Mafia Game: Monty Python and the Holy Grail (GAME THREAD)

[Askthepizzaguy]

TheLastOne36: 7 (cindle, Pinman, civplayah, CCRunner, Nictel, oyzar, choxorn)
ZPV: 3 (Stuck in Pi, Love, Renata)
oyzar: 3 (Snerk, TheLastone, Winston Hughes)
Stuck in Pi: 1 (ZPV)
Catharsis: 1 (Sprig)
Cindle: 1 (Izipo)


Abstain: Sithlord447



Not everyone has voted, far from it actually. More participation please. Round extended until 10PM tomorrow (GMT-5)

 

[Sprig]

"Far too quiet, Even the Ghost are louder than the living!

OOC: I thought Ghosts could still vote or can they not?

 

[Seon]

I think they need special ability...

I still say that OYZAR did it!!!

 

[TheLastOne36]

Im warning you all, it would be a terrible start to the game if you vote me.

 

[CCRunner]

Why is that, exactly? And I mean exactly if you want any chance of not being lynched. Ability, goal, role name, everything if you want a chance of not being lynched now

 

[TheLastOne36]

Why is that, exactly? And I mean exactly if you want any chance of not being lynched. Ability, goal, role name, everything if you want a chance of not being lynched now

If i'm someone special and I told you guys, there would be not point as I'd just be killed by the dark knights during the night. And to be honest, i'd rather die in honor to the hands of my fellow knights than to some dark sorcerer.

What time does this round end btw? maybe i'll say something last minute.(as in last hour)

 

[rhawn]

Vote: Oyzar

 

[choxorn]

Okay, fine, TLO didn't turn me into a newt, and I don't know who did. In case he's telling the truth and we're screwed if we kill him, I unvote: TheLastOne36, Vote: Oyzar.

 

[Camikaze]

It's not oyzar. I know that for a fact.

Vote: TheLastOne36
Better a doubtful bandwagon than a plain wrong one.

 

[ZPV]

Hope this makes sense; I'm still rushed:

Yesterday, I happened to learn the identity of King Arthur in this game. At the same time, I was speaking with ZPV on MSN, and he asked me if I knew who King Arthur was. Stupidly, I said yes, that I had just learned (though at least I didn't say who). Seon was among those on MSN around the time that ZPV and I were talking (also oyzar and Pinman, IIRC). Sorry to all three of you for setting you up for bait, but I decided not to go back and correct the obvious interpretation: that King Arthur might be someone I could have been talking with on MSN. (For the record: I do also use PMs.)

Then Seon wound up dead. Care to explain why you were fishing for King Arthur's identity, ZPV?

vote: ZPV

Well, I didn't make that connection of KA being online at the time - I think you're misrepresenting the temporality of what you said (although I need to look up the exact quote to confirm this). Why fish for his identity? Because I always fish for something, and it seemed like a reasonable thing for you to know.

btw, there was never any question in my mind of Seon's being King Arthur - it wasn't even an important point to me - although I don't have anything to back this up.

 

[PaulusIII]

If i'm someone special and I told you guys, there would be not point as I'd just be killed by the dark knights during the night. And to be honest, i'd rather die in honor to the hands of my fellow knights than to some dark sorcerer.

What time does this round end btw? maybe i'll say something last minute.(as in last hour)

So in other words, we'll not get any hints to your innocence other than your word. That's not good enough for me. You're still looking suspicious.

vote: TheLastOne36

 

[CCRunner]

If i'm someone special and I told you guys, there would be not point as I'd just be killed by the dark knights during the night. And to be honest, i'd rather die in honor to the hands of my fellow knights than to some dark sorcerer.

What time does this round end btw? maybe i'll say something last minute.(as in last hour)

You've already said enough about yourself for most people to target you at night-- if you even make it that far. So as I see it, your choices are tell us everything and hope for both mercy and the existence of somebody with a protection ability or get lynched.

I think the round ends 24 hours from pizzaguy's tally. Around that time at least

 

[Sprig]

"Waste of time voting for this TheLastOne. He is no more special than a lump of coal and you will only further the baddies goal by lynching him."

"Wouldn't surprise me if it was the bad guys organising this lynch mob"

 

[Catharsis]

Not everyone has voted, far from it actually. More participation please. Round extended until 10PM tomorrow (GMT-5)

OOC: Sorry for my inactivity, the router broke and I was knocked offline for a couple of days. I'll attempt to read through this properly after I look at some other stuff like EPYC.

 

[choxorn]

It's not oyzar. I know that for a fact.

How do you know?

 

[Renata]

Good question.

So what's the situation? We have TheLostOne leading the vote with a vague claim of being a powerful role, but flat out refusing to clarify the situation until, just possibly, one hour before sunset, at which point it will likely be too late to change anything. This despite plarq's unfortunate example from the day before. I'll withhold judgment for a few more hours.

Next is oyzar. I give Seon little credence for knowing what he's talking about, but I don't dismiss Winston's vote as easily as I did yesterday, not now that a less-active player has turned up to defend oyzar right on the heels of oyzar discouraging votes against less-active players. Judgment withheld on this one for now as well, pending a reasonable (or not so reasonable) explanation.

For now my vote stays on ZPV. I'm not mis-representing anything. ZPV did ask if I knew who King Arthur was, and my response was "yeah, he just told me".

 

[Catharsis]

I'm going to follow Izipo's lead and say that the aroma thing in the writeup might be a clue pointing at cindle. Vote: cindle

TLO36, the problem with what you say is that if you reveal your story/role/etc. and it seems plausible, then we get to pick another player to lynch, and the baddies' hands are forced into killing you at night instead of some other player of their choice. You die either way, but this way gives a slight advantage to the innocents, whereas the other way gives a slight advantage to the baddies.

And if you don't feel like revealing everything to the whole thread then you could PM someone you trust (which you may already have done) but if your innocence is confirmed by another player then there's nothing to stop that person being one of your baddie colleagues, so the evidence is not as tight.

Either way, dying in silence is not a good idea (see reference: plarq) and I'm not surprised that people are still voting for you at the moment.

 

[Renata]

Well put.

 

[TheLastOne36]

TheLastOne36: 7 (cindle, Pinman, civplayah, CCRunner, Nictel, oyzar, choxorn, Paulles, Camikaze)

I believe the black knights have ganged up on me, for an easy lynch, and one or more of them are the ones listed above.

Cindle has the Aroma reference. Pinman i don't think is the mafia following yesterday's event's. This leaves Civplayah, CCRunner, Nictel, Choxorn, Camikaze, PaulesIII and Oyzar.

Seon says Oyzar is also a mafia.

 

[Snerk]

Yeah mafias often rally up under the same bandwagon, specially if one of their own has any votes. If TLO is innocent then i suspect the mafia would join that bandwagon. So I agree that we should perhaps lynch Oyzar.