Open marriages

Joined
Feb 21, 2004
Messages
4,756
Your beloved wife has started having sex with another, much more attractive man. She asked beforehand and you reluctantly agreed to it. Now you can't bear the thought of it, but she says she can't stop it now and you're being blamed for not keeping your word.

To complicate matters further, you have a little kid with your wife and would hate to divorce her. She's okay with you seeing other women, so she want your relationship to be open, but you don't have any particular interest or talent for starting to date again.

Are there any good solutions to this? What would you do?


Mods can close this thread at request.
 
That situation would be terrible for those experiencing it :/

But life is too short to be dragged around unhappy like that. I know people sometimes try to work it out by separating for a little while to see if they really want to permanently separate for the long term (especially with children), but trying to maintain the situation of the OP just seems too hard, no matter the desire to try to set things as they were before
 
No doubt we all have to discipline our life great deal but on the other hand by nature most of us are polygamist. I guess its case by case a higly individualised decision dependent on the circumstances. Something tells me itsnt tolerable but also I dont always feel like following rules just becouse of society. In fact I like to challenge it and experiment. Just like they say: every rull has an exception....
 
Try Tinder?

For real that isn't going to work out, at least not short term... Maybe it's recoverable if you split for awhile and get your own bearings, but anything else just sounds miserable. Cheating is hard but a repentant mistake can often be forgiven, but that's a totally different situation.

Think about the plot to "Crazy Stupid Love"
 
There are a number of husbands out there that want their wife to cheat on them but she won't. Looks like a swap could be in order.
 
If I ever found out my girlfriend was having sex with her husband, it would be over.
Good to hear you are a man of principle but I dont think there is much chance you will ever find out...
 
If the key to his chastity device went missing, I'd at least suspect it.

Well you wouldnt meet a girl whose husband doesnt know how to use picklock anyway, right?
 
If it is to do with the locked thread, If you have a stable job, stable fiances and stable
life. It might just be the wife is chasing a fairy tale, thus casual sex with a gym teacher. I have a feeling that this relationship is just a fling and it will all end in tears. And the wife will realize a stable happy marriage is what she was after all along. And that happy marriage is gone because she wanted to have an affair and what was there after 10 years is destroyed.

It would be devastating to be married and be cheated on.

In the end it what you want, seems you want to save your marriage, But at the same time it cannot continue the way its going.
If your not ok with it tell her to stop, she must understand what this is doing to you and your marriage. If she cannot stop and dosent want to, then end your marriage.

You could always do what Sen Vitter did and pay money to use Prostitutes. Luck for him hes wife didnt carry out her promise of castration. (This is Joke, do not do this)
 
I don't believe in "open marriages", I think they are a farce.

I'd just find the man and challenge him to 1 on 1 Mortal Kombat. That way, regardless of the result, the problem would be solved.

And if you win, it would tell other men to think twice between doing your wife.
 
Such a situation is unlikely to work well. Human nature (selfishness, greed, possessiveness, jealousy etc) all work against its success. If a couple did find a way for it to work, then I would suspect that the couple did not really have much investment in their relationship to begin with.
 
If such a situation was to arise, I certainly wouldn't post the details to a public discussion forum.
 
My experience tells me that husbands become the guy miserable conversations happen with. The bills, the household breakdowns that are still unfixed, the household breakdowns the kid caused today, the kid's grades/behavior/etc. Love may be present, but it has very little opportunity to get across.

Then there is "the guy". She doesn't nag him about that cracked windowpane that needs glazed. She doesn't ask him why they can't afford a better car. The only conversation they have is him telling her how wonderful she is, and her eating it up...plus of course her telling him what a jerk her husband is and him nodding compassionately.

If you can say "you're wonderful" and tune out all the whining about the husband for a couple hours a week you can borrow a wife easily for a couple romps a week. If you get good at it you can have a whole stable of wives to choose from and be romping to the limits of your physical capacity. The problem is they all want to ditch their husband to be with "the guy who really understands them", who if he is smart recognizes that if he were with them for more than a couple hours a week he would be more hated than the husband is.

Is there a solution, from the husband's point of view? Maybe. If you really think your wife is the greatest bestest only one for you...let her leave. She will find out very quickly that the guy who thinks she is wonderful in very small doses has no interest at all in a steady diet of her. Do not divorce her, or she will be living on your income and have no complaints about Mr Wonderful...let her really examine how interested he is in supporting her.

And don't be mean about it. When she is crying and complaining about Mr Wonderful, do what he did. Tune her out, nod compassionately...you can do it for a couple hours at a time. While she's gone, live well. You may find out that the realities of demographics will have a steady stream of women trying to pick up her discard. They can either keep you busy until she gives up on Mr Wonderful, or you may find that she wasn't the greatest and bestest after all.

A key point...you have to do this letting go early, without bitterness, and with clear evidence that it is all her idea, and without indication that it may be permanent. That way if it does become permanent she is on the short end of the legal stick as the mom who ran off and abandoned her family.
 
Are there any good solutions to this? What would you do?

Make a pass at the wife's sister. That should resolve the situation with no hard feelings right away, yes sir.

More sincerely, the husband suffers from an extreme lack of confidence. The solution is two part:

1. Join a gym, lose some weight, and get cut.

2. Tell his wife, in no uncertain terms, that her relationship is harming their marriage and he wants her to stop it. He'll need to be prepared to contact either (or both) a marriage counselor or an attorney.

Taking no action is not constructive because the relationship, as it stands, is doomed without serious intervention.
 
Your beloved wife has started having sex with another, much more attractive man. She asked beforehand and you reluctantly agreed to it. Now you can't bear the thought of it, but she says she can't stop it now and you're being blamed for not keeping your word.

To complicate matters further, you have a little kid with your wife and would hate to divorce her. She's okay with you seeing other women, so she want your relationship to be open, but you don't have any particular interest or talent for starting to date again.

Are there any good solutions to this? What would you do?


Mods can close this thread at request.


The key issue is it just (a) casual sex or (b) is there a stronger emotional relationship?

If it is just (a) then the husband can just sit it out and either his wife or
her lover will get bored with it. If it is (b) then the marriage is doomed.
 
That's not a marriage, that's a roommate with the same last name.
 
That's not a marriage, that's a roommate with the same last name.

And the daughter ?

I would like to also ask if the husband has had any problems that the wife has raised ? Like an addiction or anger or other problems that could have lead to this.
If you want to save the marriage, we might be getting only one side of the story.
 
Back
Top Bottom