Civ Leader Depiction Elimination Thread

[CPWimmer]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 6+1 = 7 I'm a sucker for a seductress. Certainly more then an under-aged Disney Princess from Poland.
Victoria = 9
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 27-3 = 24 Nothing specific against Cyrus, but this puts Teddy in first place, where he belongs.
Jadwiga = 7
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14
Tomyris = 9
Gilgamesh = 10

 

[Photi]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra =7+1 = 8
Victoria = 9
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 7
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14
Tomyris = 9-3= 6
Gilgamesh = 10

Moderator Action: Restored Victoria & Jadwiga -- Jon

 

[DWilson]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra =7+1 = 8
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14
Tomyris = 9-3= 6
Gilgamesh = 10

You dropped:

Victoria = 9
Jadwiga = 7

 

[Victoria]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 8
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14
Tomyris = 6 -3 = 3 (I do not like her square braids, they could have done better, her shaking paranoia is good though)
Gilgamesh = 10
Victoria = 9 + 1 = 10 (Her graphics are not the best but her tantrums and mannerisms are bang on)
Jadwiga = 7

 

[Kimiimaro]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra =7+1 = 8
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14
Tomyris = 9-3= 6
Gilgamesh = 10

Reasons?

 

[Photi]

You dropped:

Victoria = 9
Jadwiga = 7

Sorry, not sure what happened, i just copy pasted the post above.

Reasons?

Been upvoting Cleo in all my other votes, i like her eye makeup and eyelashes, she's usually easy to friend after the ancient era, she has a nice voice.
TLDR: she's hot

Tomyris has some words when i think you first meet her that grate on me, when she says 'something something balda' or whatever, i don't like the tone and the cadence

 

[WillowBrook]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 8
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 14 - 3 = 11 His eyes sometimes look weird.
Tomyris = 3 + 1 = 4 She shouldn't go yet.
Gilgamesh = 10
Victoria = 10
Jadwiga = 7

 

[Zaarin]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 8
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 11
Tomyris = 4
Gilgamesh = 10 - 3 = 7 -- His design is ridiculous, ugly, and not even vaguely Sumerian. Why not just paint him green and let him say "Hulk smash"?
Victoria = 10
Jadwiga = 7 + 1 = 8 -- No way she deserves to be lower than Victoria or Gorgo.

 

[Kimiimaro]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 8-3=5 - She is the worst of the remaining, and she should be eliminated now. And I hate her. She is incredibbly annoying. Almost every game that contained her, she denounced me for "weak army".
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 11+1=12 - As I said, strong and cultured leader. He should survive to the top ten.
Tomyris = 4
Gilgamesh = 7

 

[Calyxx]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra 5
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 18 (17 + 1)
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 4
Gilgamesh = 4 (7 - 3)

I don't care for Gilgamesh's representation, which is... why is he like that? Trajan, on the other hand, is pretty great.

 

[Guandao]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 5
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 18
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 4+1=5 I like the look of her armor, seems historically accurate
Gilgamesh = 4-3=1 They went overboard with his mythic version, actually would prefer another Sumerian leader than him

 

[Morningcalm]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 5 + 1 = 6 (The character in VI fits the real life Cleopatra well character-wise, and her animations are among the best of the leaders, even if her head is a little large. I resent Firaxis having chosen her, but have to admit they did well representing her, including with her agenda).
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21 - 3 = 18 (Looks too cartoony, speaks of Odin and other non-Christian gods even though Hardrada was a Christian; essentially they could have picked any other Viking leader like Ragnar Lodbrok, had the same agenda, and it would have fit better because of the religion aspect)
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 5
Gilgamesh = 1

Moderator Action: Fixed Gilgamesh vote total -- Jon

 

[Liufeng]

Moderator Action: Fixed Gilgamesh vote total in both above post and this one, which eliminates him here. -- Jon

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19 + 1 = 20 He's very well done I must say !
Cleopatra = 6
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 5
Gilgamesh = 1 - 1 = -2 ELIMINATED He's a bad pick, and not sumerian but assyrian (by the clothes and the fact he speaks akkadian). They totally messed the sumerian civ ...

 

[Guandao]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 19
Cleopatra = 5 + 1 = 6 (The character in VI fits the real life Cleopatra well character-wise, and her animations are among the best of the leaders, even if her head is a little large. I resent Firaxis having chosen her, but have to admit they did well representing her, including with her agenda).
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23
Harald Hardrada = 21 - 3 = 18 (Looks too cartoony, speaks of Odin and other non-Christian gods even though Hardrada was a Christian; essentially they could have picked any other Viking leader like Ragnar Lodbrok, had the same agenda, and it would have fit better because of the religion aspect)
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 5
Gilgamesh = 4

Gilgamesh should be at 1, so Liufeng actually eliminated him

 

[NormalRadio]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 20
Cleopatra = 6 - 3 = 3
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 23 + 1 = 24
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 5

 

[nzcamel]

Gilgamesh should be at 1, so Liufeng actually eliminated him

I think if everyone always put the maths workings in brackets, that will prevent confusion.

 

[Timothy001]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 20
Cleopatra = 0 (3-3). Her head size is out of proportion
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 24
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 12
Tomyris = 6 (5+1) Love her long hair

 

[Eliminator_Sr]

Cleo eliminated in previous post.

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 20
Victoria = 10
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 24
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 8
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 9 (12 - 3): Nyet - he's the worst. I'm repeating my downvote. They should just take his template and use it for Louis XIV and redesign Peter.
Tomyris = 7 (6 +1) Doubling down on Tomyris to stay - she has the intimidation factor and is well designed IMO.

 

[DWilson]

Teddy Roosevelt = 25
Saladin = 20
Victoria = 7 (10-3) My least favorite remaining. I feel like several worse options were eliminated before her.
Gorgo = 12
Hojo Tokimune = 24
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 9 (8+1) She's a great buddy of mine, very relaxing as an interaction. At the least I think she deserves to outlast Victoria, arguably Tomyris también.
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 9
Tomyris = 7

 

[MantaRevan]

Teddy Roosevelt = 26 (25+1)
Props to the dev team for going back and un-warping Teddy's face. If only they were as attentive to our other concerns...

Saladin = 20
Victoria = 7

Gorgo = 9 (12-3)
Let's just get rid of her already. All the other leaders are really good.

Hojo Tokimune = 24
Harald Hardrada = 18
Cyrus the Great = 24
Jadwiga = 9
Trajan = 17
Peter the Great = 9
Tomyris = 7

Moderator Action: Fixed Gorgo's vote -- Jon