Optical
The Fall of the Eleventh
Sorry for being so inactive. I keep forgetting to vote because my subscribed threads are screwing over my ability to check threads properly.
Talisman Mafia
- Thread starter Turquoiside
- Start date
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Aw yea.
Maybe someone would like to sign for my new large game?
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=455989
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=455989
Turquoiside
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2008
- Messages
- 1,552
Section 13 rose to find a new corpse waiting for them, this time the heat-beam ridden body of General Olaf. But strangely, the person who brought the body to the base's attention was General Olaf himself! Any other place this would have been earth-shattering, but here anything impossible could usually be traced back to the Talismans.
General Olaf has been killed:
Paying no mind to the living Olaf, they set about moving the body to a coffin and placing it with the others. But while placing the corpse, they couldn't help but notice that Tohru(Earthling's) body was beginning to stir. After the initial horror and panic, almost everyone in the complex was gathered in the room to see if he was truly alive. And he was. According to him, his last memory was being hung...and then waking up a few hours before now with an intense pain in his neck and an intense feeling of fatigue. Captain Black ended any further badgering by ordering everyone non-essential back to work, saying he needed to question Tohru alone and make certain he was healthy; if a corpse ever really is healthy.
Earthling has been revived!
General Olaf has been killed:
Spoiler :
Paying no mind to the living Olaf, they set about moving the body to a coffin and placing it with the others. But while placing the corpse, they couldn't help but notice that Tohru(Earthling's) body was beginning to stir. After the initial horror and panic, almost everyone in the complex was gathered in the room to see if he was truly alive. And he was. According to him, his last memory was being hung...and then waking up a few hours before now with an intense pain in his neck and an intense feeling of fatigue. Captain Black ended any further badgering by ordering everyone non-essential back to work, saying he needed to question Tohru alone and make certain he was healthy; if a corpse ever really is healthy.
Earthling has been revived!
It is now Day! Day Four ends in roughly 47 hours, 10 PM EST!
Vote for the lynch choice in bold!
Vote for the new owner of the Snake Talisman in Lime!
Vote for the new owner of the Sheep Talisman in Turquoise!
Vote for the lynch choice in bold!
Vote for the new owner of the Snake Talisman in Lime!
Vote for the new owner of the Sheep Talisman in Turquoise!
Only one Talisman will be handed out today.
Spoiler :
Optical
The Fall of the Eleventh
Anyone who can protect people, protect me tonight. I can't do that twice.
I think we should give the Snake Talisman to Earthling. Since he's back, and a confirmed innocent and all.
Failing that, of course, I'm happy to award the Sheep Talisman to Takhisis. But I am curious as to why he wants it.
I think we should give the Snake Talisman to Earthling. Since he's back, and a confirmed innocent and all.
Failing that, of course, I'm happy to award the Sheep Talisman to Takhisis. But I am curious as to why he wants it.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
IMO, sending the sheep talisman to Takhisis is more important than sending the snake talisman to Earthling. He wants it because it gives him a cop ability! (Apparently)
And what DID you do exactly?
Also, from a Jackie Chan Adventures expert, can you think of any reason why someone would come back to life? And, if they did, would there be any possibility of them being turned "evil"?
The other thing that I find interesting about last night's update is that there was only one night kill. Did the Vigilante stop killing? Or has the Mafia kill been stopped somehow? Strange.
I'd say he's probably just a new player. Doesn't mean he's not mafia, but with new players, it's hard to tell what's them actually being scummy and what's them just being new at the game.
I'm in complete agreement with your logic on Earthling, though. He can haveboth talismans.
I'm in complete agreement with your logic on Earthling, though. He can haveboth talismans.
People, please! DO NOT VOTE BOTH TALISMANS.
We want to give sheep talisman to someone, dont we?
And, as yesterday, only one talisman would be given.
Earthling can have sheep talisman
And my vote goes for Takhisis, as I do not have better idea and I have to go to work now.
We want to give sheep talisman to someone, dont we?
And, as yesterday, only one talisman would be given.
Earthling can have sheep talisman
And my vote goes for Takhisis, as I do not have better idea and I have to go to work now.
Sheep to Earthling.
I think that Takhisis seemed a little suspicious, demanding the sheep like that.
I think that Takhisis seemed a little suspicious, demanding the sheep like that.
Too right. Earthling is really the only one we can trust, though I doubt the mafia will be long in killing him again. If there's a doctor in the house, go protect him!
Really, we can't deduce much from the voting. I'd like to say those voting to save earthling and get kennigit were clear innocents (which includes me), but from the write-up, the other mafia didn't know he was one of them, so I don't think we can say that.
Jarrema looks innocent to me, as if he *were* mafia, he would'nt have known kennigit was one of them, so it can't even be a busing. The only reason I'm not voting him a talisman is to ensure earthling gets it, and so any doctor only needs to protect one person.
sheep to Earthling
On the other hand, given two reasonably clear innocents, Takhisis' behaviour looks dodgy. Until he can explain himself I'm voting him. But I must admit, I do doubt a bit that a mafia would be so obvious about it.
Looking back at Takhisis's posts since he replaced Zack:
Fluff.
Not really scummy or not scummy, just telling NinjaCow not to edit posts.
Demanding the Sheep Talisman when it was up for vote yesterday.
Just joining the Kennigit-wagon and saying Jarrema should be lynched if he's innocent.
Again with the Sheep Talisman.
Why do you want the Sheep Talisman so badly, Takhisis? Why so bandwagony? And most of all, why have you posted only 6 times in the past few days? You normally post a lot more than this. What gives, Takhisis?
Fluff.
Not really scummy or not scummy, just telling NinjaCow not to edit posts.
Demanding the Sheep Talisman when it was up for vote yesterday.
Just joining the Kennigit-wagon and saying Jarrema should be lynched if he's innocent.
Again with the Sheep Talisman.
Why do you want the Sheep Talisman so badly, Takhisis? Why so bandwagony? And most of all, why have you posted only 6 times in the past few days? You normally post a lot more than this. What gives, Takhisis?
We want the sheep talisman distributed today for the investigation ability, absolutely - no sense voting on the other one. I would definitely use that so thanks for the support, I can take the Sheep talisman.
I wasn't told who exactly it was revived me but it was a townie's talisman ability, assuming you know what you are doing and what you want to share, don't particularly need to pressure anyone about that.
I personally think we can do a bit better than lynching Takhisis, especially as I thought Zack was looking innocent the first day (and unlikely to kill BSmith). I need to look through some voting histories though.
Here's issues I'm noticing right now:
If we've got a protector and discuss this that could be ok by me; I don't know who else has been being protected though. I would say - I certainly don't need to be protected guys, I came back with no personal abilities and I'll just be buying time and adding to the town numbers while I'm here, so important innocents who've been alive the whole time are more worth protecting.
This also relates to the tiger talisman being split in half perhaps? - one version survived? It seems like you were attacked by that vigilante/pig talisman ability like before, so people are right we don't know for sure who did that hit and hopefully the mafia didn't get control of that talisman.
Does it seem to anyone else like the mafia knew this about the tiger talisman in advance? Still seems that way to me - see Kennigit before.
Also, I'm not sure we can logically rule out that Kennigit was separated from the other Dark Hand by the time he was lynched. Careful on that when looking at votes. He theoretically could have made contact by then with an ability the first day, and they certainly could have made contact by just, like, talking to each other in private if they guessed right. We're not quite clear who killed whom either, Kennigit was seen doing the one nightkill but don't know if it was him or one of the other scum the first night.
I wasn't told who exactly it was revived me but it was a townie's talisman ability, assuming you know what you are doing and what you want to share, don't particularly need to pressure anyone about that.
I personally think we can do a bit better than lynching Takhisis, especially as I thought Zack was looking innocent the first day (and unlikely to kill BSmith). I need to look through some voting histories though.
Here's issues I'm noticing right now:
If we've got a protector and discuss this that could be ok by me; I don't know who else has been being protected though. I would say - I certainly don't need to be protected guys, I came back with no personal abilities and I'll just be buying time and adding to the town numbers while I'm here, so important innocents who've been alive the whole time are more worth protecting.
This also relates to the tiger talisman being split in half perhaps? - one version survived? It seems like you were attacked by that vigilante/pig talisman ability like before, so people are right we don't know for sure who did that hit and hopefully the mafia didn't get control of that talisman.
Does it seem to anyone else like the mafia knew this about the tiger talisman in advance? Still seems that way to me - see Kennigit before.
Also, I'm not sure we can logically rule out that Kennigit was separated from the other Dark Hand by the time he was lynched. Careful on that when looking at votes. He theoretically could have made contact by then with an ability the first day, and they certainly could have made contact by just, like, talking to each other in private if they guessed right. We're not quite clear who killed whom either, Kennigit was seen doing the one nightkill but don't know if it was him or one of the other scum the first night.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Ah carp pants. I just realised I gave certain information to Taki that I really shouldn't have. I got him confused with Jarrema. So that means that I will vote: Takhisis and if he is Mafia then that is very bad. 
