perfect for my play style.)
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 10
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 15

 

[Vasire]

Amanitore - 2 (5-3) For some reason I always feel like she has got it in for me.
Catherine de' Medici - 14 (13+1) I just love it when she is happy with my spies.
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 10
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 15

 

[nzcamel]

Amanitore - 2
Catherine de' Medici - 14
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11 (10+1) His barely hidden contempt for any belief not of his own adds plenty of flavour to the game
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 12 (15-3) She's a tough old competition... Wilhe just isn't as good as the rest.

Mvemba a Nzinga - 1-3=0 Eliminated! I don't mind his look (it was either this or a more European style garb, which could tick off certain people). It's mainly his/and Kongo's portrayal as being incapable of founding a religion I have some issue with. Plus the leader background portrays Mbanza Kongo as some flimsy huts in a swamp....

Shaka - (20+1)=21 I liked how they modeled his facial appearance on his Zulu miniseries actor. I prefer his clean shaven look over the bearded look they gave him in Civ5. And he laughs sometimes too.

Yeah, I think they were on a hiding to nothing with Mvemba no matter how they portrayed him.
Did Shaka have facial hair!? Shows how little I played V...

Poundmaker - 30 (+1) - looks a lot like eagle pursuit

Eagle used to be much more chubby n Teddy-ish

 

[Liufeng]

Amanitore - 2
Catherine de' Medici - 14
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 22 + 1 = 22 Young and intrepid, he's exactly how I would have imagined him. Much more than Alexander, he truly represent the young hero in this game !
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11
Poundmaker - 30
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 14 - 3 = 11 I don't mind Saladin at all, but he should have been chosen if the goal was to make a warmonger Arabia. The historic Saladin, as pious as he was, doesn't reflect at all his agenda (as he was very tolerant towards other religions), and he was no cultural/scientific leader (not more than the others at least).
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 12

 

[Lord Lakely]

Amanitore - 2
Catherine de' Medici - 14
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11
Poundmaker - 27 (30-3) this is largely to make the playing field more competitive
Robert the Bruce - 14
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13 (12+1) I don't know what you've all been smoking, this is easily the best designed leader. *smacks half this board around with a parasol*

 

[Morningcalm]

Amanitore - 2
Catherine de' Medici - 14 + 1 = 15 (Perfectly embodies a stylized version of the real queen, complete with some Italian-accented French and references to Nostradamus (one of her favorites) and her Flying Squadron), even if her face doesn't exactly match historical paintings of her.
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15 (Gr, represented as a typical Viking pagan when in reality he was a Christian member of the Byzantine Varangian Guard before Stamford Bridge. And he looks foolish rather than fearsome.)
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11
Poundmaker - 27
Robert the Bruce - 14 - 3 = 11 (Among the worst voice actors in the game, with a strange agenda that doesn't connect historically)
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[God of Kings]

Amanitore - 2 - 3 = ELIMINATED Her agenda is not as consistent in practice and her voice actor isn't fluent in her language
Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 18 + 1 = 19 Excellent design
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11
Poundmaker - 27
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[Ozymandias9891]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 19
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 11 - 3 = 8 Still don't know why he's stuck around as long as he has...
Poundmaker - 27 + 1 = 28 Started a game as him this past weeked and I'm nearing the end now. Must say, I love his trade route abilities, unique improvement, and unique scouts. So much fun to play as.
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[Weraptor]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 19 + 1 = 20 Want some wine, Tomyris? Great model and personality, which may or may not be accurate, although he is more stylised in the game of course.
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 8
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10 - 3 = 7 She doesn't stand up to the others here
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[nzcamel]

Next person to vote, please add Poundmaker - 28 back into the list. Ta.

 

[Kimiimaro]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21+1=22 - I just love the laguage and his fancy golden pants He's also well animated.
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 8-3=5 - Tomyris must not fall before Philip II with oversized hands who loves to scream and swing his sword furiously despite being known as a calm person.
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 7
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[BenitoChavez]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 28 + 1 = 29. Samurai are awesome
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 22
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 5
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 21 - 3 = 18. I still think his back is weird.
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 7
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[JH24]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 22
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 5
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 18 - 3 = 15 Nothing against Shaka, but the design of his face stands out to me, and not in a good way.
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 7 + 1 = 8 like her design, lighting and the general atmosphere.
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[KayAU]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 23 (22 + 1) I like both his appearance and his voice.
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - 2 (5 -3) Stop waving that thing around, you're going to put your eye out!
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 8
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[kaspergm]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 15
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 23
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Philip II - ELIMINATED (2-3) ... I agree, his hissy fits seem stupid.
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 9 (8+1) ... I think she is quite well made, one of the best original leaders.
Victoria - 13
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[BrotherInJah]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12 (15-3) crossy eyes, small head.. all those year wearing undersized helmet leave their marks
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22 (21+1) you should be higher than most of these males.. you are the king..!
Jayavarman VII - 23
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 11
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 9
Victoria - 13 - i will spank you next time young lady..
Wilhelmina - 13

 

[earlc]

Catherine de' Medici - 15
Chandragupta Maurya - 22
Cyrus the Great - 20
Genghis Khan - 18
Gitarja - 25
Gorgo - 22
Harald Hardrada - 12
Hojo Tokimune - 29
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 23
John Curtin - 20
Lautaro - 23
Peter the Great - 21
Poundmaker - 28
Robert the Bruce - 8 (11-3) only one left besides Harald who's hard to look at
Saladin - 11
Seondeok - 21
Shaka - 15
Teddy Roosevelt - 25
Tomyris - 10 (9+1) Seems fine, too low on the list. I see the contradictory agenda more as a problem with the joint-war mechanic than how she's intended to be portrayed.
Victoria - 13.
Wilhelmina - 13