US vs China

Who contributed more in the history of Mankind?

  • U.S.A

    Votes: 26 31.3%
  • China

    Votes: 44 53.0%
  • Other (Explain)

    Votes: 13 15.7%

  • Total voters
    83
Have to agree with you, KoC, about the second part. Guess he's steeped in chauvinism and govt brainwash.

Seriously, I feel silly (as I have said somewhere earlier) posting here. There's no meaningful comparison history-wise betw China and the US. Both are fundamentally different countries with different culture, time-frame, govt type, even form of writing (alphabet for the US, ideograms for China). Let's just agree that both nations contribute to human civ and progress and leave it there. ;) Peace.
 
Have any of you non-Chinese read the White Papers? I urge you to do so. It's really chilling stuff:eek:, when it isn't totally obtuse:confused:. The only part I'd exempt from those blanket statements is the part about what the Western religious missionaries did there in the Victorian age.
 
You would be surprised with Chinese strength and determination should they attempt to invade Taiwan.

Eqipment and other quantifiable capabilities are only part of the equation. Ask America in their attempt in Vietnam. Or Russia's attempt in Afghanistan.



Originally posted by jumbo2002
As Fayadi posted in offtopic about China having a real fast plane or having excellent attack fighters...

At the same time, it does not matter China has planes or fighters if somebody else has stronger planes. Even though China's military is strong, it's a ground based military. China could not successfully invade Taiwan. It simply does not have the aerial or sealift capabilities to mount such an invasion; moreover, doing so would require the redeployment of approximately 500,000 troops. This action would be highly visibile by modern satellites.

The lone option that remains is a coordinated missile strike that attempts to "decapitate" the Taiwanese government. However, if four weeks of continuous bombing could not unseat Saddam Hussein (in 1991) or the Taliban (now) I have a feeling that even 250 medium range missiles would do little to Taiwan....
 
Anyway lets sign peace treaty I began to think that I am silly too to post this forum.By the way this voting polls got errors,THE MODERATORS CHANGED Them so the correct votes is US present votes - 34 votes(what I am reading now is 44 so 44-34=10 the correct vote should be 10 thats the correct one.SO roughly the votes are about the same,AND DONT ASK ME WHY THE MODERATORS WANT TO CHANGE THEM I HAVE NO IDEA Either and it is so obvious that they change them!From 0 jumped to 34 (i was here round the clock that time so i knew it),the moderators have bombarded this poll anyway its ok ,its fun n games anyway
 
I would like to point something out:

Fayadi, your last post is the true communism your government practices. You essentially disregard the peoples votes as the fault of a moderator, and present your own statistics (which I have NO clue how you arrived at them) pushing your views. It is so funny that you did this:lol: !

Can you possible present a positive image of a government who does not trust the people to select its own leaders? Do you think it is healthy for your Premier and Chairman to be selected by only a few wealthy aristocratic government Bureaucrats, who probably have no clue what is really going on? Would you prefer a system where everybody was able to jointly select the leaders? Just curious.

~Chris
 
I posted this on another thread, but it is more relevent here

does any one else find it funny that China, the worlds last major communist nation (Cuba, North Korea not withstanding), has the worst labour record in the world? So much for a people's republic
:(
 
Originally posted by Whiskey Priest
I posted this on another thread, but it is more relevent here

does any one else find it funny that China, the worlds last major communist nation (Cuba, North Korea not withstanding), has the worst labour record in the world? So much for a people's republic
:(

And your statement was base on?


I only read some posts but I here is what I come up so far:
1. I agreed that the topic and the poll is dumb
2. many of you don't have a clue what the modern China is like. In fact no one does including me since we are not living in China.
3. Fayadi you need to calm down. Don't act like a kid. Go play some civ3 if other's opinions anger you. Remember, it's not up to you to justify and correct all the injustice and dumbheads in the world.


anyways, if you anticpated in this post I think you will find mine topic interesting:
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=7826
 
Originally posted by sonorakitch
I would like to point something out:

Fayadi, your last post is the true communism your government practices. You essentially disregard the peoples votes as the fault of a moderator, and present your own statistics (which I have NO clue how you arrived at them) pushing your views. It is so funny that you did this:lol: !

Can you possible present a positive image of a government who does not trust the people to select its own leaders? Do you think it is healthy for your Premier and Chairman to be selected by only a few wealthy aristocratic government Bureaucrats, who probably have no clue what is really going on? Would you prefer a system where everybody was able to jointly select the leaders? Just curious.

~Chris

ok I find the first part of your statment funny

as for the second part, I will try to counter your statments the way your presented them. I pick US cause they always diss us Canadians:p

Can you possible present a president who had less than 50% of popular votes? Do you know there is/was a huge corruption problem in China but if the party members are "clean", they earned 300 dollars per month? Does American stop functioning because of the election split it in half? Does all of these really matters the outcome? Also curious.


my point is that no government is perfect and different countries need different government to run efficiently. You aren't running 1.3 billion people so why not go chill and play some more civ3?
 
Originally posted by Fayadi
Anyway lets sign peace treaty I began to think that I am silly too to post this forum.By the way this voting polls got errors,THE MODERATORS CHANGED Them so the correct votes is US present votes - 34 votes(what I am reading now is 44 so 44-34=10 the correct vote should be 10 thats the correct one.SO roughly the votes are about the same,AND DONT ASK ME WHY THE MODERATORS WANT TO CHANGE THEM I HAVE NO IDEA Either and it is so obvious that they change them!From 0 jumped to 34 (i was here round the clock that time so i knew it),the moderators have bombarded this poll anyway its ok ,its fun n games anyway

You need to chill too. The poll result really doesn't matter cause most of would just laugh at its topic. And remember people speak English in here and nationality > rationality. Not that I have anything to do with those two since I really think the poll is dumb...
 
Originally posted by FearlessLeader2
Have any of you non-Chinese read the White Papers? I urge you to do so. It's really chilling stuff:eek:, when it isn't totally obtuse:confused:. The only part I'd exempt from those blanket statements is the part about what the Western religious missionaries did there in the Victorian age.

Can you summerize it for me? It's already 5Am and I'm a bit tire. Damn civ3:D

Did you know that recently the Pope offically apologize to the Chinese government for what western missionaries did to Chinese people in the early 1900? The news said the pope hoped to restablish relationship with China

:)
 
Well i got every reason the mods change them.At first there is 2 options one is China and the other one is US.At first China votes was 4 US votes was 0.Suddenly this poll was moved from Off Topic To World History.Another option appeared in the poll "Others please specify" .From votes of 0 it jumped to 34.Beside not many people are voicing their opinions here (except some of our talkative members here) ,it is obvious they bombarded the poll.Anyway it dont matters,call me stupid to post this poll,but i post this poll because of ...... read this site and u know why i post it!http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=6799&perpage=20&pagenumber=1
Take note of BRANDON749 's speech in that site!he angered me indirectly maybe I was overexcite that time to post this poll?anyway i am wrong too!
 
Originally posted by Fayadi
Well i got every reason the mods change them.At first there is 2 options one is China and the other one is US.At first China votes was 4 US votes was 0.Suddenly this poll was moved from Off Topic To World History.Another option appeared in the poll "Others please specify" .From votes of 0 it jumped to 34.Beside not many people are voicing their opinions here (except some of our talkative members here) ,it is obvious they bombarded the poll.Anyway it dont matters,call me stupid to post this poll,but i post this poll because of ...... read this site and u know why i post it!http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=6799&perpage=20&pagenumber=1
Take note of BRANDON749 's speech in that site!he angered me indirectly maybe I was overexcite that time to post this poll?anyway i am wrong too!

WHO CARES, THIS IS THE INTERNET, everything's possible. You are lowering yourself to people who you dismiss. It doesn't really matter the poll result cause as I just said, most sensible people would take a look at the topic and sneer. Just don't talk about the poll result, please, you aren't going to get justice in an INTERNET forum(if they indeed changed it, and no, I don't need you to state your prove AGAIN)

Do you know that many, if not most American are self-centered? As a Canadian we all surely experience this brainwahsed American kids who thing "American the greatest of all times of everything of everywhere" Blah, wait until they run out of fresh water and start beggin us :p

Some American are very intellectual, most aren't. Let me tell you a trend:
they are getting dumber over time:D
 
APOLOGISE LETTER:

Fayadi has apologised for posting an insane thread ,boasting about China(which could hurt China's Image) and dont think bad of Fayadi because of this thread or any other else.He is overexcited that time and he had finally woken up!Dont think him being brainwashed by Govt,he is not!He is not communist racist!End Topic!Meet each other next time in a more sensible thread cya!
 
Your English teacher needs the sack. Although I can't really speak as your English is better than my Chinese.

To say one nation or chose a nation that has contributed the most to human civilisation throughout history is IMO impossible to do.

I think your goverment is doing a great job of convincing you that China is the greatest at everything!

Ah-So! :goodjob:
 
What ever happened to the Egyptians and papyrus scrolls??? Definitely before china. (real history)

China great??? - For corruption, depravity, intolerance, paranoia, small man syndrome & invasion of Tibet. China may be large but its not great. The sleeping dragon will never truely rise with an inherently corrupt society. The History of china is of corruption. The majority of the revolutions that have brought down any dynasty or government in china has been to the effects of corruption(.) from the peasent revolts of pre-manchus to the republic to the current drive of the communists to try and clean themselves up.
The Chinese are creating their own messes. They created the conditions for their war with the British that lost them Hong Kong amongst other things. Unequal trade with an arrogant attitude. (China has everything it needs with in its own borders - manchu Emperor) Trade means trade. This can be seen in todays historical economy as it was then. America will change it dealings with the chinese too. Its only a matter of time.

The whole who is better than who is a moot point. BUT who has contributed the most to human society - well that can be measured and interpreted differently by who is reading the info.
There are three types of lies: 1) Lies 2) Damned Lies 3) and Statistics (Mark Twain?)

Lets look at who has contibuted the most in the last 1000 years to human kind.

Year 1000 - The Eastern Roman Empire? The Islamic Invasion? Geghis Khan? India? Native American Tribes?

Do any of these matter? War, conquest, death, change, money & resources is what drives human society for the majority of its existance and changes. Not until recent history does this change (the last few hundred years) for truely the benefit of man kind.
Medicine, standard of living, comfort & peace.

Read history people- not the television. Ask MANY questions.
 
didn't I said we should end this thread?

Originally posted by Tritium
What ever happened to the Egyptians and papyrus scrolls??? Definitely before china. (real history)

what about it and what does it have to do with this thread? Just because you put "real history" in bracket doesn't mean it's real history. At least make a link or a reference that support your fact.

China great??? - For corruption, depravity, intolerance, paranoia, small man syndrome & invasion of Tibet. China may be large but its not great. The sleeping dragon will never truely rise with an inherently corrupt society. The History of china is of corruption. The majority of the revolutions that have brought down any dynasty or government in china has been to the effects of corruption(.) from the peasent revolts of pre-manchus to the republic to the current drive of the communists to try and clean themselves up.

SUPPORT YOUR STATEMENT. You did? No, you need to update your history since China had evolved since 1970s. Corrupt Society? That's one hell of statment, support it please. And then you are talking about the Chinese history. Look, that's like what? 5000+ years. Which civilization wasn't in a monarchy? Wasn't corrupted? The point is, who cares? We are looking at the future, not our past. Yes, they are spending huge effort to clean themselves up, doesn't it counter your whole argument?

Oh, just because Dutch people are the tallest doesn't mean they are anything special. And invasion of Tibet? :confused: I don't know, all I can think of is North VS South.....

The Chinese are creating their own messes. They created the conditions for their war with the British that lost them Hong Kong amongst other things. Unequal trade with an arrogant attitude. (China has everything it needs with in its own borders - manchu Emperor) Trade means trade. This can be seen in todays historical economy as it was then. America will change it dealings with the chinese too. Its only a matter of time.

:confused: :confused: READ YOUR HISTORY BOOK, it was the British who demanded an unequal trade with an arrogant attitude. It's about some sort of drugs, can't remember(Heroine?) The Chinese didn't want it but the British force them to accept the trade cause it means $->Britain. I don't blame the British cause the strongest survive, right? The Chinese dynasty(last one) was extremely weak and tried to do something about it but ended up in a losing war. And oh my god, you seriously think US is getting a poor deal from Chinese trade? Are you totally brainwashed? Look how much things made in China cost you and do you think they should give you for free? :confused:

You know what's the BIGGEST problem of your argument? Assume that you are from US, you did not imply anything your governemnt had done that might not live up to the US image. Thus your viewpoint is bias.



The whole who is better than who is a moot point. BUT who has contributed the most to human society - well that can be measured and interpreted differently by who is reading the info.
There are three types of lies: 1) Lies 2) Damned Lies 3) and Statistics (Mark Twain?)

I don't know, I don't agree the topic is event a valid one.

Lets look at who has contibuted the most in the last 1000 years to human kind.

Year 1000 - The Eastern Roman Empire? The Islamic Invasion? Geghis Khan? India? Native American Tribes?

Do any of these matter? War, conquest, death, change, money & resources is what drives human society for the majority of its existance and changes. Not until recent history does this change (the last few hundred years) for truely the benefit of man kind.
Medicine, standard of living, comfort & peace.

Read history people- not the television. Ask MANY questions. [/B]

Just because we are living in the 21th century doesn't mean all our ancestors worth jacks you know. They went thru the bloodshed to create the condition we are living in. About the benefit, you miss one of our greatest invention: Nuke.

Let's not forget our planet will be burn by the sun after 500,000,000(or something like that) years. Until then, why not have peace and just forget our(I mean all countries) past and plan our(I mean all countries) future?



:p
 
Originally posted by Tritium
The Chinese are creating their own messes. They created the conditions for their war with the British that lost them Hong Kong amongst other things. Unequal trade with an arrogant attitude. (China has everything it needs with in its own borders - manchu Emperor) Trade means trade. This can be seen in todays historical economy as it was then. America will change it dealings with the chinese too. Its only a matter of time.
The British drugpushers who called themselves merchants were trying to push thru the sale of opium to the Chinese. They couldn't sell the Chinese anything else cos in those days, China could still meet its own needs w/o resorting to importing manufactured goods fr half a world away.
The war started cos the Manchu official in Canton seized crates of opium on a Chinese ship (flying a British flag). The Brits seized on that flimsy excuse to attk China and force open her market and ports. And the French joined in.
Trade may mean trade but we still need to ascertain what goods are being traded.
 
Originally posted by Tritium
China great??? - For corruption, depravity, intolerance, paranoia, small man syndrome & invasion of Tibet. China may be large but its not great. The sleeping dragon will never truely rise with an inherently corrupt society. The History of china is of corruption. The majority of the revolutions that have brought down any dynasty or government in china has been to the effects of corruption(.) from the peasent revolts of pre-manchus to the republic to the current drive of the communists to try and clean themselves up.
Wow, 5000 yrs of historical existense, 2500 yrs of recorded history is ALL about corruption. What a statement! Do you, per chance, ever studied Far Eastern history previously? :rolleyes:
Maybe you shld wonder why China is large, thru out history, even today. That's cos it was (is?) great; that's why it's large. And FYI, natural disasters played as much a role, or even greater, in the peasant uprisings that toppled some of the Chinese dynasties. Corruption was also a factor but not the only one.
And in particular, revolts against the Manchus were also cos they were revolts of a patriotic and nationalistic nature against foreign overlords. The Manchus were not a native Chinese dynasty!
 
manchus may no thave been native but they were sinocized after a period of time and themselves became just as much chinese as the chinese.
 
Back
Top Bottom