Mafia Game: Monty Python and the Holy Grail (GAME THREAD)

[Renata]

And still no role claim, TLO? Did you read Catharsis's post?

 

[hell_hound]

As it was mentioned before (by Renata I believe) If you tell us your role it is more than likely in a game of this size somone will have a protection ability of some sort to defend you with if you are so vitally important.

Also I can understand the vague reference and reason for lynching Cindle, but what reason do we have for lynching Oyzar other that Seon wanting it to happen?

For the mean time Vote:TLO

 

[TheLastOne36]

Yeah mafias often rally up under the same bandwagon, specially if one of their own has any votes. If TLO is innocent then i suspect the mafia would join that bandwagon. So I agree that we should perhaps lynch Oyzar.

Finally someone with some sense.

We should start with Oyzar i guess, but I think we have a list of potential Mafias in this game already. It'd be best if you start voting them off one by one.

 

[TheLastOne36]

Unvote: Oyzar

Vote: Nictel

I believe Oyzar's voting is completely wrong and Seon was mad.

Going through the list of people who voted against me, I will pick Nictel as he has been fairly silent.

 

[Pinman]

I honestly think TLO is about to come up guilty.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

TheLastOne36: 9 (cindle, Pinman, civplayah, CCRunner, Nictel, oyzar, Camikaze, PaulusIII, hell_hound)
oyzar: 4 (Snerk, Winston Hughes, rhawn, choxorn)
ZPV: 3 (Stuck in Pi, Love, Renata)
Cindle: 2 (Izipo, Catharsis)
Stuck in Pi: 1 (ZPV)
Catharsis: 1 (Sprig)
Nictel: 1 (TheLastone)

Abstain: Sithlord447


See any errors? Only 21 are voting out of 26 living players.

 

[Catharsis]

Only 21 are voting out of 26 living players.

80% participation? A lot of NotW GMs would kill for that level of commitment.

 

[Izipo]

Indeed, that's pretty good.
On with the show now, is TLO guilty or what ?

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

80% participation? A lot of NotW GMs would kill for that level of commitment.

I'm a GM who kills for that level of commitment. As in... wrath of God.... giant foot stomping the inactive players.

I so enjoy death. Be sure to vote...

*sharpens his giant war axe*

 

[Renata]

I knew I liked you for a reason. And I noticed you didn't count the abstention as a vote, either.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Agh, actually the abstention counts as a vote. 22 players voting, then.

It's up to the town to be evil towards abstainers, not the host.

 

[sithlord447]

As it was mentioned before (by Renata I believe) If you tell us your role it is more than likely in a game of this size somone will have a protection ability of some sort to defend you with if you are so vitally important.

Also I can understand the vague reference and reason for lynching Cindle, but what reason do we have for lynching Oyzar other that Seon wanting it to happen?

For the mean time Vote:TLO

i can't say i like bandwagoning and snerk said it good bandwagoning is usally a pretty scumy thing to do

so vote:hell hound

 

[Snerk]

Maybe Seon knows something we don't? And if Oyzar turns out to be innocent, then at least we'll know that we can safely ignore anything Seon says.

 

[Sprig]

i can't say i like bandwagoning and snerk said it good bandwagoning is usally a pretty scumy thing to do

so vote:hell hound

"Following this, I would have thought the first death last night sounded like a hell_hound had attacked him."

OOC: Could be just the GM style though.


"Regarding TheLastOne, I have spoken to him and the chances of him being an innocent are rather remote. He claimed to be special and when challenged and offered protection he had nothing to say for it."

Unvote, Vote: TheLastOne

 

[civplayah]

Where did it say anything about an aroma?

There are a lot of references to birds in the writeup.

Hand me that chicken

the one with feathers

empty-headed animal food trough wipers

the Knights of the Round table were in a foul(fowl) mood

Reviewing the player list, I saw no players referring to birds, let alone any animals, except for taillesskanguru and Cubsfan.

Just some info. I'm not accusing them yet, though.

 

[hell_hound]

Reviewing the player list, I saw no players referring to birds, let alone any animals, except for taillesskanguru and Cubsfan.

Just some info. I'm not accusing them yet, though.

Well Catharsis has a bird for his avatar, and to be honest I had not noticed all that until you pointed it out

 

[Backwards Logic]

Let's see, we have the aroma reference which more than likely points to cindle, the ghost Seon screaming it was oyzar yet giving no reason why (unless he can't) and TLO acting all defensive and claiming to be someone important yet not extrapolating any. I'm going to go with the write-up clue and say it was cindle (vote: cindle). I have no idea what to make of TLO, though he's either overly paranoid or overly guilty or maybe just perhaps a little of both.

 

[civplayah]

Catharsis, do you have anything to say?

 

[Renata]

The last is my guess. He told me his role. If he told anyone else, please contact me ASAP provided you know what I mean by "favorite". I'm still undecided whether to just spill everything he's told me -- it feels like that should be his prerogative, or not. I'd appreciate feedback if anyone else has the information.

My best guess is he's telling me the truth about his role, but I don't believe he's allied with England. I think he's strictly neutral, and that neither major group (Town, Knights) can win while he's still alive, though either might conceivably benefit from (or be hurt by) his presence in the meantime.

Do what you want with that.

 

[Catharsis]

Catharsis, do you have anything to say?

Not really: you have a point. I do have a bird in my avatar (not a chicken though, it's the majestic Great Grey Shrike). But I would point out that the first two quotes you cited are effectively only one quote (they both refer to the same chicken), the third one is an actual quote from Monty Python (I Googled it) and the fourth one is just stretching, come on now. Also, they're all in the lynching post and not the morning one. And in Chainsaw Gang, all the clues that ATPG did were related to posters' names, not their avatars (hence aroma -> cindle).

However, that does mean that there is one bird reference in the write-up, which matches the one reference to aroma (it's in the writeup of cubsfan's murder) that suggests cindle as a suspect. So I'm happy to concede that I should be held under the same degree of suspicion as cindle. (I'm not removing my vote, though, because I'm not convinced about TLO or any of the other options presented today, and let's face it, cindle isn't in any danger at the moment. And I don't want to not vote.)