Just to check... if you settle on the deer, do you get access to deer automatically once you have hunting? yes, but you miss out on the food from the camp
If so - then yes the fp deer looks nice, the time taken to get there is offset by the extra food you get on the starting space for making a worker. 1S of the settler looks decent for a future city. Would the settler see more by going 1SE (on the hill) rather than 1S by the way...? I think the idea is to move 1S first, and then to the hill. So if you see great stuff you can still settle on turn 0 at 1S.
Also - is there a mistake in the first post? It states that a mall "gives +20% commerce in the city " but the data page on this website says +20% gold? You are correct. I'm pretty sure the mall only boots gold and not all commerce.