Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Based on the inconsistencies in ATPG's stories, plus the fact that he has been consistently wrong about BSmith, plus Zack's helpful analysis, I am going to vote: ATPG.
[Game thread] Smurf Mafia
- Thread starter Kennigit
- Start date
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
people shouldn't read into the method of death of the updates closely, if at all. I just like "blue hue" 'cuz it rhymes.
robbiecon
Savoy Truffle
I can guarantee BSmith is not responsible for either death last night. I roleblocked him. Also, atpg, I thought you were going after jht last night?
Zack
99% hot gas
robbiecon
Savoy Truffle
Very well, and what dost thou think of atpg's somewhat gung-ho methods?
azzaman333
meh
I can confirm that my opera ticket brought Smurfette into my possession on night 4, and I gave her to ATPG
This post makes me very suspicious of Verarde.
I'm also getting an anti-town vibe from Dreadnought.
But, I'm going to vote for robbiecon
Who are you, and how did you roleblock BSmith?
Dreadnought
Deity
Anti-town vibe? I'm the only one who hasn't been needlessly lynching innocent townies at this juncture!
azzaman333
meh
You've been very critical of people putting themselves out there to try and lynch the mafia, without giving any alternatives.
Dreadnought
Deity
Yes, because they have been lynching townies, with pretty awful leads as "evidence".
azzaman333
meh
Because we're just swimming in evidence that certain people are blatant mafia, right?
I welcome and encourage you to provide well-reasoned alternatives.
I welcome and encourage you to provide well-reasoned alternatives.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Wow, can't leave you folks alone for a second.
Azzaman had possession of Smurfette and gave her to me because he had no use for her, and asked if I wanted it; I replied that yeah, Smurfette actually boosts my killing power.
As for blue hue:
Zack- all Smurfs are blue, buddy. What are you smoking?
Azzaman had possession of Smurfette and gave her to me because he had no use for her, and asked if I wanted it; I replied that yeah, Smurfette actually boosts my killing power.
As for blue hue:
Zack- all Smurfs are blue, buddy. What are you smoking?
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Also, I was killing CivCube as I stated I was going to. I had absolutely no connection with the choxorn death, which is clearly mafia.
Zack. I realize you want pizza to be guilty so you can lynch him and be the hero. But for your own sake, put some skepticism into your own case on me. You'll thank yourself later.
Zack. I realize you want pizza to be guilty so you can lynch him and be the hero. But for your own sake, put some skepticism into your own case on me. You'll thank yourself later.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Also, every kill of mine causes someone's neck to break or end up being strangled. Check it.
If that was an analysis, then I'll eat YOUR smurf hat.
If that was an analysis, then I'll eat YOUR smurf hat.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Realize this is a quintuple, but check this:
MartinLuther's body was found dead; his enormous corpse laid in the center of the town.
This is the only kill of mine that doesn't involve a broken neck. Reason being, my weapon probably cannot break a neck of a giant, and non-Smurfs are giant compared to my size.
All the Smurfs I've killed have been done via the broken neck, this one is different because the corpse is like 100 times more massive than the rest of us.
That's the only difference AND I'm the only one who has made the claim to have killed him.
And no one else's neck got broken that night.
Check it. Do the math. You're wrong, Zack.
MartinLuther's body was found dead; his enormous corpse laid in the center of the town.
This is the only kill of mine that doesn't involve a broken neck. Reason being, my weapon probably cannot break a neck of a giant, and non-Smurfs are giant compared to my size.
All the Smurfs I've killed have been done via the broken neck, this one is different because the corpse is like 100 times more massive than the rest of us.
That's the only difference AND I'm the only one who has made the claim to have killed him.
And no one else's neck got broken that night.
Check it. Do the math. You're wrong, Zack.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
You are now number two behind Verarde.
I can cross off completely the following people:
Askthepizzaguy- killed a scum, DEMONSTRABLY not the mafia's killer. I mean, *bleeping* DUH, people. Use your freaking heads for Smurf's sake.
Azzaman- wouldn't give Smurfette to me just so he can burn an opera ticket for no freaking reason.
Autolycus- I have proof that he is also, demonstrably, not the Mafia's killer.
I have a strong lean that the following aren't mafia because of private claim information:
JoanK - Believable and more importantly, VERIFIABLE role.
Mat93 - Believable and more importantly, VERIFIABLE role.
And if robbiecon is to be believed, that means:
bsmith 2 - Not the mafia kill-er last night.
robbiecon - too busy roleblocking to be the kill-er.
As such, the person who DID the mafia's kill must be one of the following 5:
Zack 2
Ninjacow64
johnhughthom
Dreadnought
Verarde
I am willing to give NinjaCow the benefit of the doubt simply because I buy it. His simplistic roleplaying and consistency.
That leaves me willing to vote for any of the four:
Zack2- Not quite yet. Let's see if he's capable of crumpling up and tossing out his lousy case.
johnhughthom - was ready to kill him last night but Azza and Ninja asked me not to.
Dreadnought - Needs to claim now.
Verarde- Put him on my top 3 for today anyway yesterday.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Dreadnought
Deity
Claim now? 
I`ve been the only one not buying into the piss-poor reasons for a number of townie lynches, and you think I`m scum?
You're trying too hard, mate.
I`ve been the only one not buying into the piss-poor reasons for a number of townie lynches, and you think I`m scum?
You're trying too hard, mate.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Claim now?
I`ve been the only one not buying into the piss-poor reasons for a number of townie lynches, and you think I`m scum?
You're trying too hard, mate.
You've not been trying hard enough.
Any scumbag knows when a townie is being lynched. Never thinking any of the townies we're lynching is scummy, IS SCUMMY, smurf-for-brains!
Claim or you die tonight.
Dreadnought
Deity
Do it. I dare you.
