Would Socialist Healthcare Be Acceptable If...

Status
Not open for further replies.

UnendingRequiem

Chieftain
Joined
Mar 24, 2011
Messages
40
Being a conservative leaning libertarian, I obviously don't support universal healthcare. But would it be acceptable if it existed, but the ONLY people who had to pay taxes to support it would be people who wanted it. Everyone else would get normal privatized healthcare. But certain people can choose to have government healthcare, and only those people have to have higher income taxes. And the rest of the population would still have private healthcare, but not have to pay higher income taxes. That way the poor people get healthcare and the non-poor people can still have economic freedom. What are your thoughts on this?

Of course there would be rules. Like people couldn't switch willy-nilly so that way a poor person can't select not to do it, then when he gets sick, decide to do it. There would be rules like you can only change from socialist healthcare to non socialist healthcare and back again once every 5 years, or once you make the decision, you can never go back.
 
I dont think it would work too well as poor people generally dont have much to pay for taxes anyways
 
I agree. Libertarians who don't like to pay taxes can not pay taxes. They should just not be allowed to use roads and stuff. Galt's Gulch awaits.
 
I don't think that'd work. You can't have private insurance companies competing with the billions and billions of dollars the US government would be able to pour into competition.
 
^ counterpoint: every other nation in the world with such a system

but the OP's proposal wouldn't work at all, it's not a feasible way to fund healthcare.
 
I don't think that'd work. You can't have private insurance companies competing with the billions and billions of dollars the US government would be able to pour into competition.

Sure you could. The private sector hospitals are ALWAYS better. USA has the best health care system in the world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom