NOTW LV: The Underground (Game Thread)

[Zack]

Here is the voting record:

Spoiler :

blue = dead townie

red = dead mafia

italics/underline = lynched

grayed out = dead, can't vote

• TFA (aka Double A the orc) was replaced first despite others being inactive (ostensibly because he had not been online since July). EQandCivfanatic was replaced by Snerk even though Kennigit was just as inactive. Why has Autolycus not announced that KingMorgan is in danger of replacement, and why did he not say Kennigit was in danger of replacement?

• Backwards Logic, choxorn, and Jarrema were all on both the bladescape and spaceman wagons. The latter two gave little reasoning. This is exactly how they acted as scum partners in A Tale of Two Cities. Backwards Logic explained his votes and pushed others to follow him - he wasn't really jumping on a bandwagon, although IIRC he was not the first to vote either candidate.

• choxorn and Jarrema are also both the only living players to vote for a different confirmed townie each Day. (Takhisis also did this, but he's dead; I have voted for all confirmed townies, but two of those were for the same person.)

• The kills seem random. There's not anything really connecting them and some of the choices are odd.

Now to Double A's posts:

Wait do the mafia have a vote blocking power? That's... horrifyingly lame unless YLOL happens.

Basically confirms that the mafia blocked Riedquat's vote. This post is horrifyingly lame.

Okay so my understanding of the jht wagon is you're voting him for acting like jht. Are lurkers gonna get lynched now, too? If you want to be consistent.

Did... Did Double A just defend me?

Defends jht.

vote: jht
unvote: jht

There now I can read the thread without being bothered by not being here for that on D1

Also did this with jht. Worth noting Double A also voted spaceman at some point and advocated his lynch even after switching off (the spaceman who was gung-ho about lynching jht). Possible connection there.

Wait, what am I doing? I hate bandwagons.

unvote: spaceman
vote: Ken

get your butt on this forum young man
only I'm allowed to be that inactive and still be considered an active participant

Randomly switches to Kennigit for no particular reason. Possibly calling his inactive teammate to action.


TL ; DR

My favorite candidates: choxorn, Jarrema, johnhughthom

 

[Visorslash]

I disagree on choxorn, middling on jarrema.

Take those two out, who else?

 

[Visorslash]

What about sprig or robbie?

 

[Zack]

I'd be totally fine with Sprig, he hasn't really produced meaningful content.

 

[Zack]

I disagree on choxorn, middling on jarrema.

Take those two out, who else?

Why ?

 

[Zack]

I'd be totally fine with Sprig, he hasn't really produced meaningful content.

meaning I think townie Sprig is better than this

 

[Visorslash]

Why ?

choxorns interaction with AA seems weird if they're partners

and choxorn has been pretty afk/not carey as town recently - see ciretako

i don't get the impression he's thinking too hard about this game

 

[Zack]

I disagree on choxorn, middling on jarrema.

Take those two out, who else?

What about jht?

 

[Autolycus]

@Zack Kennigit informed me he was going to be away last weekend, which is why I replaced EQandcivfanatic instead of him. KingMorgan voted day 1 and has said he's back now. We're also too deep in the game for internal replacements and I don't have externals, so the WOG/leave trade-off would be real even if he hadn't posted his return. Do not reason based on replacements.

 

[Visorslash]

jarrema is still on the list but if you had to drop him, who for?

sprig/jht interaction look a tad like bussing

 

[Visorslash]

What about jht?

on the list i guess

 

[Visorslash]

robbie

 

[Visorslash]

We've got four methods of death.

Throttled
10.Hornguard- Bsmith1068- throttled Night 1-A New Hope
14. Mage-Winston Hughes- throttled Night 2-A New Hope
9. General-landlubber- throttled Night 3--A New Hope

Fire
13. Lanun Refugee- TheForestAuro/DoubleA- scorched Night 3 -The Clan of Embers
3. Cannoneer-riedquat-burned Night 2 -A New Hope

Poisoned
7. Elven refugee- snerk- poisoned Night 1 -A New Hope

Axed
21. Vicar-Takhisis- axed Night 3 -A New Hope

Throttled is obviously the mafia kill. Fire seems like CoE I guess because fire. Dunno how AA died then.

Poisoned and Axed, no idea who they could be.

 

[Visorslash]

At this stage I think we're facing two scum teams.

 

[Kennigit]

why not SK?

 

[Jarrema]

as always, at his moment of game I start to think: what if the most active towne, the one organizing town network, is mafia himself?

Visor, why do you refrain from telling me what your role is? You wanted to know mine and I told you. Can others tell me if Visor was also so reserved in contact with them? I feel that he wants to know everything and gives nothing in exchange.

I know it is not much of data for accusing someone, but I go for a feeling. I unfortunately do not have much time to spent on the game now.

 

[Jarrema]

guess what: Visorslash contacted me right when I was writing previous post... revealing nothing and wanting more thoughts from me. As conspicious as before.

 

[Visorslash]

Oh jarrema

thats the not the line you take with me when we're town together

 

[Visorslash]

I feel that he wants to know everything and gives nothing in exchange.

I mean I guess this isn't an uncommon thought. But I've been reasonably open this game.

And I've done nothing with anyones claim except for last night as everyone I've pmed can attest to.

 

[Visorslash]

I've also told people on numerous occasions to not lynch townies and they end up flipping town

so not sure how you're going to wrangle up a lynch of me