Mafia Game: Monty Python and the Holy Grail (GAME THREAD)

[Renata]

One question (actually, I have more than one question): Didn't Renata earlier claim to know who King Arthur was? It would be pretty helpful if she would elucidate her thoughts slightly more...

There's not much to say; I'd have thought you'd all guess without me saying anything.

Love came to me back on Day One claiming to be King Arthur, with a protective ability, exactly as he has explained here. I have no reason to think he's lying. oyzar seemed to imply he had trouble believing there might be two people in the game with protective abilities, but with three attacks every night, I don't find that particularly odd.

I know I'm ignoring a lot of potential clues toward Love, but I find them less convincing than my own knowledge of how Love plays the game, particularly as the clues themselves are so scattered all over the place -- they've been pointed out in segments referring to all three attackers!

If he gets lynched and I'm wrong ... oh well.

 

[Izipo]

A chicken I have on my crest, but vicious I am not. As evidenced here.

I stated this way back when my faithful minstrel died, and not even Sprig tried to claim he was Sir Robin too.

 

[Catharsis]

I love it. I mention one thing that looks eerily like a positive clue, Camikaze writes a friggin' book about pretty much the same thing, Love comes out and says he King Arthur and suddenly I'm the bad guy here. I'd argue my one clue was better than Camikaze's entire list and to me the length and dubious content of it is suspicious. With this revelation of Love as King Arthur I'll certainly retract my accusation of Love (unvote: Love). Sure, the word electric had been used oddly in an instance or two but it's no different than the bird evidence against (vote: ) Catharsis. You said you were going to vote against me anyway and I'd wager the evidence against you is more damning then what's against me. I heard you're French - last I checked they were against England, no?

It's not like the 'electric' references are the only evidence against you - your inactivity, while not your fault, counts against you, and then there are the two points oyzar brought up in post #438. Plus, the fact that you seem to be trying to play it as if the 'electric' references were the only evidence against you.

The 'bird' references carry the same weight as the 'electric' ones, that is correct, but as far as I know, the only other evidence against my name is that sprig thinks I'm French. Now, the French guy got killed this morning, and it was cindle, and I voted to lynch cindle - in fact, I was the second person to vote for him on that day, so you could call me the bandwagon-starter (had a bandwagon actually started, but TLO was just being too shifty on that day, I guess).

Oh, and by the way, nice work with establishing a relatively late bandwagon, Catharsis, Izipo and Nictel.

'Relatively late'? Halfway through the first day (real-life day) counts as 'relatively late'?

I stated this way back when my faithful minstrel died, and not even Sprig tried to claim he was Sir Robin too.

Why did you state this so early? There really wasn't any reason to do so, and it only puts you in more danger if you're innocent.

According to wiki, Sir Robin 'almost stood against the vicious chicken of Bristol'. Well, what's to stop the chicken from devouring him and stealing his identity, is what I want to know. If anyone can be imitated by a chicken, it's Sir Robin.

 

[Backwards Logic]

Vote:Backwards Logic have yet to explain himself to me, neither in private, when confronted with the same accusation I had against Civgeneral, nor now publicly in the thread.

Actually I did, remember? You came to me on MSN asked if I were the reason for the extension and I told you I had no night time abilities that would have caused the delay. You never asked anything else further and I felt no reason to go on.

Backwards Logic claim of a clue against Love is silly. That is obviously taken straight from the movie.

It's in the thread, is it not? Could a connection not be made? I felt it was the closest thing out there where a definitive deduction could be made. I took a chance and happened to step on the landmine that is the identity of King Arthur. Now I get penalized.

I have something to propose which you all may or may not agree with. We all know Sprig is a pain which if killed would help alleviate some of the misinformation that's going around. With his desire it seems to go into a duel with one of us and claiming to only be able to be defeated by certain people, I suspect he's the Black Knight, the one who challenged King Arthur to a duel and not only lost the battle but all of his limbs as well.

Why not pit these two in battle? In the movie King Arthur defeats the Black Knight and I would highly suspect he can do the same here. We know Love is King Arthur and we know Sprig is a pain, so what do we have to lose? We either kill Sprig through battle, or we expose a liar in Love. Seems like a win-win to me. Does anyone else think this is a good idea?

 

[Sprig]

"You logic is backwards- I Love It." "But yeah i would love to challenge Love to a duel and show you who is the true king. I am also gussing by your statement that Love must be the Black Knight"

"Woot Woot - bring it on! I'll kick your arse again!"

 

[Love]

Come on you filthy Frenchman!

 

[Sprig]

I AM THE KING im not french you douche!

 

[Sprig]

Update (someone should probably double check.)

Sprig: 1 (PaulusIII)
Catharsis: 1 (Backwards Logic)
Love: 5 (Pinman, Camikaze, sprig, Snerk, Nictel)
Backwards Logic: 8 (Love, Catharsis, Izipo, , Renata, Double A, CCRunner, Sithlord, oyzar)

Abstain/Not Voting: Tasslehoff, hell hound (second in a row), ZPV, choxorn.

 

[hell_hound]

Sprig is unable to count

Vote: Sprig

 

[choxorn]

Actually, that tally was correct.

Anyway, for lack of a better choice, I vote sprig.

 

[Pinman]

Let it stand then.

I think it will turn out badly, but let it stand.

 

[Double A]

unvote, vote: Sprig

He's probably mafia or French. At the very least we can get him to shut up for a bit.

 

[Nictel]

I'm confused. Can't we just lynch all three?

 

[Seon]

Ghost Comments:Methinks we should lynch everyone except for the king. THEN we would know if we got all of them or not.

 

[Nictel]

But we have two kings now...

 

[Double A]

Double lynch!

 

[Sprig]

Better yet if Love, Backwards Logic and I all tie for votes we can have a battle royal !!


Sprig: 4 (PaulusIII, hell hound, choxorn, Double A)
Catharsis: 1 (Backwards Logic)
Love: 5 (Pinman, Camikaze, sprig, Snerk, Nictel)
Backwards Logic: 7 (Love, Catharsis, Izipo, Renata, CCRunner, Sithlord, oyzar)

Abstain/Not Voting: Tasslehoff, ZPV,

 

[sithlord447]

i do think sprig is the black night so perhaps he is not lying and that he can only be killed by arthur anyway if that is true love needs to vote sprig

anyway unvote:backwards logic vote:sprig

 

[Sprig]

Love - Vote for that French man Catharsis and let the battle commence.

 

[choxorn]

Hell, anyone just has to unvote Backwards and vote someone aside from Love or sprig and the Battle will commence.