Would you rather be a superhero or supervillain?

Which?


  • Total voters
    20
I would be neither. I would be a guy with superpowers who doesn't do really extremely evil stuff and doesn't have a lair, but doesn't go out fighting crime on a regular basis either. I would definitely not be wearing a spandex suit or a hat with wings or anything of the sort either. I wouldn't change what I wear at all. I also wouldn't be joining any superhero or supervillain social clubs, I don't have any room in my life for those, all my social energy is fully accounted for. I also wouldn't be saying any snappy one-liners after I use my superpowers, at all.

All of the above seem to disqualify me as a supervillain or a superhero. So I would be neither, I would be a regular dude who occasionally engages in amazing feats of superpowerism.

The drawbacks of being a supervillain seem to be that you have to get into some pretty bad stuff. Killing people, killing endangered animals, stealing babies, beating up the poor, none of it appeals to me at all. On the other hand, being a superhero seems to be a a pretty big commitment too. You need to figure out some sort of a cool looking suit to wear.. I know absolutely nothing about sewing or costume design. I'm not interested in wearing anything skintight or flashy either. So that's right out. As a superhero you also need to commit yourself to fighting crime to some degree, and I'll leave that to the incompetent police forces of our planet, thank you very much. That's their job, I'm not going to get involved. I'd probably just get arrested and thrown in jail. The cops don't like it when you try to do their job. Imagine what would happen if I uncovered some of their corruption or cop crimes, that would just get way too intense for me. I'll stay out of it all, no superhero labels for me. Who am I to be judge and executioner? That's way too much responsibility, and it's illegal to boot.

I'll tell you what I'd use my superpowers for. Some good and some bad. I'd be a chaotic lawful sort of superpower wielding regular guy. I would for the most part occasionally use my powers for good, I would help old ladies off trees if my superpowers allowed me to do that easily, I would stand up to bullies and help out those in need occasionally, I would help my friend build a deck, pick things off shelves that are too high for others, I would look into the future and warn people of volcano explosions anonymously in some convincing way, but this would all be an every once in a while sort of proposition, not a daily crime fighting endeavour.

I would also probably use my superpowers for sneaky things like trying to make some extra money, depending on what sort of superpowers I had, I would definitely scam casinos out of some money if I had superpowers that allowed me to do that without detection.. I wouldn't rob convenience stores, but I would secretly occasionally defraud billionaires, banks, and companies I hate. I'm also tempted and slightly ashamed to say that I would probably partially fall way of Patrick Stewart and use my powers to see some ladies naked. I mean, if I can see through walls, I'm not going to stand here and tell you I'm not going to peek into the showers when the swedish bikini team is in there. It wouldn't be a super common occurrence, as I value privacy, but hormones are hormones. I wouldn't stalk anyone, I wouldn't go as far as Stewart, it would be on the down low, nobody would ever know, it wouldn't be super common, and I would never do it to somebody I know personally. I realize this does not make me a good person, but let's be honest, if you can see through walls, you're going to look through walls.

I would also probably use my superpowers to try to get dates. I mean, let's be honest, it's a very competitive dating world out there, you gotta use every single advantage you have. Focus on your strengths and try to not focus on your negatives, that's what they say. Spiderman did it, so why can't I.

I admit that all of this would probably mean that both superheroes and supervillains would dislike me, so I would try to keep as quiet about my powers as possible. If my superpower was flying, I would not be flying frequently at all. I mean, that's a dead giveaway. I would use my flying powers sparingly. I don't want the CIA to discover that I have superpowers, they would probably try to capture me and stick things up my butt.
 
What if your superpower was just rejuvenation/neotenism? It'd do the trick.
If you need to be a supervillain for that, you can be a vampire.

If I could live as long as I want, but the catch is that I have to suck people's blood occasionally and kill them.. That would be a bit of a dilemma for me for sure. I don't really want to kill anyone, ever, for any reason. But a super long life might be enough for me to make an exception, once I get old enough. I mean, I don't feel good saying that at all, but when it came down to it.. it would probably be too large of a temptation to ignore. Of course I'd only go after the lowlifes in life, the corrupt politicians, police officers, organized crime bosses and billionaires.. but then again that would put me on too many people's radars.. so.. Could I kill someone on death row somehow? That seems implausible too. I guess I'd need to turn into a bit of a Dexter but target those lowlifes nobody will really care going missing. Seems stressful, but if we're being honest, extending my life would be really really tempting. And I suppose if I'm a vampire I'd have certain urges that would lead me to uncontrollably kill people anyway? I don't watch enough vampire movies to really understand the ins and outs of this very well, tbh. Either way, it would be something I'd consider at one point or another.
 
I would be neither. I would be a guy with superpowers who doesn't do really extremely evil stuff and doesn't have a lair, but doesn't go out fighting crime on a regular basis either. I would definitely not be wearing a spandex suit or a hat with wings or anything of the sort either. I wouldn't change what I wear at all. I also wouldn't be joining any superhero or supervillain social clubs, I don't have any room in my life for those, all my social energy is fully accounted for. I also wouldn't be saying any snappy one-liners after I use my superpowers, at all.

All of the above seem to disqualify me as a supervillain or a superhero. So I would be neither, I would be a regular dude who occasionally engages in amazing feats of superpowerism.

The drawbacks of being a supervillain seem to be that you have to get into some pretty bad stuff. Killing people, killing endangered animals, stealing babies, beating up the poor, none of it appeals to me at all. On the other hand, being a superhero seems to be a a pretty big commitment too. You need to figure out some sort of a cool looking suit to wear.. I know absolutely nothing about sewing or costume design. I'm not interested in wearing anything skintight or flashy either. So that's right out. As a superhero you also need to commit yourself to fighting crime to some degree, and I'll leave that to the incompetent police forces of our planet, thank you very much. That's their job, I'm not going to get involved. I'd probably just get arrested and thrown in jail. The cops don't like it when you try to do their job. Imagine what would happen if I uncovered some of their corruption or cop crimes, that would just get way too intense for me. I'll stay out of it all, no superhero labels for me. Who am I to be judge and executioner? That's way too much responsibility, and it's illegal to boot.

I'll tell you what I'd use my superpowers for. Some good and some bad. I'd be a chaotic lawful sort of superpower wielding regular guy. I would for the most part occasionally use my powers for good, I would help old ladies off trees if my superpowers allowed me to do that easily, I would stand up to bullies and help out those in need occasionally, I would help my friend build a deck, pick things off shelves that are too high for others, I would look into the future and warn people of volcano explosions anonymously in some convincing way, but this would all be an every once in a while sort of proposition, not a daily crime fighting endeavour.

I would also probably use my superpowers for sneaky things like trying to make some extra money, depending on what sort of superpowers I had, I would definitely scam casinos out of some money if I had superpowers that allowed me to do that without detection.. I wouldn't rob convenience stores, but I would secretly occasionally defraud billionaires, banks, and companies I hate. I'm also tempted and slightly ashamed to say that I would probably partially fall way of Patrick Stewart and use my powers to see some ladies naked. I mean, if I can see through walls, I'm not going to stand here and tell you I'm not going to peek into the showers when the swedish bikini team is in there. It wouldn't be a super common occurrence, as I value privacy, but hormones are hormones. I wouldn't stalk anyone, I wouldn't go as far as Stewart, it would be on the down low, nobody would ever know, it wouldn't be super common, and I would never do it to somebody I know personally. I realize this does not make me a good person, but let's be honest, if you can see through walls, you're going to look through walls.

I would also probably use my superpowers to try to get dates. I mean, let's be honest, it's a very competitive dating world out there, you gotta use every single advantage you have. Focus on your strengths and try to not focus on your negatives, that's what they say. Spiderman did it, so why can't I.

I admit that all of this would probably mean that both superheroes and supervillains would dislike me, so I would try to keep as quiet about my powers as possible. If my superpower was flying, I would not be flying frequently at all. I mean, that's a dead giveaway. I would use my flying powers sparingly. I don't want the CIA to discover that I have superpowers, they would probably try to capture me and stick things up my butt.
I actually think you should contact Hollywood, as you have a genre-redefining premise here.
 
chillin' with the villains
 
The goodies always win, and who does not want to be on the winning side?
My original line of thinking is different from yours, and since I like open-ended questions I’m not going to say either is incorrect.

I went into this thinking of like the old 1960’s Batman TV series, and I don’t remember if any characters’ storylines actually have any kind of resolution—I think of it just being in a kind of permanent balance.

I'm trying to think of a villain who has a better lair than the Batcave.
I guess I was thinking of Bond movies at the same time, though they’re not really supervillains in the sense that they have any superpowers or face opponents who do. Then again, if as @Kyriakos mentioned and some superheroes don’t have superpowers, I guess you can throw them in too. Besides, lair design is just one of the benefits of actually being top banana if you are so inclined to be concerned with interior decorating, etc. as I am.
I'll stay out of it all, no superhero labels for me. Who am I to be judge and executioner? That's way too much responsibility, and it's illegal to boot.
That’s why if I were a supervillain I think I would want to limit my crimes to those that don’t really do any harm to people.

Some fun supervillainy things I would like to do:

• ruin a snooty night at the opera (one attended by The Mayor, because The Mayor seems to be the most important figure in all of Superland and is always allied to the goodies) by having my language ray-gun make all of the singers perform in Klingon

• take over TV transmission during the most critical moment of the Super Bowl

• switch all of the drinks at a college kegger to non-alcoholic

I liked Frank Gorshin as the Riddler. These kinds of things appeal to me a lot more than actually doing stuff that’s like, really bad.
 
And then a Riot starts
I assume everyone has agency, so if they act irrationally to their objectively inferior sport (go baseball) being interrupted, that’s not my fault.

That could even be a part of my persona—The Bowler! He leaves a single pin at the scene of the caper. (Capers are better than crimes.)

edit: I would also wear a bowler hat, and my base would be in New Brunswick
 
Why not be there and destroy the stadium/kill people?

There’s nothing beautiful about that.

People are like diamonds—you can’t smash them with a hammer, you need to slowly grind them down until they truly sparkle.
 
Bane gave Batman access to rope, a doctor for his broken back, and tv to watch the news from Gotham. And Batman was still dumb enough to use the rope only for safety instead of climbing up to it.
 
Bane gave Batman access to rope, a doctor for his broken back, and tv to watch the news from Gotham. And Batman was still dumb enough to use the rope only for safety instead of climbing up to it.
I don’t have that kind of personality. The brilliance of the 1960’s Batman is that they were having fun. Dark and brooding? Not my style!

Also, The Bowler? My henchmen will be The Pinheads. I guess if I should get some comeuppance, it would also be bowling-related, like stopping me from getting a 300. That’s the kind of zanyness that it needs in order to work.
 
What if your superpower was to forget you have a superpower, your sidekick's role was to constantly remind you of it, and so apart from sidekick he was also antagonist?
 
What if your superpower was to forget you have a superpower, your sidekick's role was to constantly remind you of it, and so apart from sidekick he was also antagonist?
That’s another reason for supervillain, no sidekick. Almost as bad as teamwork, especially if they’re called the superfriends or something—I have friends outside of work, and usually when I’ve found coworkers get together to talk outside work, they talk about work!
 
I would be neither. I would be a guy with superpowers who doesn't do really extremely evil stuff and doesn't have a lair, but doesn't go out fighting crime on a regular basis either. I would definitely not be wearing a spandex suit or a hat with wings or anything of the sort either. I wouldn't change what I wear at all. I also wouldn't be joining any superhero or supervillain social clubs, I don't have any room in my life for those, all my social energy is fully accounted for. I also wouldn't be saying any snappy one-liners after I use my superpowers, at all.

All of the above seem to disqualify me as a supervillain or a superhero. So I would be neither, I would be a regular dude who occasionally engages in amazing feats of superpowerism.

The drawbacks of being a supervillain seem to be that you have to get into some pretty bad stuff. Killing people, killing endangered animals, stealing babies, beating up the poor, none of it appeals to me at all. On the other hand, being a superhero seems to be a a pretty big commitment too. You need to figure out some sort of a cool looking suit to wear.. I know absolutely nothing about sewing or costume design. I'm not interested in wearing anything skintight or flashy either. So that's right out. As a superhero you also need to commit yourself to fighting crime to some degree, and I'll leave that to the incompetent police forces of our planet, thank you very much. That's their job, I'm not going to get involved. I'd probably just get arrested and thrown in jail. The cops don't like it when you try to do their job. Imagine what would happen if I uncovered some of their corruption or cop crimes, that would just get way too intense for me. I'll stay out of it all, no superhero labels for me. Who am I to be judge and executioner? That's way too much responsibility, and it's illegal to boot.

I'll tell you what I'd use my superpowers for. Some good and some bad. I'd be a chaotic lawful sort of superpower wielding regular guy. I would for the most part occasionally use my powers for good, I would help old ladies off trees if my superpowers allowed me to do that easily, I would stand up to bullies and help out those in need occasionally, I would help my friend build a deck, pick things off shelves that are too high for others, I would look into the future and warn people of volcano explosions anonymously in some convincing way, but this would all be an every once in a while sort of proposition, not a daily crime fighting endeavour.

I would also probably use my superpowers for sneaky things like trying to make some extra money, depending on what sort of superpowers I had, I would definitely scam casinos out of some money if I had superpowers that allowed me to do that without detection.. I wouldn't rob convenience stores, but I would secretly occasionally defraud billionaires, banks, and companies I hate. I'm also tempted and slightly ashamed to say that I would probably partially fall way of Patrick Stewart and use my powers to see some ladies naked. I mean, if I can see through walls, I'm not going to stand here and tell you I'm not going to peek into the showers when the swedish bikini team is in there. It wouldn't be a super common occurrence, as I value privacy, but hormones are hormones. I wouldn't stalk anyone, I wouldn't go as far as Stewart, it would be on the down low, nobody would ever know, it wouldn't be super common, and I would never do it to somebody I know personally. I realize this does not make me a good person, but let's be honest, if you can see through walls, you're going to look through walls.

I would also probably use my superpowers to try to get dates. I mean, let's be honest, it's a very competitive dating world out there, you gotta use every single advantage you have. Focus on your strengths and try to not focus on your negatives, that's what they say. Spiderman did it, so why can't I.

I admit that all of this would probably mean that both superheroes and supervillains would dislike me, so I would try to keep as quiet about my powers as possible. If my superpower was flying, I would not be flying frequently at all. I mean, that's a dead giveaway. I would use my flying powers sparingly. I don't want the CIA to discover that I have superpowers, they would probably try to capture me and stick things up my butt.

To some extent, you've described the BBC version of Merlin, played by Colin Morgan. He doesn't like flashy clothes, tries to keep his superpower (magic) to himself because it's illegal in Camelot and if the King (whether Uther or Arthur) finds out, he could be punished by banishment, beheading, hanging, or being burned at the stake. He doesn't hang out with other sorcerers because they're usually trying to kill him, Arthur, or both. He does have snappy one-liners, but they're mostly when he's snarking at Arthur.

He's annoyed by the Druids constantly referring to him as "Emrys" and would really rather not have this grand "destiny" put on him, but when a huge dragon keeps nagging you about it, you should probably go along with it.

He stands up to bullies, doesn't kill endangered animals (unless they're evil), and actually turned himself into an old lady in one episode. He's not above a bit of playful sneakiness, as he helps Gwaine and Percival steal some chicken from the palace kitchen (the cook wasn't too happy about that), and cheats at dice by using magic. Oh, and he and Gwaine steal some horses as well (for a good cause).

He doesn't have a lair, unless you count his room just off Gaius' infirmary. It's nothing fancy, but has a nice view of the castle, courtyard, and lower town. He's a Dragonlord with two dragons, though he doesn't treat the younger one very well. The older one lets him fly occasionally.

Unfortunately for dating, Merlin's only girlfriend turned out to be a shapeshifting Bastet, cursed to turn into a murderous monster at night and a human by day. Arthur kills her, and Merlin takes her to the Lake of Avalon, where she becomes the Lady of the Lake. That doesn't mean the ladies don't like Merlin, it's just that he's very busy most of the time because there are so many nasty people who want to kill Arthur, so his time is divided between chores, accompanying Arthur and the knights on patrols and when they go hunting, and other times when he's using his magic to prevent Arthur from getting killed. Arthur is oblivious to Merlin's magic.

You wouldn't need to worry about the CIA, since it didn't exist in the 6th century.
 
I don’t have that kind of personality. The brilliance of the 1960’s Batman is that they were having fun. Dark and brooding? Not my style!
Same here. My favorite Batman is the one from the old movies. There is nothing quite like a bat credit card and Arnold doing Arnold quips as Mr. Freeze.
 
Back
Top Bottom