NCAA Football Thread - 2024

For me it's not just about playoff implications as to whether I can get into a game, but whether it's just a good, even, could-go-either-way game. Although my favorite team is in control of its own destiny, so the implications of games involving two-loss teams are more academic than practical for me. That could change if Indiana is 11-0 in a week's time.

Both of the late games wound up being upsets - New Mexico over Wazzou and Kansas over BYU. Colorado had better not be snoozing on Kansas - the Jayhawks beat Iowa State last week, and have consecutive wins over ranked opponents for the first time ever. I'd been wondering what happened with Kansas after their legitimately good year last year - when they were 2-6 they were arguably the team with the second-worst change from last year (after Florida State of course). But all but one of their losses were by 6 points or fewer, and they've now won 3 of 4, the loss being a 2-point loss to then-#16 Kansas State. So they seem to have figured out how to finish games, and that mid-afternoon Kansas/Colorado game looks a lot more interesting now.

Now we only have 11 one-loss teams (including G5). My chart is based on last week's rankings so presumably it's Georgia, not Tennessee, that will be in (edit: and Ole Miss over SMU), and the Committee would put Alabama ahead of Army, though I'll keep my powder dry until we see how the Yankee Stadium game next week turns out.

One hundred years ago in 1924, the Four Horsemen of Notre Dame helped the Irish defeat Army in the Polo Grounds baseball stadium in New York City. Can Army return the favor a century later in a different New York baseball stadium?
 
Last edited:
I really really hope Ohio State beats Indiana by forty. I think Indiana is a great story, and I like Cignetti a lot, but they're the one team currently in the playoffs (other than the G5 and probs Big XII champ) that I don't think can put up a fight against the other playoff teams. So in the spirit of hoping for good games, I'd like the committee to have no choice but to leave them out. There are other teams with undeserving resumes, like Texas and Penn State, but I think those teams will put up a fight when given the chance, and Texas at least still has some opportunity left to prove it . . .

The WSU outcome was a shocker, but I was expecting Kansas over BYU, or at least the likelihood of it. I feel the same way about Colorado, tho perhaps less likely. This weekend is looking like Ole Miss/Florida early (bc I'm expecting that OSU/Indiana blowout), Colorado/Kansas in the afternoon and Alabama/Oklahoma at night. Solid alternatives in each slot tho. Kind of wish WSU/Oregon State wasn't getting the CW treatment, but I wouldn't watch it over Alabama anyway . . .

EDIT: Ohio State opens as an 11' point favorite. I was expecting more ; p It will be interesting to watch that line during the week. Other lines of note, Penn State/Minnesota is the same as Ohio State/Indiana, ASU favored by 3' over BYU, Colorado and A&M each only 2' over Kansas and Auburn.

EDIT EDIT: Up to 13' for Ohio State, almost two touchdowns, 12' for Penn State and 3 for Colorado, others haven't moved . . .

EDIT EDIT EDIT: So basically what we need here is for Indiana to lose badly enough that they fall behind the four 8-2 SEC teams behind them in the standings. That shouldn't be that hard Ohio State. Go out there and do your job ; p
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom