MNOTW XV: The Academy Game Thread
- Thread starter Autolycus
- Start date
KaiserElectric
Total Freakin Besties
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2007
- Messages
- 3,461
Zack said:
Yeah, that's solid reasoning.
vote: Zack
Zack
99% hot gas
The implication being "OMGUS" is solid reasoning?
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
what other scan results do you have zack?
Do you know if he is an orc specifically or darkalliance as we all suspect? Kaiser will die in 1 or 2 nights without our lynch attempt, and we can speed up that process sooner.
He has lost -1 brawn and will lose -1 brawn tonight, and we can make that into -2 brawn (for a total of -3 brawn). A dark alliance probably shouldn't have more than 3 brawn.
And if he is an orc he can lose -5 brawn in 2 nights from now.
Just a possibility.
Do you know if he is an orc specifically or darkalliance as we all suspect? Kaiser will die in 1 or 2 nights without our lynch attempt, and we can speed up that process sooner.
He has lost -1 brawn and will lose -1 brawn tonight, and we can make that into -2 brawn (for a total of -3 brawn). A dark alliance probably shouldn't have more than 3 brawn.
And if he is an orc he can lose -5 brawn in 2 nights from now.
Just a possibility.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
as well as throw in whatever mystery attacker is claimed to attack dreadnought, since that person must do at least -1 or -2 brawn and can choose to use it on kaiser.
All these abilities are worthless vs orcs as orcs will have like 4 or 5 brawn (or at least should), and I personally don't want to waste a lynch on a dark alliance if we can just kill him ourselves (whcih we can and are doing).
All these abilities are worthless vs orcs as orcs will have like 4 or 5 brawn (or at least should), and I personally don't want to waste a lynch on a dark alliance if we can just kill him ourselves (whcih we can and are doing).
Zack
99% hot gas
dude, how do you know so much about the game's setup
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
well everything about respective brawn is an assumption. I discussed stuff with mergle and stuff with BSmith, but then both of them had to go die on me.
The mergle information is pretty much public, but I can add a tiny bit more (my thoughts previously):
there are 2 claimed brawn attacks (one is successfully used and will automatically continue on kaiserelectric; a magical "decay" attack), with the other being able to be implemented as well on kaiser if need be.
neither of those people claimed to attack dreadnought, which makes me suspicious that
(a) dreadnought wasn't attacked at all. or (b) this person is a purple and is scared/stupid to not talk, since at the very least purple people are anti-dark alliance from mergle's actions.
and I generally wouldn't expect to see a scum have like a -1 or -2 brawn ability (on top of team scumkill) and have evidence of only 1 use ever. I imagine if a scum had a -1 or -2 brawn ability they would be using it a lot more, and I doubt an orc can just do a minor attack like that.
So in my view there is 1 decay attack already underway on Kaiser and 2 pro-town anti-brawn abilities that can be implemented. Orcs and Dark Alliance do not know the individuals who can implement these abilities, for the time being (I don't know who knows, but I think I have most concentrated information about these claims)
I base the assumptions on a 1-5 scale, but I think they are reasonable assumptions.
The mergle information is pretty much public, but I can add a tiny bit more (my thoughts previously):
there are 2 claimed brawn attacks (one is successfully used and will automatically continue on kaiserelectric; a magical "decay" attack), with the other being able to be implemented as well on kaiser if need be.
neither of those people claimed to attack dreadnought, which makes me suspicious that
(a) dreadnought wasn't attacked at all. or (b) this person is a purple and is scared/stupid to not talk, since at the very least purple people are anti-dark alliance from mergle's actions.
and I generally wouldn't expect to see a scum have like a -1 or -2 brawn ability (on top of team scumkill) and have evidence of only 1 use ever. I imagine if a scum had a -1 or -2 brawn ability they would be using it a lot more, and I doubt an orc can just do a minor attack like that.
So in my view there is 1 decay attack already underway on Kaiser and 2 pro-town anti-brawn abilities that can be implemented. Orcs and Dark Alliance do not know the individuals who can implement these abilities, for the time being (I don't know who knows, but I think I have most concentrated information about these claims)
I base the assumptions on a 1-5 scale, but I think they are reasonable assumptions.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
oh, I don't remember rules on editting so I'll just double post:
the reason I think purple people exist is because mergle was targetted for a decay in brawn, but showed no concern of the damage he was taking. He either somehow didn't get affected by it in the first place (unlikely) or had someone "healing" him or something. Mergle died shortly after saying that he did not find a healer by "random pming" in our private talks. I do not know if that means he never took damage or began with a healer (purple people)
the reason I think purple people exist is because mergle was targetted for a decay in brawn, but showed no concern of the damage he was taking. He either somehow didn't get affected by it in the first place (unlikely) or had someone "healing" him or something. Mergle died shortly after saying that he did not find a healer by "random pming" in our private talks. I do not know if that means he never took damage or began with a healer (purple people)
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
so for a triple post, this is what I would guess is remaining:
2-3 orcs; high brawn. unlikely to have taken any brawn decay from hearing people's targets so far
1 dark alliance (likely kaiser)
1-2 purple people (one that heals)
1 myself
2 of the claimed attackers
1 dreadnought
--------------------------- that would be 10 people if taking the latter numbers.
then we got a claimed
1 scan zack
which adds up to ~9-11 roles depending on what assumptions/lies are made, and there are 10 roles left. There can be overlap obviously with those numbers (such as dreadnought actually being an orc and lying about being attacked). Or dreadnought actually being attacked but is started as an orc brawn 5 or something and survived.
there should be at least 2 clan of embers in my mind no matter what, as I thought they were thematically the main scum, and it seems we got a dark alliance left unless someone wants to take credit for the non axe kill last night.
2-3 orcs; high brawn. unlikely to have taken any brawn decay from hearing people's targets so far
1 dark alliance (likely kaiser)
1-2 purple people (one that heals)
1 myself
2 of the claimed attackers
1 dreadnought
--------------------------- that would be 10 people if taking the latter numbers.
then we got a claimed
1 scan zack
which adds up to ~9-11 roles depending on what assumptions/lies are made, and there are 10 roles left. There can be overlap obviously with those numbers (such as dreadnought actually being an orc and lying about being attacked). Or dreadnought actually being attacked but is started as an orc brawn 5 or something and survived.
there should be at least 2 clan of embers in my mind no matter what, as I thought they were thematically the main scum, and it seems we got a dark alliance left unless someone wants to take credit for the non axe kill last night.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
edit list, then going off for a little bit (we have a good 52 hour day to get this game solved)
2-3 orcs; high brawn. unlikely to have taken any brawn decay from hearing people's targets so far
1 dark alliance (likely kaiser)
1-2 purple people (one that heals)
1 myself
2 of the claimed attackers
1 dreadnought
--------------------------- that would be 10 people if taking the latter numbers.
then we got a claimed
1 scan zack
1 separate attacker (from dreadnought attack claim)
any other results that might have occurred to people (did your brain go down by 1 at night on random night? Roleblocked? PLEASE CALL KENNIGIT AT 1-800-PMK-ENN-IGIT)
2-3 orcs; high brawn. unlikely to have taken any brawn decay from hearing people's targets so far
1 dark alliance (likely kaiser)
1-2 purple people (one that heals)
1 myself
2 of the claimed attackers
1 dreadnought
--------------------------- that would be 10 people if taking the latter numbers.
then we got a claimed
1 scan zack
1 separate attacker (from dreadnought attack claim)
any other results that might have occurred to people (did your brain go down by 1 at night on random night? Roleblocked? PLEASE CALL KENNIGIT AT 1-800-PMK-ENN-IGIT)
Capt Blackadder
Chieftain
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2010
- Messages
- 71
Vote Kaiser a scan claim is good enough for me. However Zack do you have any other scans that would be helpful?
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Well the vote: KaiserElectric thing seems to be picking up steam.
It seems solid. But if he flips town, Zack should at least be looked at. I understand the "don't kill the scanner", but that's the kind of WIFOM that I would expect from Zack.
It seems solid. But if he flips town, Zack should at least be looked at. I understand the "don't kill the scanner", but that's the kind of WIFOM that I would expect from Zack.
azzaman333
meh
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
unvote, vote Kaiser
Turquoiside
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2008
- Messages
- 1,552
Eh, Vote: KaiserElectric
End Day 5
Perhaps spurred by their dwindling numbers, the scholars were decisive today. The shadow adept said he had seen the nature adept at the site of mat93's demise, and that was good enough for everyone. The veritable barrage of spells left barely enough of KaiserElectric to tell that
Spoiler :
Encouraged by this first success in the upcoming war with the Orcs, they retired for the night hoping that their actions had slowed the rate of death.
Begin Night 5
Night Ends in 24 hours at 2 pm
Night Orders to me.
Night Ends in 24 hours at 2 pm
Night Orders to me.
Living 9/20
Capt Blackadder- Assistant Headmaster
Takhisis-Chaos Adept
Kennigit-Entropy Adept
Buddhafish-Fire Adept
Dreadnought-Mind Adept
Turquoiside-Secretary
Zack- Shadow Adept
azzaman333-Spirit adept
Choxorn-Sun Adept
Dead 11/20
Optical-Life Adept, axed night 1
EliteofWarman8-Earth Adept, lynched day 2
Ninjacow64-Luonnatar, axed night 2
Visorslash-Body Adept, slain night 2
Topsecret- Water Adept, lynched day 3
Earthling-Death Adept, slain night 3
Mergle-Enchantment Adept, axed night 3
Verarde-Metamagic Adept, lynched day 4
BSmith1068- Air Adept, slain night 4
mat93-Ice Adept, axed night 4
KaiserElectric-Nature Adept, lynched day 5
Similar threads
