Red Dwarf Mafia: The Smeggening [Game Thread - Concluded]

[choxorn]

He's stuck his neck out too far to be scum

Agreed, there's no way Jarrema acts the way he's acted towards me and towards us if he's a Serial Killer. That doesn't mean he's necessarily a neutral survivalist, but he's not an SK.

 

[Double A]

I just don't get why BSmith could fix one of them but not both of them, and what the hell was causing all this ability loss.

I don't get anything at this point

remake claimed he lost his ability the day after I attacked him and I don't see any reason to doubt him now
Tak claimed getting attacked and ability loss in the same day
it seems some abilities act as a limited BP thingy

 

[landlubber]

I just don't get why BSmith could fix one of them but not both of them, and what the hell was causing all this ability loss.

That's what makes me suspect BSmith. His ability is... weird. The whole ability-loss thing is weird, and the fact that BSmith has only ever successfully fixed Winston is a red flag to me. I'd be surprised if both of them were scum (because that would mean 5 monsters, 4 RS, Jarrema, and 20 town-- too many scum per townie IMO) but something's going on with them.

 

[BSmith1068]

One of Tak or Winston is lying in my opinion. Winston claims that nothing happened to him the first time I tried to fix him. Tak, with a known ability loss claims nothing happened to him when I tried to fix him. Winston claims that I was able to fix him after he lost his ability and I tried to fix him the second time. Something doesn't add up.

Tak - the PM I sent you a few game days back was an attempt to see if you had been fixed. You replied by saying nothing had changed.

So in my mind it is either Tak or Winston.

 

[Double A]

unvote again

 

[landlubber]

I'd be comfortable with a Winston lynch if we could get enough votes on him in time. I'd prefer BSmith to him, but lynching Winston would settle the debate of who's lying between Winston and BS. Lynching Tak wouldn't. It's got to be either Winston or BS.

 

[BSmith1068]

Trust me, I think my ability is weird too. The only success I have had has supposedly been with winston. Even after I figured out that people were losing their abilities and started targeting them instead of the random selections I had done up to that point. My role simply states that I am a town fixer and can attempt to fix problems with a players role at night.

 

[BSmith1068]

unvote; vote: Winston

 

[landlubber]

BSmith sounds townie here.

unvote, Vote: Winston.

god help me

 

[Double A]

yeah alright

Winston Churchill

I hope this iron curtain thing is just a fad

 

[BSmith1068]

If winston is scum, it makes sense to say that he is protecting choxorn. It makes sense to keep choxorn alive so the QT stays alive and the info keeps coming.

 

[Double A]

yeah there's no way any scum would kill choxy

 

[landlubber]

I've got a statistics test tomorrow so this is really the best I can do for tonight. I'm reasonably settled on a Winston lynch. I'm totally uncertain, but Winston is my biggest scumlean now.

 

[Double A]

I've been ready for bed for the past hour and I don't know why
I usually fall asleep at 3

 

[Double A]

what gets me is why the monsters didn't kill landlubber

 

[choxorn]

Vote: Winston

Also, the first time you fixed him was before he said he'd lost his ability.

And I don't think we ever actually verified that he had a doctor ability, did we?

 

[BSmith1068]

Yeah, I am heading back to bed too. I only happened to be online by chance because my daughter is sick and has been up crying for the past 45 minutes. Turning he computer on has done the charm and distracted her enough to stop crying at least. Just happened to not be a quiet time!

I am convinced one of winston or tak is scum. I am fine with a winston lynch at this point.

 

[Double A]

Vote: Winston

Also, the first time you fixed him was before he said he'd lost his ability.

And I don't think we ever actually verified that he had a doctor ability, did we?

Woah, wait, what?

 

[landlubber]

what gets me is why the monsters didn't kill landlubber

I dunno, IF seemed to think that he could generate momentum against me. That's my take on it.

I'm really gone now.

 

[BSmith1068]

correct. and I sent a PM to him like I did Tak inquiring as to if anything changed with him. But once he was in the QT and saw the ability in full is when he claimed to have lost his ability too. I do not believe that we have been able with certainty to verify his doctor ability.