Asian Tsunami. Lessons we can learn from it.

The power plant does need water for cooling though (the seawater condenses the steam), but obviously it should be built on some kind of raised foundation so a wave doesn't wash right over it. What were they thinking?

Don't store fuel rods next to operating nuclear reactors.

Don't use plutonium in nuclear power plants (use enriched Uranium instead)

last, but not least. The population of Japan should abandon the islands and move to the U.S.
 
The power plant does need water for cooling though (the seawater condenses the steam), but obviously it should be built on some kind of raised foundation so a wave doesn't wash right over it. What were they thinking?
They had walls around it. They just weren't tall enough. I'm not sure rasing the whole fundation is the way to go. It might even be useful for the reactors to be bellow sea level.
 
They had walls around it. They just weren't tall enough. I'm not sure rasing the whole fundation is the way to go. It might even be useful for the reactors to be bellow sea level.

Exactly: all around the east coast of Japan there are rather high walls to protect the land from tsunamis.
In the areas with most high density of population Japan built walls as high as 4.5 meters, designed to redirect water in the event of a tsunami facilitating floodgates and channel.
The walls systems actually worked to some extent: it did not stop completely the tsunami but gave people some extra precious time to evacuate.
Without them the death toll would have been much higher.

The nuclear plant was protected by even higher walls than in normal places, and based on a raised foundation.
Unfortunately the wave was even higher then the walls and went over the protection wall.
The plant itself was secure, but auxiliary support units were not and got destroyed.

One of these auxiliary units was the electric generator to power the pumps to cool down the reactor in case of emergency.

In a complex system it's easy to have unseen weak points, and however small they are they can cause huge problems.
We tend to forget that buildings and plants built to withstand earthquakes and tsunami do so only until a certain point (e.g. the wall protecting the nuclear plan was not designed to stop waves taller than 10 meters).
The planet can always throw at us even bigger catastrophes.

In short, the lesson we can take is that we always have to think about contingency plans in case our main "defenses" may get overwhelmed.
 
So in retrospect, what do you guys think we should have learned from the Asian tsunami?

What should we learn from the Japanese earthquake?
God hates Asia
 
I would say that we should always prepare for the worst case scenario and get Bears Grylls to show us how we can avoid it. But some things are just unavoidable and we cannot prepare for every emergency that comes our and just hope to God we are prepared as well as we can be.
 
I would say that we should always prepare for the worst case scenario and get Bears Grylls to show us how we can avoid it.
He already did:
Spoiler :
tzAFs.jpg
 
I heard a geologist on the radio not long after it happened. His lesson: No matter how bad you think it could possibly be, sometimes it will be worse. So the lesson is not to plan for the worst you can imagine, but for much worse than that. And that no planning can cover everything.

Other than mistakes in the design and protection of the nuclear plants, I think Japan probably did about as best they could. If you go for 100% protection against everything, you'll bankrupt yourself.
 
Back
Top Bottom