@Songkok: Thanks for replying to Andulias on my behalf. You put in a few words what I would have needed several paragraphs for.
Just briefly on the "fanboy" vs "hater" user review topic: If the "haters" generally outnumber the "fanboys" so greatly on user review platforms, as you (Andulias) suggest, then why do games like Crusader Kings 2 (extremely inaccessable at first, seemingly boring to those fond of more action and basically no graphics (= reasons to hate)) get an average of 8.5/10 on metacritic and 4.4/5 on Amazon? Why does Skyrim (that arguably "dumbed down" the Oblivion skill system and as a blockbuster would seem to attract many haters) get an 8.1 and a 4.5, respectively? Perhaps because they are good games? Could the reason that Civ 5 attracts more haters than fanboys (your premise) be that it is simply not good? Just a thought.
Otherwise I agree of course, everyone is different, and ultimately we have to decide on our own if we want to give a game a shot. User reviews can help greatly with the decision-making though. I have found the average ratings to be astonishingly close to my own evaluation of games. But maybe I'm just too much an average guy.
Just briefly on the "fanboy" vs "hater" user review topic: If the "haters" generally outnumber the "fanboys" so greatly on user review platforms, as you (Andulias) suggest, then why do games like Crusader Kings 2 (extremely inaccessable at first, seemingly boring to those fond of more action and basically no graphics (= reasons to hate)) get an average of 8.5/10 on metacritic and 4.4/5 on Amazon? Why does Skyrim (that arguably "dumbed down" the Oblivion skill system and as a blockbuster would seem to attract many haters) get an 8.1 and a 4.5, respectively? Perhaps because they are good games? Could the reason that Civ 5 attracts more haters than fanboys (your premise) be that it is simply not good? Just a thought.
Otherwise I agree of course, everyone is different, and ultimately we have to decide on our own if we want to give a game a shot. User reviews can help greatly with the decision-making though. I have found the average ratings to be astonishingly close to my own evaluation of games. But maybe I'm just too much an average guy.