Patroklos
Deity
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2003
- Messages
- 12,721
I don't agree. This isn't how the English language works, IMO.
Calling a bloke the "c" word is extremely frequent. And is a register above (or below depending on your pov) calling a man the "d" word. The gender specific ~equivalent of the "d" word is the "b" word. (This is bizarre. I'd be just as happy typing the actual words. To me they really are just words. Though the intent behind them is what concerns us here.)
Calling a woman the "c" word is extremely unusual and connotes the sexist mindset. Only one step below referring to a woman as "it". A practice quite common in certain circles intra-males. Indicating the complete objectivification of women.
I feel you, but disagree. The "c" word has no special meaning, in some circles I have run in its a common insult thrown about casually and in others it is the end all be all of insults. Same with the "t" word.
The level of insult is irrelevant though, its the meaning. When someone uses the "d" word it is generally in regards to someone displaying behavior associated with super male traits. Overly aggressive, arrogant, selfish, etc. You are literally calling a guy by his private parts and it is generally still a male only insult. I can't really say the same thing for the "c" word, there isn't any sex specific behavior associated with it, its just am unpleasant thing to call someone. If you don't see the "d" word as sexist, you are probably a hypocrite if you consider the other one to be.
As you said the "b" carries genders specific stereotype connotations too (nagging, emotional, irrational, etc.) so is far more indicative of sexist feelings. The problem is that this word has long lost its gender specificness and is used universally. So if someone is displaying any of those steriotypical behaviors it is a valid descriptive word recognized by everyone male or female, used by male or females. I think it can still be used non generally to be overty sexist though. As in "you are just a 'b'" instead of say "stop acting like a 'b'"
Of course you can personally it be using to to convey whatever you want, or you can interpret it being used any way you want. That doesn't mean your interpretation is going to translate to others. Look at how meaningless the "f" word is these days.
And yes, I wish we could use vulgar words if the context is for discussion's sake only. Boards require simple to apply and enforce rules though.
Anyway, on another tack, notice how often she says "I am offended by...". Is she right to be offended? Has she the right to be offended?
Yes. Yes. That has no bearing on whether I should care about her choices in that regard either way.
Is the leader of the opposition simply exercising his freedom of speech in calling the PM of Australia a " witch", etc?
Yes. It is still extremely rude and inappropriate if done outside of a private setting.