Mafia: The League of EEEEEVIL!!! [Game Thread - Concluded]

[Jarrema]

Worst. Vote. Ever. There's no basis for it. As Azzaman explained, out of all of the lurkers, Visor is the most understandable, having subbed in last. He/She is also injured. If past games like SW vs. LOTR are anything to go by, injured people cannot use their abilities anyways. No evidence is given, not even the barest "your a lurker, you die now" comment. fos: Jaremma. Explain yourself.

I didnt have opportunity to vote for him day one, that explains everything

Spoiler :

I always vote for him. This vote is nothing more than a placeholder. I am at my family house and have no time for thinking now, I will vote for a case someone else made

 

[Kennigit]

my placeholder is the vote: autolycus. That's fair; our lynches have been incorrect--or at the very least, kim possible has not been a leading candidate yet (unless civgeneral was a possibility)-- so the main mafia team would have been pretty free to just vote for whatever and let the townies bicker amongst themselves.

nothing really distinguishes autolycus from civgeneral or other inactives though, but that's a fine start.

 

[azzaman333]

Another thing I don't really like is that when I informed you of my buletproofness, there were two people trying to kill me. One of them was probably the robot. The other though is unclear. BTW there were, at that point, three people being targeted with kills, none of which included neverwon (should I reveal who the third intended victim of earlier tonight was?). Since then, one of the people targeting me switched off, and neverwon got targeted (and Azule, along with the second intended victim of earlier in the night went missing).

So, if I've got this right, you were targeted by two killers, and another mystery person (I reckon it'd be good to know who) was targeted by one killer. One of the killers targeting you stayed on you, one of the killers moved to neverwon, and the third killer did not kill.

Sounds like the 3rd killer, Azula, was roleblocked.

 

[Zack]

Kennigit was one of very few people who actually asked me about neverwon after I announced that I knew his/her ability in thread. I responded honestly. Neverwon was then killed by the mafia, one of the people targeting me stopped doing so, and the mafia killed tonight. vote: Kennigit though I think that people who have more info about Azule (most importantly, whether he/she targeted me early tonight) have a clearer picture of the situation than I do.

This is meaningless, Neverwonagame roleclaimed publicly.

 

[BSmith1068]

Azula was blocked. I would share who the other target was.

 

[spaceman98]

Azula was blocked. I would share who the other target was.

BTW, this confirms that the other killer targeting me was Kim Possible and she switched to neverwon, after I told Kennigit I was bulletproof. Yet more reason IMO to suspect that Kennigit is mafia.

 

[Takhisis]

Over the last few days, I have been in communication with claimed doublevoter Kennigit. In private, he/she confirmed the claim of doublevoter (keep in mind that this is an utterly untestable ability).

Not so untestable. In my games, it always shows up. It's pointless to ask the GM whether Kennigit's claim is true or not, but I think that it would show. It doesn't, however, neither in mid-day tallies nor in the updates.
It is also a very curious case of a claim for a day ability so that he doesn't get tracked, watched or blocked at night -has anyone targeted him at all?

my placeholder is the vote: autolycus. That's fair; our lynches have been incorrect--or at the very least, kim possible has not been a leading candidate yet (unless civgeneral was a possibility)-- so the main mafia team would have been pretty free to just vote for whatever and let the townies bicker amongst themselves.

nothing really distinguishes autolycus from civgeneral or other inactives though, but that's a fine start.

Care to explain why you're suddenly taking someone else to the lead instead of making a case on someone, or trying to refute the one made on you, Kennigit?

 

[Takhisis]

This would be the tally, if my party-addled brain is working properly:

Autolycus: azzaman333; Kennigit
Visorslash: Jarrema
Kennigit: spaceman98; Takhisis​

If Kennigit's a double-voter, why would he suddenly make it 3-1 on a lurker?

 

[azzaman333]

Spaceman, is there a reason you're only sharing the other target privately rather than publicly?

 

[Sprig]

BTW, this confirms that the other killer targeting me was Kim Possible and she switched to neverwon, after I told Kennigit I was bulletproof. Yet more reason IMO to suspect that Kennigit is mafia.

No, it doesn't at all. All it confirms is: who ever the Robot guy is, he is awesome!

Both Vig (if Robot guy is vig) were targeting you. Clearly Kim Possible switched from the undisclosed target to Neverwon.

 

[Sprig]

So, if I've got this right, you were targeted by two killers, and another mystery person (I reckon it'd be good to know who) was targeted by one killer. One of the killers targeting you stayed on you, one of the killers moved to neverwon, and the third killer did not kill.

Sounds like the 3rd killer, Azula, was roleblocked.

No, for clarification:

- Robot guy and Azula targeted Spaceman.

- Kim Possible targeted other person.

- Both robot guy and Azula kept on target and Kim Switched



What ticks me off, is that Neverwon was't protected in anyway... Tailess should have bussed him away to safety.

 

[Sprig]

and for third post in a row... Vote: CivGeneral

 

[spaceman98]

Spaceman, is there a reason you're only sharing the other target privately rather than publicly?

Because I wasn't sure if it was a good idea for the target to know that he or she was being targeted, given that I thought that the target might have been the intended victim of a vige. However, sprig's latest post explains things. Taillesskangaru, you were the target.

As to Kennigit, while Sprig's comments remove some suspicion from him, the fact remains that, as Takhisis pointed out, his/her claim is all too convenient, and his night behavior still seems bizarre/inconsistent to me. Does anyone know what Choxorn's usual policy on doublevoters in tallies is?

 

[Kennigit]

Tally:
John doe 6 votes (jack, jon, joel, johan, jj, jim)
Jane doe 6 votes (jill, jackie, jamie, jenna, jan, jean)

But little does everyone know jamie is a [double voter] [ tiebreaker] [jamie made jims vote invalid] so jane is lyched!

Said no update/public tally ever

 

[Takhisis]

What the hell? Are you equating double voters with tiebreakers? They're quite different.

 

[choxorn]

Does anyone know what Choxorn's usual policy on doublevoters in tallies is?

They don't show up in my tallies.

 

[Jarrema]

well, in that case
unvote; vote: Kennigit

 

[Darth Feather]

There is a way though, how a doublevoter may show up. Suppose it is

John doe 6 votes (jack, jon, joel, johan, jj, jim)
Jane doe 5 votes (jill, jackie, jamie, jenna, jan)

But Jamie the double-voter makes it a tie. A random tiebreaking method lynches Jane: There is a double voter amongst them.

 

[Sprig]

Unvote; Vote: Jareema you know because, that tally thing... and your vote sucks again...
I hope you got some tricks up your sleave!

 

[azzaman333]

No, for clarification:

- Robot guy and Azula targeted Spaceman.

- Kim Possible targeted other person.

- Both robot guy and Azula kept on target and Kim Switched



What ticks me off, is that Neverwon was't protected in anyway... Tailess should have bussed him away to safety.

How do you know Azula stayed on spaceman?