So you call me a 'fanboi'

Discussion in 'Civ5 - General Discussions' started by Dale, Dec 27, 2010.

  1. Clement

    Clement Layman

    Joined:
    Oct 7, 2010
    Messages:
    732
    lol, well to be fair i don't mind the salad one as it is pretty funny :D
     
  2. Isikien

    Isikien WHOA

    Joined:
    May 7, 2008
    Messages:
    299
    So 'I studied on killin' you' isn't an immersion breaker for you?
     
  3. lietkynes

    lietkynes Hello sword !

    Joined:
    Aug 27, 2002
    Messages:
    883
    Location:
    Rome
    I seriously doubt a game designer would accept much criticism on game design issues from beta testers. After all, he's the lead game designer for the most successful strategy game ever and they are just beta testers, why should he think they are right and he is wrong ?

    Of course after reading Sulla and Dale posts you would think they are way better than Shafer at game design, because they are very good at pointing out his mistakes and really it's difficult not to agree with their points. But that doesn't mean that they would be able to do better then him. Finding someone else's mistakes is easier then making your own design.
     
  4. Clement

    Clement Layman

    Joined:
    Oct 7, 2010
    Messages:
    732
    Hey, we not supposed to compare Civ 5 to Civ 4 remember? "it's a totally different game!" :D

    Well joking aside, i agree with both of you, looking back with rose tinted glasses at Civ 4 made me forget that the leaders did speak in silly ways too, but i think the excellence of the game itself made me not notice, Civ 4 was so deep and interesting that in an odd way the leaders earned the right to joke and be cheekily out of character with me as a player, for me personally when a leader does that to me in Civ 5 it just feels irritating instead of funny because i'm unhappy with so much else of the game, again, just my opinion.
     
  5. lschnarch

    lschnarch Emperor

    Joined:
    Oct 7, 2010
    Messages:
    1,296
    Sorry, but what would be the point to have beta testers, then?
    "Don't tell me where the game doesn't work, after all *I* by the Lord's Grace am the lead designer?"
    Of course it is much easier to pick out the flaws. No doubt about this.
    And I am far away from claiming that either of the two you mentioned would be a better designer.
    Well, maybe they would be slightly better, since I regard Civ5 as a complete desaster.
    The UI is a slap into the player's face, but was heavily advertised for "accessibility".
    The combat is so poor that it is hard to put in words. Three months after release. But it was heavily advertised. Actually, it was the *one* thing about which they talked all the time.
    Diplomacy is completely erratic. You could as well roll dice. And it has already been significantly changed.
    The engine is hardware demandin like no good. The relative output compared to the demand is poor. Yet, it was advertised as "scaling and even been developed with the help of Microsoft"

    The whole game feels like everybody in the development team was allowed to create his own "baby" and then they tried to combine it all. And they failed.

    So, yes, even Dale and Sullla might have been better leads, as it is hard to imagine it getting even worse.
    After all, we are not talking about the first garage-made game from an indy developer, but about the last iteration of an almost 20 years old franchise. There should have been some lessons learned from the past.
     
  6. LDiCesare

    LDiCesare Deity

    Joined:
    Dec 22, 2005
    Messages:
    2,612
    Location:
    France
    The early days make it all.
    Civ V may be a good game if you expect to play it for 50 or 100 hours.
    It is not when you expect it to have lasting appeal as Civ 1,2,4 (or 3 for those who liked it), which means hundredS or thousands of hours of fun.
    So maybe it's fun for casual players, but not those who want MP, nor those who want to 'cheat' by altering the map to their liking in-game, for instance.
     
  7. bryanw1995

    bryanw1995 Emperor

    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2006
    Messages:
    1,459
    Location:
    San Antonio, TX
    really, city placement is meaningless? ever have a capitol on the coast surrounded by grasslands? they've already gone a long way towards promoting better city development. library + public schools make a size 12 city worth as much science as 15 size 2 cities, and that's not taking into account a university/national wonder/etc.

    diplomacy is still frustrating, but just because YOU don't know how it works doesn't mean that it's meaningless. if you're a warmonger people will hate you, that's pretty simple. taking over a CS is the same as taking over a major civ. do that 2 or 3 times and expect a dow from everyone else. if you city spam like crazy, get the top military/pop/etc they will hate you. isn't it the same in MP? the last thing you want in a competitive game with 6-12 players is to have a big X on your chest at the start.

    I don't know why I'm telling you all this, you've seen it all a thousand times but still choose to ignore it and instead come onto the message boards to rant about your bad experiences over and over and over. if it's so bad then why are you still here? I really enjoy civ5, but I'm spending time at the cIII forums now too because I've started playing that again as well. I'm not on the elemental forums b/c I don't like/play that game. makes sense, right?
     
  8. bryanw1995

    bryanw1995 Emperor

    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2006
    Messages:
    1,459
    Location:
    San Antonio, TX
    once the sdk is out you'll be able to do whatever you want with the map. it took 6 months or so iirc for previous sdk's to be released.

    I'm at over 600 hours and really enjoying it still.
     
  9. elthrasher

    elthrasher Revcaster

    Joined:
    Sep 11, 2009
    Messages:
    712
    Build credibility? "My game was tested by top players!"

    Holding playtesters responsible for Civ5 isn't reasonable. We have no idea what the game was like when they received it. The thing about testing is that unless your initial release is perfect (and trust me, it's not), multiple rounds are required to really get anywhere. So maybe the playtesters offered some good feedback and some problems with the game were fixed. That doesn't mean the game is now 100% perfect. You have to go back and test the new & improved game to see if it is sufficiently improved.

    There can be no doubt this game was rushed to release. I expect a result of having to rush meant there were fewer rounds of playtesting and less time to absorb playtester feedback than you would have wanted in a perfect world.

    I've been involved in playtesting other games. Sometimes you see the final release and go "oh yeah, this feature here, that was my idea to fix this horribly broken thing!" The other 99% of the time you go "yeah, that's still a problem. I told them."
     
  10. lietkynes

    lietkynes Hello sword !

    Joined:
    Aug 27, 2002
    Messages:
    883
    Location:
    Rome
    To catch bugs, more or less. I understand that a small group of players was selected to test game design issues, but I doubt that serious critics ("the core maths are broken") would have been taken into consideration by the lead designer.


    I think people are over-estimating Firaxis which, in my opinion, is a company that is living on old glory but seriously lacks talent. The departure of Shafer might be good, a fresh approach to the game from a new designer is probably a good thing. Time will tell.
     
  11. Dralix

    Dralix Killer of threads

    Joined:
    Dec 28, 2001
    Messages:
    2,407
    You're actually partially correct here, hyperbole aside. The point of a beta test is not to critique design elements. By that time, it's too far down the process to overhaul the design. That kind of stuff should have been worked out long before. The point of beta testing is to see if the game is working as designed.
     
  12. moscaverde

    moscaverde Prince

    Joined:
    Apr 26, 2004
    Messages:
    403
    Location:
    Brazil
    This, and the great "actual quotes" mod.
     
  13. Zyxpsilon

    Zyxpsilon Running Spider

    Joined:
    Oct 29, 2009
    Messages:
    3,250
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    On Earth
    QFT... there is some precious wisdom explicitly deployed in just two simple paragraphs that even i must learn from.
     
  14. zuraffo

    zuraffo Warlord

    Joined:
    Jan 7, 2006
    Messages:
    207
    Yes, I get it. I am trying to say I feel the same (more immersive) as you during my initial "testdrive". I don't know. I am waiting to see if you can still be so optimistic into your 6th or 7th playthrough. :mischief:

     
  15. zuraffo

    zuraffo Warlord

    Joined:
    Jan 7, 2006
    Messages:
    207
    Doing post-mortem analysis is always easier than taking the helm. The view is always clearer on hindsight.
     
  16. JimMac99

    JimMac99 Warlord

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2003
    Messages:
    128
    Location:
    Belfast. N.Ireland
    Dale, you make some good points (as did Sulla). I definitely feel the lack of immersion, but hadn't realised the maths discrepancy.

    With your knowledge of how things work behind the scenes, are you hopefull that these problems will be resolved (without the aid of mods)?
     
  17. Dale

    Dale Mohawk Games Developer

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2002
    Messages:
    7,235
    Well, I have a pitch document for a stand alone Civ 5 product linked in my sig (wasn't taken up, so I'm debating whether to do it as a Civ 5 mod or just make it into a game I can sell). Have a read and tell me what you think. (Note: a pitch document's goal is to highlight the major features, not the entire design) :)

    I also hear Sullla put out there that he might put on paper his design for a "Civ" styled game.
     
  18. Dale

    Dale Mohawk Games Developer

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2002
    Messages:
    7,235
    Firaxis is working hard to ensure Civ 5 supports the majority of players. But you need to remember that CFC players are really a tiny percentage of the overall player base and they receive feedback from all player groups, not just CFC.
     
  19. Arsenic Steel

    Arsenic Steel Warlord

    Joined:
    Nov 4, 2010
    Messages:
    155
    Good thing being a player comes first and players are able to create forum accounts in places other than CFC, maybe even a place where the overall:lol: player base is.
     
  20. LDiCesare

    LDiCesare Deity

    Joined:
    Dec 22, 2005
    Messages:
    2,612
    Location:
    France
    I'd like to know how you pulled that one out. In such circumstances, assuming few forests, the map generation code is biased to turn some land into hill. Plus it'll send you additional goodies to enhance your start location, mostly luxuries.
     

Share This Page