JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Damn. We're toast.
Darths and Droids Mafia- Game Thread
- Thread starter choxorn
- Start date
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
5 left. Zack has been proven-ish not to be cult. Mergle is working with Zack. I know I'm innocent. Gone 3 killed last night. And I don't know what the hell topsecret was doing.
Out of these 5, I would dare say that there is one trade fed and one cult left. That means one needs to be lynched today for the town to have a realistic chance.
Gone 3 the Celt is most certainly innocent. He killed last night, and unless he can kill as two people, he's town.
No matter if you believe me or not, I am town. One more suspect down.
Zack has been all but proven innocent seven ways from Sunday. If he's scum, this is the game of the year for him.
Mergle has a scanning ability. It's not unreasonable to assume that he got buddy buddy with Zack in order to build townie cred. If that means bussing, he busses hard and from nowhere. The ultimate cover. Or he could just be a stand up guy with a scan. I'd like to see some results.
topsecret is a wild card. So that's where my vote goes for now.
Vote:topsecret
Remember, we have another confirmed townie voting with us in BL.
Out of these 5, I would dare say that there is one trade fed and one cult left. That means one needs to be lynched today for the town to have a realistic chance.
Gone 3 the Celt is most certainly innocent. He killed last night, and unless he can kill as two people, he's town.
No matter if you believe me or not, I am town. One more suspect down.
Zack has been all but proven innocent seven ways from Sunday. If he's scum, this is the game of the year for him.
Mergle has a scanning ability. It's not unreasonable to assume that he got buddy buddy with Zack in order to build townie cred. If that means bussing, he busses hard and from nowhere. The ultimate cover. Or he could just be a stand up guy with a scan. I'd like to see some results.
topsecret is a wild card. So that's where my vote goes for now.
Vote:topsecret
Remember, we have another confirmed townie voting with us in BL.
Gone 3 the Celt is town. What Buddha says on that is true, and in addition, I scanned him last night.
And yes, it looks like one trade fed and one cult left. And Zack is town, as I showed yesterday. What's more, I've previously scanned topsecret as town. That doesn't make me look good, as it only leaves me and Bhudda as potential scum.
And like Buddha, I can say know I'm town. But unlike him, I have rather more evidence.
My scanning ability is confirmed by my personal goal, which SamSniped scanned yesterday. Zack can testify to that - so can Backwards Logic if his post-death post and vote allows it.
For cult, unless I was setting up my cult leader by suggesting the tracker follow him (see my post yesterday), I just can't be any more than Zack could.
As far as trade federation goes, both he and I voted southernking on a tied vote. Yes, it could be bussing. And I scanned Xenoneb as mafia, and the nature of my scan means I could easily have given a different result than victory condition and been undetectable in doing so. And I've reported others as town when that could be to my detriment by narrowing the pool of unconfirmed townies. I don't know whether I'd have to be stupid or brilliant to do that.
So explanation? I think the last two scum must be topsecret and buddhafish.
topsecret could be cult if my victory scan only detects original victory conditions (I scanned him post-mechaerik). Or he could be trade fed if he's got a scan-fooling ability. In that case, though, he'd also need a nightkill immunity because he was attacked by what appears to be grevious on night 4. Of course, if he had such an ability, it would be an instant-cred way of establishing innocence to arrange for himself to be attacked by his teammate.
Bhuddafish is interesting. voted for southernking, although early and with a weak reason, perhaps thinking that the wagon wouldn't roll and he could gain cred for it later. Was attacked night 2, but not by grevious (note grevious with multiple lightsabres attacked Joan K). His ability and personal goal seem odd for mafia, but not impossible, particularly if his ability is slightly different from how he's presented it.
On the other hand, absolutely nothing to clear him from being cult.
On balance, I'm gonig for topsecret as trade fed and buddhafish as cult.
But another possibility now occurs to me. The dreadnaught may in fact be tied to the cult in some way, and its use on Jarrema at the same time as the imperial attack a ruse to make it appear there was still another faction in play. On the other hand, the imperial killing last night is definitely down to the cult, so there must be a cultist in play.
Buddhafish is the most likely cultist. vote: Buddhafish. If my final idea is right, then that should give a town win. If not, then there's probably a trade fed about, and I can't see how it's anyone other than topsecret.
And yes, it looks like one trade fed and one cult left. And Zack is town, as I showed yesterday. What's more, I've previously scanned topsecret as town. That doesn't make me look good, as it only leaves me and Bhudda as potential scum.
And like Buddha, I can say know I'm town. But unlike him, I have rather more evidence.
My scanning ability is confirmed by my personal goal, which SamSniped scanned yesterday. Zack can testify to that - so can Backwards Logic if his post-death post and vote allows it.
For cult, unless I was setting up my cult leader by suggesting the tracker follow him (see my post yesterday), I just can't be any more than Zack could.
As far as trade federation goes, both he and I voted southernking on a tied vote. Yes, it could be bussing. And I scanned Xenoneb as mafia, and the nature of my scan means I could easily have given a different result than victory condition and been undetectable in doing so. And I've reported others as town when that could be to my detriment by narrowing the pool of unconfirmed townies. I don't know whether I'd have to be stupid or brilliant to do that.
So explanation? I think the last two scum must be topsecret and buddhafish.
topsecret could be cult if my victory scan only detects original victory conditions (I scanned him post-mechaerik). Or he could be trade fed if he's got a scan-fooling ability. In that case, though, he'd also need a nightkill immunity because he was attacked by what appears to be grevious on night 4. Of course, if he had such an ability, it would be an instant-cred way of establishing innocence to arrange for himself to be attacked by his teammate.
Bhuddafish is interesting. voted for southernking, although early and with a weak reason, perhaps thinking that the wagon wouldn't roll and he could gain cred for it later. Was attacked night 2, but not by grevious (note grevious with multiple lightsabres attacked Joan K). His ability and personal goal seem odd for mafia, but not impossible, particularly if his ability is slightly different from how he's presented it.
On the other hand, absolutely nothing to clear him from being cult.
On balance, I'm gonig for topsecret as trade fed and buddhafish as cult.
But another possibility now occurs to me. The dreadnaught may in fact be tied to the cult in some way, and its use on Jarrema at the same time as the imperial attack a ruse to make it appear there was still another faction in play. On the other hand, the imperial killing last night is definitely down to the cult, so there must be a cultist in play.
Buddhafish is the most likely cultist. vote: Buddhafish. If my final idea is right, then that should give a town win. If not, then there's probably a trade fed about, and I can't see how it's anyone other than topsecret.
Sorry, omitted one point on the night 2 doings. I presume one figure with a single lightsabre was serial killer BSmith, and the second one was Gone 3. Together with Grevious (who attacked JoanK), that makes up all the lightsabre wielders we've seen.
I have to go to the hospital with my dad, and I don't know when I'll be back, so I'll post what I've got so far: (not much...)
Alright, we're down to the wire here. The only two suspects are apparently me and Buddhafish, I will role reveal. My role is Wuher, the bartender at the cantina in Mos Eisley, and my ability keeps me safe from night-kills. Though I'm not sure if I could survive a Space Dreadnought, it keeps me safe from all organic beings. And I am a townie, still.
So, here's what's up. There are only 5 options left:
Zack
Mergle
G3TC
Buddhafish
topsecret
Like I said, I'll be gone for I don't know how long, so I'll see what happens then.
Alright, we're down to the wire here. The only two suspects are apparently me and Buddhafish, I will role reveal. My role is Wuher, the bartender at the cantina in Mos Eisley, and my ability keeps me safe from night-kills. Though I'm not sure if I could survive a Space Dreadnought, it keeps me safe from all organic beings. And I am a townie, still.
So, here's what's up. There are only 5 options left:
Zack
Mergle
G3TC
Buddhafish
topsecret
Like I said, I'll be gone for I don't know how long, so I'll see what happens then.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
All the points that you have raised are valid, Mergle. But we're stuck with a situation where everyone has been seen as town for one thing or another.
I could be a cultist. That would make the most sense. But I know I'm not, and that's a pretty terrible defense.
My vote stays on topsecret. Hopefully he's scum, leaving a chance for tomorrow.
I could be a cultist. That would make the most sense. But I know I'm not, and that's a pretty terrible defense.
My vote stays on topsecret. Hopefully he's scum, leaving a chance for tomorrow.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Night-Kill immunity can very easily be a mafia ability.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Sorry, the first post was an x-post.
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
No heads up Zack that you were going to kill me? I didn't ask for much here...
Oh well, PG time: Gone 3 the Celt.
Oh well, PG time: Gone 3 the Celt.
Zack
99% hot gas
@BL -- If you weren't town, I didn't want to invite shenanigans.
I am town (and have proven so in every way imaginable), Gone 3 the Celts is town (he's been killing at night), Buddhafish is not mafia (based on his demonstrated ability), Mergle is the scanner (and instrumental in taking down the mafia, and contributed to taking down the cult), and topsecret has been scanned town.
Talk about a rock and a hard place.
I'm almost tempted to vote no lynch, and hope the cult and mafia kill each other.
I am town (and have proven so in every way imaginable), Gone 3 the Celts is town (he's been killing at night), Buddhafish is not mafia (based on his demonstrated ability), Mergle is the scanner (and instrumental in taking down the mafia, and contributed to taking down the cult), and topsecret has been scanned town.
Talk about a rock and a hard place.
I'm almost tempted to vote no lynch, and hope the cult and mafia kill each other.
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
Why was Celt scanned last night? He's been in every update - along with the Dreadnought and Stormtrooper killers. Seemed like a waste to me.
Zack
99% hot gas
Just the facts, ma'am (correct me where wrong):
CULT:
MAFIA:
CONCLUSIONS:
CULT:
Spoiler :
MAFIA:
Spoiler :
CONCLUSIONS:
Spoiler :
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
Did you get the Orb back?
Zack
99% hot gas
No, I did not.
It might seem a little far-fetched, but it's the only plausible solution to the problem. I simply cannot envision a possible scenario where Buddhafish is not the last cultist (assuming there's only one cultist left) and Mergle is not the last Trade Federation. Nothing else makes sense.
It might seem a little far-fetched, but it's the only plausible solution to the problem. I simply cannot envision a possible scenario where Buddhafish is not the last cultist (assuming there's only one cultist left) and Mergle is not the last Trade Federation. Nothing else makes sense.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Well something else has to, because that's not how it is.
Honestly, I agree with you. There is no other way that this game could be set up. But it is.
Honestly, I agree with you. There is no other way that this game could be set up. But it is.
Zack
99% hot gas
Vote: Mergle
I think it's the safer bet, based on the unlikelihood of anyone else being mafia. Specifically, I want to hear Mergle expand on his reasoning why someone who was attacked by the Trade Federation at night - topsecret - and who he supposedly also scanned as town is somehow mafia. That doesn't make any sense.
I think it's the safer bet, based on the unlikelihood of anyone else being mafia. Specifically, I want to hear Mergle expand on his reasoning why someone who was attacked by the Trade Federation at night - topsecret - and who he supposedly also scanned as town is somehow mafia. That doesn't make any sense.
Zack
99% hot gas
I also find it interesting how he revealed to me immediately after "scanning" me, and he revealed to Jarrema immediately after being tracked by him; yet, he never revealed himself to topsecret, whom he "scanned" town a while ago. On the contrary, he voted for him and accused him of being mafia.
Zack
99% hot gas
Mergle's "scan" results on Nights 5, 9, and 10, when the Space Dreadnaught was used (as per the writeups):
Night 5: No result - convenient, no?
Night 9: Ravus_Sol has a beard. Oh really, Bail Organa has facial hair?
Night 10: Gone 3 the Celt is town. Obviously, as Backwards Logic pointed out already.
Night 5: No result - convenient, no?
Night 9: Ravus_Sol has a beard. Oh really, Bail Organa has facial hair?
Night 10: Gone 3 the Celt is town. Obviously, as Backwards Logic pointed out already.
Similar threads
