Ask a red

Status
Not open for further replies.

Richard Cribb

He does monologues
Joined
Nov 5, 2003
Messages
4,291
Since my offer to make such a thread produced unexpectedly much positive feedback, I will give it a try. Before anything else, kindly read:

FAQ 1.0

1. What is the purpose of this thread?
To inform about what socialism and communism, both their ideological tenets, their approach to concrete political issues and history. Judging from several threads, there is quite a few misconception regarding these topics, and they do not always stem from ideological malevolence. It can then serve as a reference thread for every time somebody makes a wild claim about any of said ideologies.
One should also consider the fact that the amount of socialist and communists on this board is quite small to say the least, and it is sometimes difficult to participate in debates which typically are dominated by diverging opinions held by different segments of the societal elite.
2. I asked a question, but it was never answered!
There might be different reasons for this:
- You might be a fascist or a fascistoid. There are about ten of those among the regular posters (anybody interested in a list might PM me), and I have zero tolerance for your kind, while I also don't want to give you any attention.
- Your question might be irrelevant, or impossible to answer. I don't suffer fools easily either, nor pedants.
- You might be a troll. Trolls must and will be ignored. And while not one who typically run to moderators, if you persist I will have to call for the big guns.
- I might have overlooked your question. After all, believe it or not, I am only human.
- I might be temporarily indisposed, see below.
3. This is such a great thread! I am pretty radical myself and I want to assist you in answering some of those questions!
That is highly appreciated, but only after my permission. It goes without saying that I approve of collective efforts,indeed what can be said to be the right-wing equivalent of this thread seems to operate on these lines with good results. I also know that some of you would be a most welcome addition to my team, but I think it is just as evident that some structure has to be kept. To quote one of the classics of socialism; "Confidence is good, but control is better". So in case you want to contribute, PM me and just wait for my approval. Most of you will get it.
4. Who are you anyway who think that you can teach me anything about this?
I am a 43 year old Norwegian male (Well, I turn 44 on the coming Sunday)with a genuine working class background, happily married, for the time being a freelance writer, chess trainer (perhaps I should consider an ask a chess trainer thread as well!) and political animal who according to a particulary slimy poster here would make a great dictator. According to the same source I am also incredibly arrogant. I can only express my gratitude for those compliments and try to live up to it. I have been in the "communist" camp (this involves anarcho-syndicalism as well as marxist-leninism and less ideoligically pure positions ) since my political awakening when I was about 13 and have rather a wast experience in practical politics. As far as my academical credentials goes, while they are in no way necessary ("everybody" can become a specialist on politics), they are both sufficient and mostly relevant. Furthermore, those of you who know me from this board should know that I do possess a certain knowledge about these topics.
I should also make you aware that I might be indisposed at times and that a certain patience must sometimes be demanded by those who post questions. Just a few months ago I was diagnosed with celiaki. While this is in no way a life threatening condition the sensations of a new diet and the possibility that I as a novice in such matters might have devoured something "forbidden" make certain days quite wearisome. Consequently I will then sometimes have to economise with my time and give priority to other matters. But I promise that I will do my best to give everyone the attention and consideration they deserve.

BTW, as I have the thing in common with Lennart Torstenson ( more with him, actually), Mikhail Botvinnik, Mae West and Robert de Niro that my birthday is today, so I pretty much doubt that I will be able to provide to many answers before tomorrow...
 
What is true communism ?
 
How can the problem be handled that many that come from a working-class background do not interest themselves in politics, and how could the problem be solved that not many working-class poeple go register for their socialist party and try to run for something?

So in a simple sentence: what can the socialist party do(or how has it to be reformed), to keep in touch with their base, and not be held hostage by a few "pseudoscoialists" who are in an ivory tower and sold-out to the right-wing stances?

I am especially reminded by the local socialist party organisation in where a popular 37-year old women ("babe" won the party elections) over a union leader who was very sincere and pleaded to reform the party, so it doesn't becomes a populist molog that's shoves to the right with each elections.
 
In a communist system not only the means of production generally are owned by the state but also the means of transferring Information . The Media. How can one have a plurality of opinions in a communist system and in addition have the state be criticized by several Media (newspapers/radio/TV ) , which are owned for example by people with opposite interests , in a communist system ? Can Criticism against the State ever be viable in a communist system ?

And how do we avoid the Government employing a Secret police to oppress criticism against it , since in there eyes they are protecting their interests by doing so ?
 
What state was the closest to "Ideal" Communism in your opinion?
 
A slightly personal question: What working class does Norway have at the moment?
 
Two questions:

1. Does communist doctrine extend beyond domestic social and economic organization, to areas like foreign policy?

2. What sort of things are debated within communist circles? That is, what are some core issues in communist theory in which there is disagreement among mature and intelligent communists?
 
Why will people bother to create economic growth in a communist society?
This is my question as well. But perhaps extended to "Why would people even bother to work, to save, to excel, or to innovate in a system that provides everything?"

From my limited knowledge it appears to me that communism fails to take into account human nature - people are lazy and selfish by default. And it is rewards (money, prestige, more comfortable life etc.) that motivate people to push themselves harder. Unless the human race evolves into a more genuinely altruistic species such a system will only take away what otherwise motivates achievers to excel, and reward lazy but "safe" behavior.

Prior to the shift to "socialism with Chinese characteristics" that was the way the 'communist' society functioned over here - clerks who wished they were postmen, salesladies who wished they were clerks, postmen who wished they were construction workers etc. etc. Everybody had an "iron rice bowl" and so nobody really cared about their work. As long as you do not commit a grievious offense you cannot be fired. The result is ridiculously bad standards of work all around and economic stagnation.

And this is just in a localized country yet which decides it need not compete with the world. In today's globalized world down that path lies madness and economic ruin. Perhaps if the entire world were communist then the competition factor is eliminated but then won't humanity be doomed to an eternal culture of mediocricy?
 
What would anarcho-communists, collectivist anarchists, and/or mutualists, say about Communism as practiced by Lenin, Mao, and Castro? "I told you so"?

Who's red? What makes any/all of the above camps red, or not?
 
Well, I'm popping up at this moment just to wish a happy birthday, which will have the practical effect of placing this thread among those on my subscription list.

I too have a few pre-arranged activities for today, but I will soon be posting some of my questions to you. Hope you don't mind that I bring up some previously held talks up, as my question is based on disagreements I already know we have - since I find it will also help address some common criticism to communism in this forum.

See you soon!

Regards :).
 
*Just edited this quickly to say that most of these questions regard communism, in case that wasn't clear.*

Do you believe the state can really wither away, and who do you forsee taking up responsibilities that used to be performed by the state? I'm thinking of things including (but not limited to) defence, diplomacy, the nationwide co-ordination of healthcare and education, etc.

How can a state wither away while there is opposition to it? What happens to political parties that do not think communism is the right way? I'm asking since communism lies at the end of a long road of reforms. What's to stop the public from changing their mind before the end is reached?

What falls under "means of production" exactly? Would it apply to a little old lady baking cakes in her own kitchen? What about the human mind? Do ideas or creative works become communal property?

What kind of property is allowed to be owned individually?

Would a communist system still use a form of currency as a means of exchange? If not, what would people do for money while travelling abroad in non-communist countries? How would they be able to travel abroad in the first place?


Thanks

PS Happy Birthday
 
1. Do you believe that there has never been a truly communist state? How do you view the USSR or communist China from several decades ago - totally antithetical to your views, or pseudo-communists, or what

2. Do you really think humanity will ever have any sort of classless society? I'm not asking what you hope, but what you honestly think will happen.

Oh, and happy birthday!

EDIT: Oh, and am I one of the fascists? ;)
 
I just popped in to say Good Thread, seems you've got a number of good questions lined up.

Happy Birthday!
 
- You might be a fascist or a fascistoid. There are about ten of those among the regular posters (anybody interested in a list might PM me), and I have zero tolerance for your kind, while I also don't want to give you any attention.
:cry: I knew it. I'm on the list. Admit it.

Anyway, I guess I could still ask a question...

Since nowadays communism is highly disregarded and seen in extremely negative light in the western countries...what do you think communism or communistic thinking has to offer to the world and what kind of role you could see communism have in the world in the future?

And happy birthday good old big red machine! ;)

EDIT: And don't forget the History Quiz question.
 
Can you put this myth down once and for all that Scandinavia and Europe as a whole are not socialist?

I see this thrown around the forums like it somehow makes the United States better to scream that Sweden is a socialist state.
 
What are the main obstacles to implementing communism? Can they be overcome right now or do you see communism as a long term goal?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom