You think the US has poor people?

Ecofarm

Deity
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
15,370
Location
Univ. Florida
DAKAR, Senegal — On the day he decided to run away, 9-year-old Coli awoke on a filthy mat. Like a pup, he lay curled against the cold, pressed between dozens of other children sleeping head-to-toe on the concrete floor. His T-shirt was damp with the dew that seeped through the thin walls. The older boys had yanked away the square of cloth he used to protect himself from the draft. He shivered.

It was still dark as he set out for the mouth of a freeway with the other boys, a tribe of 7-, 8- and 9-year-old beggars.

Coli padded barefoot between the stopped cars, his head reaching only halfway up the windows. His scrawny body disappeared under a ragged T-shirt that grazed his knees. He held up an empty tomato paste can as his begging bowl.

There are 1.2 million Colis in the world today, children trafficked to work for the benefit of others. Those who lure them into servitude make $15 billion annually, according to the International Labor Organization.

It's big business in Senegal. In the capital of Dakar alone, at least 7,600 child beggars work the streets, according to a study released in February by the ILO, the United Nations Children's Fund and the World Bank. The children collect an average of 300 African francs a day, just 72 cents, reaping their keepers $2 million a year.

Most of the boys — 90 percent, the study found — are sent out to beg under the cover of Islam, placing the problem at the complicated intersection of greed and tradition. For among the cruelest facts of Coli's life is that he was not stolen from his family. He was brought to Dakar with their blessing to learn Islam's holy book.

In the name of religion, Coli spent two hours a day memorizing verses from the Quran and over nine hours begging to pad the pockets of the man he called his teacher.

It was getting dark. Coli had less than half the 72 cents he was told to bring back. He was afraid. He knew what happened to children who failed to meet their daily quotas.

They were stripped and doused in cold water. The older boys picked them up like hammocks by their ankles and wrists. Then the teacher whipped them with an electrical cord until the cord ate their skin.

Coli's head hurt with hunger. He could already feel the slice of the wire on his back.

He slipped away, losing himself in a tide of honking cars. He had 20 cents in his tomato can.

___

Three years ago, a man wearing a skullcap came to Coli's village in the neighboring country of Guinea-Bissau and asked for him.

Coli's parents immediately addressed the man as "Serigne," a term of respect for Muslim leaders on Africa's western coast. Many poor villagers believe that giving a Muslim holy man a child to educate will gain an entire family entrance to paradise.

Since the 11th century, families have sent their sons to study at the Quranic schools that flourished on Africa's western seaboard with the rise of Islam. It is forbidden to charge for an Islamic education, so the students, known as talibe, studied for free with their marabouts, or spiritual teachers. In return, the children worked in the marabout's fields.

The droughts of the late 1970s and '80s forced many schools to move to cities, where their income began to revolve around begging. Today, children continue to flock to the cities, as food and work in villages run short.

Not all Quranic boarding schools force their students to beg. But for the most part, what was once an esteemed form of education has degenerated into child trafficking. Nowadays, Quranic instructors net as many children as they can to increase their daily take.

"If you do the math, you'll find that these people are earning more than a government functionary," said Souleymane Bachir Diagne, an Islamic scholar at Columbia University. "It's why the phenomenon is so hard to eradicate."

Middle men trawl for children as far afield as the dunes of Mauritania and the grass-covered huts of Mali. It's become a booming, regional trade that ensnares children as young as 2, who don't know the name of their village or how to return home.

One of the largest clusters of Quranic schools lies in the poor, sand-enveloped neighborhoods on either side of the freeway leading into Dakar.

This is where Coli's marabout squats in a half-finished house whose floor stirs with flies. Amadu Buwaro sleeps on a mattress covered in white linens. The 30 children in his care sleep in another room with dirty blankets on the floor. It smells rotten and wet, like a soaked rag.

Buwaro is a thin man in his 30s who wears a pressed olive robe and digital watch. The children wear T-shirts black with filth. He expects them to beg to pay the rent, because there are no fields here to till.

But their earnings far exceed his rent of $50. If the boys meet their quotas, they bring in around $650 a month in a nation where the average person earns $150.

Buwaro expects the children to suffer to learn the Quran, just as he did at the hands of his teacher.

So when Coli failed to return, Buwaro was furious. He flipped open his flashy silver cell phone and called another marabout who kept a blue planner with names of runaway boys. The list stretched down the page. He added Coli's name.

___

His tomato can tucked under one arm, Coli jumped on the back of a bus, holding on to the swinging rear door. He was hundreds of miles from the village where he grew up speaking Peuhl, a language not commonly heard in Dakar.

He could not ask the Senegalese for help. So he got directions in Peuhl from other child beggars, who like him were trafficked here from the zone of green savannah just outside Senegal.

Coli made his way to a neighborhood where he had heard of a place that gave free food to children like him.

"Do you know where you come from?" asked the kind-faced woman at Empire des Enfants. The shelter's capacity is 30 children, but it usually houses at least 50.

Coli knew the name of his mother, but not how to reach her. He knew the name of the region where he was born, but not his village. "My mother is black," he said. "I'm sure I'll recognize her."

The shelter worker told Coli what to do if his marabout came. We will protect you, she said. If he tries to grab you, scream.

Days went by. Maybe weeks.

Then Coli's marabout arrived.

In 2005, Senegal made it a crime punishable by five years in prison to force a child to beg. But the same law makes an exception for children begging for religious reasons. Few dare to cross marabouts for fear of supernatural retaliation.

Coli's marabout entered the shelter flanked by a column of religious leaders in cascading robes that tumbled onto the ground. One of them stabbed his finger at the clouds and yelled out, "The sky will fall down on you if you don't hand over our children."

The shelter is used to such threats. But this time the marabouts had discovered the center's legal paperwork was not complete. They threatened to close the shelter if it did not hand over 11 boys.

To save more than 40 others, the shelter handed over the 11. Coli was on the list.

Back at the school, they beat the 9-year-old until he thought he was going to faint. At night, they dragged him off the floor, doused him in water and beat him again.

Three days later, he ran away again. When he arrived at the shelter, he said: "I want to go home to my mom."

___

To find Coli's mother, aid workers broadcast his name on the radio in Guinea-Bissau. The names of over a dozen children also from Guinea-Bissau played in a continuous loop, like sonic homing pigeons trying to find their target.

No response. Some boys worried their parents might be dead.

"I'm sure my mother is still alive," Coli reasoned. "When I left her she was well, so why wouldn't she be well now?" Underneath his bright eyes is another worry. Will she be angry that he disobeyed his teacher?

Over the past two years, the International Organization for Migration has returned over 600 child beggars to their homes. Several had been hit by cars. Some had scars on their backs. One 10-year-old was so hungry he ate out of the trash. Soon after he returned home, he vomited worms and died.

Almost all the boys had begged on behalf of Quranic instructors in Senegal.

"Cultural habits have been manipulated for the sake of exploitation," said the IOM's Laurent de Boeck, deputy regional representative for West and Central Africa.

Two months went by before a shelter worker pulled Coli aside. His parents were alive.

___

The 13 boys from Guinea-Bissau pile into a bus. Coli screams with glee as it takes off for the airport.

"Is this Guinea-Bissau?" one of them asks as they descend onto the cracked runway and enter the small airport of the nation's capital. "Senegal looks better," says another.

Though Senegal is among the world's poorest nations, it's visibly more developed than Guinea-Bissau, listed 160th out of 177 countries on the U.N.'s human development index. The capital they left had streets clogged with taxis and flashy 4-by-4s. The buildings were tall. The capital they returned to has squat, low buildings and crumbling colonial villas.

"I'm not sure I like it," Coli confides.

As the bus leaves the capital, they pass villages of cone-shaped huts and fields where boys herd bulls. They sing songs, clapping their hands. As they pull into the shelter where their parents were told to expect them, the boys fall silent.

Timidly, they file off the bus. A few of the 12- and 13-year-olds recognize their families. They approach them respectfully, shaking hands.

Coli's mother is not there.

___

A judge tells the parents they will be jailed if they send their children away to beg again. They have to sign a statement promising to protect their boys from traffickers. Most are illiterate, so they leave a thumbprint in blue ink next to their names.

"You sent your kids to hell," the judge says. "You can't say that because you are poor you're going to allow your kids to be abused."

His booming voice ricochets off the cracked walls of the building. The parents stare straight ahead.

But the conditions that made these families send their children to hell still persist.

Many of the villages do not have enough food. Few have schools. In one, the schoolhouse is a bamboo enclosure that doubles as an animal corral. "We haven't had classes here in over a year," an elderly man says as he ducks into the classroom and skirts a pile of bull manure.

The aid group pays for school fees and supplies. But the stipend cannot cover the economic worth of a child. Some of the children returned in previous months now work as bricklayers and goatherds. Others have already been sent back to the marabouts by their parents. The idea of child trafficking as a crime is so new in the region that no African language has a word for it, experts say.

With each passing day, more parents and relatives come, but not Coli's.

On the third day, the shelter pays for another radio address.

By the fourth, half the 13 children are gone.

The others become increasingly agitated. Maybe the radio is broken, Coli muses. His wet eyes fill with the invisible color of worry.

___

Early on the fifth morning, a woman in a pressed peach robe walks up to the shelter.

Coli rushes outside. He stands a few feet away as tears topple down his cheeks. She covers her face with her veil and weeps.

The two sit side-by-side in plastic chairs. Coli's mother looks at her feet. Her family is poor, she says, and she wanted Coli to get an education. It took her several days to reach the shelter because she didn't have $2 for the bus fare.

For more than an hour, Coli cries. Tears run down either side of his cheeks, forming two watery garlands. They meet at his chin and plop down on his collar bone, pooling above his shirt.

She stands up and wipes his chin. They leave, crossing the dusty boulevard.

Her arm reaches around his shoulder and the long sleeve of her robe falls around the little boy. It hides him from the remaining children, who silently watch Coli go home.

___

EPILOGUE:

Soon after Coli left, his marabout traveled to Guinea-Bissau. He angrily demanded to know why Coli had run away.

Ashamed, Coli's father promised to make up for the boy's bad behavior.

He is sending the marabout two more sons.

The only way to end this is to stop the brain-drain with our own lives.
 
Unfortunately it doesn't have enough oil so we're uninterested in it, plus its selling what it does have to China in return for weapons etc, and the UNSC is powerless against China. Zimbabwe is worse anyway. 1000000% inflation, average life expectancy 35. Well done Mugabe your earning your $3,847,383,873,483,748,347,834.32 wage that's £40,000 a year in English money . ;):rolleyes:
 
The thread is not about tyranny. It's about poverty and you people seemed to have missed the point. Ending poverty requires human capital that the 3rd world is greatly lacking thanks to the brain drain.

The only way to stop this is by volunteering our lives as teachers. Maybe you don't know what the brain-drain is, so you could not understand what I was saying.

The Brain Drain

I'm not calling for an invasion to end poverty. Invasions are only good for overthrowing tyranny, not ending poverty. To end poverty, we need a human wave of volunteer educators to flow from the 1st to the 3rd world. That's what I meant with "our lives", you war-mongers. Sorry to ruin your good-ole "Ecofarm is a neocon!!!!" bash fest, but I'm not talking about war here.
 
The thread is not about tyranny. It's about poverty and you people seemed to have missed the point.

The only way to stop this is by volunteering our lives as teachers.

Maybe you don't know what the brain-drain is, so you could not understand what I was saying.

The Brain Drain


I'm not calling for an invasion to end poverty. Invasions are only good for overthrowing tyranny, not ending poverty. To end poverty, we need a human wave of educators to flow from the 1st to the 3rd world.

That's what I meant with "our lives", you war-mongers.

Ending poverty requires human capital. Capital that the 3rd world is greatly lacking thanks to the brain drain.

Au contraire the West only cares about countries it can exploit generally. Luckily the Charity agencies are apolitical.

And considering I'm pretty anti war except for defensive reasons I find that a little ironic. ;) Unfortunately I don't have a hot line to Tony Blair or Gordon Browns bat phone.

I think pro-war idiots neocons are morally turgid sacks of effluent.
 
Au contraire the West only cares about countries it can exploit generally. Luckily the Charity agencies are apolitical.

Don't you understand??? I am not asking for governments to do anything. I am asking for individual people to volunteer to help stop the brain drain. Stop thinking that the government solves everything. Sometimes actual people have to solve problems, and this is one of them.

ps. charitable organizations are largely political. You don't think all the christian aid programs are? Considering that you cannot be gay and be in one...
 
Yes the US has poor people. Not as many as Africa, of course. Africa definitely needs our help.

I don't understand why "stopping the brain drain of our own lives" (whatever that means) has anything to do with the problems in Africa. I know I spend way too much time entertained by CFC. Maybe I could help the world by posting less on CFC, maybe not.

edit - Oh, you were talking about us taking educated from Africa and Asia, leaving the less developed world stuck without skilled labor (it's not all 3rd world anymore... get with the 21st century ;) ). The doctors and lawyers don't have jobs where they live. They chose to come here. We can only hope they care enough to remit some of their wages back to the home country, like so many south and central americans.

Where I'm from, the brain drain is the larger and larger number of kids turning away from math and sciences, forcing us to look outside of our country for the skilled labor we need to run our country. If we solved that problem, the foreigners would be forced to leave and develop their own countries, and solve all their problems... and we could afford to send skilled labor overseas.
 
I don't understand why "stopping the brain drain of our own lives" (whatever that means) has anything to do with the problems in Africa. I know I spend way too much time entertained by CFC. Maybe I could help the world by posting less on CFC, maybe not.

You do not understand what the brain drain is? I provided a link you know... anyway...

It is the loss of educated people caused by a desire to escape 3rd world conditions. If someone gets an education, they move to a city. If they get more education in the city, they move to the capital. If the get more education in the capital, they leave the country. This results in a terrible lack of educated people in the country (especially rural areas), hence: the brain drain.

In order to end poverty (or at least make a difference), we need to stop the brain drain by replacing the loss of educated people in the 3rd world with ourselves. If we move there, and spend our lives educating and working towards a better future, we can reverse the brain drain and make a real difference in poverty. A difference that any amount of aid money to corrupt regimes has been unable to accomplish.

Sure, posting less and working more with organizations that fight poverty might help. But chances are the organization is largely political, bureaucratically inefficient, and merely a support for a corrupt regime (as they give money). Moving to a country to be a teachers, however, makes a real difference and if a few million people did it we would see a reduction in poverty never seen before.
 
Don't you understand??? I am not asking for governments to do anything. I am asking for individual people to volunteer to help stop the brain drain. Stop thinking that the government solves everything. Sometimes actual people have to solve problems, and this is one of them.

ps. charitable organizations are largely political. You don't think all the christian aid programs are? Considering that you cannot be gay and be in one...

DONT YOU UNDERSTAND!!!?!!!?!!11111111one1111"$££t43q08w8-e09 ;):D

And I'm saying that only debt relief and concerted governmental action/diplomacy together will be effective, charity alone is not going to be anywhere near as effective.

Education requires infra structure, infra structure requires money, money requires x, x requires y, and so on.
 
You do not understand what the brain drain is? I provided a link you know... anyway...

It is the loss of educated people caused by a desire to escape 3rd world conditions. If someone gets an education, they move to a city. If they get more education in the city, they move to the capital. If the get more education in the capital, they leave the country. This results in a terrible lack of educated people in the country (especially rural areas), hence: the brain drain.

In order to end poverty (or at least make a difference), we need to stop the brain drain by replacing the loss of educated people in the 3rd world with ourselves. If we move there, and spend our lives educating and working towards a better future, we can reverse the brain drain and make a real difference in poverty. A difference that any amount of aid money to corrupt regimes has been unable to accomplish.

...Except that we have such a shortage of skilled labor that we need to import so many people from asia and africa.

edit - I forgot to read the link. I am familiar with that concept. But you were talking about our own lives, and we do have an internal brain drain that is being filled with the foreign doctors and engineers and such. That is the brain drain I though you were talking about. That's a much longer term solution to the current problems than most people are willing to work on.
 
DONT YOU UNDERSTAND!!!?!!!?!!11111111one1111"$££t43q08w8-e09 ;):D

And I'm saying that only debt relief and concerted governmental action/diplomacy together will be effective, charity alone is not going to be anywhere near as effective.

And I am saying BS. We've being doing that crap for decades without results. I'm not talking about charity. I'm talking about relocation. You can get paid for what you do, just go... that's the important thing.

Education requires infra structure, infra structure requires money, money requires x, x requires y, and so on.

No it doesn't. Education requires educated teachers. The schools exist - they are empty. All that is required is that you go there.

Take personal action, stop waiting for the government to solve all the world's problems.

That's a much longer term solution to the current problems than most people are willing to work on.

I know. But if we don't start raising awareness now, we may never accomplish our goals. There are millions of ex-pats in 3rd world countries around the world working in NGOs, and schools, and with villagers. What we need is another few dozen million of them.

As far as the US suffering brain drain, no. It's not the same thing. Not the same term. Brain drain specifically refers to the LOSS of educated people to other countries. Not a country getting lazy and importing all it's brains. Not the same thing at all. It's not like we import al these doctors because ours go somewhere else. The doctors we import ARE the brain drain that other countries suffer. I'm not asking them to stop comming here. I'm asking us to go there.
 
The only way to end this is to stop the brain-drain with our own lives.

What about the elephant in the room ? Starvation and Aids ?
 
To end poverty, we need a human wave of volunteer educators to flow from the 1st to the 3rd world. That's what I meant with "our lives"...

Yeah that's what I meant by the Sarkastic Civvers' Crusade, but whatever...

But, you do realise this sort of thing would be a monumental undertaking and mobilisation of the masses not seen since forever? I say, we start at the most basic level and go drill some wells. People can't learn properly if they're thirsty and sick from drinking dirty water that had to brought from miles away.
 
What about the elephant in the room ? Starvation and Aids ?

Education is the answer to both. Granted, someplaces simple canot grow food. People should not be living in the desert. They have to be moved. That is a different problem. I merely wish to address poverty where it persists despite sufficient physical resources and due to a lack of human resources. This represents a vast majority of poverty in the world.

Yeah that's what I meant by the Sarkastic Civvers' Crusade, but whatever...

But, you do realise this sort of thing would be a monumental undertaking and mobilisation of the masses not seen since forever? I say, we start at the most basic level and go drill some wells. People can't learn properly if they're thirsty and sick from drinking dirty water that had to brought from miles away.

Of course it is a monumental undertaking and it is something that the environmental community has only begun talking about in the last decade. I'm not saying we stop drilling wells (a short term fix, likely leading to long-term unsustainability). I'm saying we should also, as individuals, implement a long term fix. That is, providing a level of education sufficient to allow people to attempt to pull themselves from poverty. Empowerment is the source of the change. Not money, not wells, not government regulation. Just pure empowerment.

There are plenty of empty schools in places with sufficient resources. Let's go teach in one.
 
And I am saying BS. We've being doing that crap for decades without results. I'm not talking about charity. I'm talking about relocation. You can get paid for what you do, just go... that's the important thing.



No it doesn't. Education requires educated teachers. The schools exist - they are empty. All that is required is that you go there.

Take personal action, stop waiting for the government to solve all the world's problems.

:rolleyes: I can only assume that you think teachers spring magically from the ground when you apply and liberally water teacher seeds. :crazyeye:

Physician heal thyself if you want good education and more educated people a good place to start would be in your own back yard.

Why should I go to a country to be paid virtually nothing and get shot at/ kidnapped by terrorists?
 
Of course it is a monumental undertaking and it is something that the environmental community has only begun talking about in the last decade. I'm not saying we stop drilling wells (a short term fix, likely leading to long-term unsustainability). I'm saying we should also, as individuals, implement a long term fix.

Hmmmm In many places the water table has dropped signifigent amounts. Nothing as serious as mexico or india but we can see poor water management problems leading to problems down the road.

Even with 100% Free education we need to free up the children for school as child labour is often used to feed the family and many are unable to be spared. There also needs to be actual jobs for them to make use of maths and literture. And good government stability to actually ensure the time needed to graduate. What with wars and droughts.

theres a myriad of problems.
 
I still retain that a full-scale invasion and annexation of Africa is the best way to combat all its problems.
 
Hmmmm In many places the water table has dropped signifigent amounts. Nothing as serious as mexico or india but we can see poor water management problems leading to problems down the road.

Even with 100% Free education we need to free up the children for school as child labour is often used to feed the family and many are unable to be spared. There also needs to be actual jobs for them to make use of maths and literture. And good government stability to actually ensure the time needed to graduate. What with wars and droughts.

theres a myriad of problems.

We have to start somewhere. I suggest we start with an action that we ourselves can take, without relying on governement intervention.

Just because there are many bridges to cross does not mean we should neglect to build one. "OH! but there are so many problems" is an excuse used by many to avoid personal responsibility. We can complain about how difficult it is, and we can do something about it too.
 
:rolleyes: I can only assume that you think teachers spring magically from the ground when you apply and liberally water teacher seeds. :crazyeye:

I taught in Kenya. I didn't magicaly grow from the ground.

Physician heal thyself if you want good education and more educated people a good place to start would be in your own back yard.

Do you deny that brain drain is a problem? Do you deny that it is our responsibility to address it? I think the US will do just fine without me being one of a million professors. Besides, I'm a global citizen, not an isolationist.

Why should I go to a country to be paid virtually nothing and get shot at/ kidnapped by terrorists?

You don't have to. I'm not demanding it. I'm requesting it. If you cannot look into your soul and see a need to make the world a better place, starting where real change is desperately needed and possible... fine. No problem. Do your thing. But don't pretend that my plan is impossible, when thousands of people do it every day.
 
Back
Top Bottom