[Game thread] Smurf Mafia

Vote: Robbicon, because I find his role claim highly dubious.

Okay.

Why? Can't BSmith verify he's been blocked?

If he lies for robbiecon, they're both mafia and therefore both dead. If you're voting him, thats basically what you're saying they're doing. one of those mafia tactics that no one ever uses because it guarantees a team wipe.
 
This is very interesting but I have a long drive ahead of me and must run.

When I get back, either Zack pulls his head out of his Smurf, or I'm choosing him over John tonight based on that atrocious case.
 
Okay.

Why? Can't BSmith verify he's been blocked?

If he lies for robbiecon, they're both mafia and therefore both dead. If you're voting him, thats basically what you're saying they're doing. one of those mafia tactics that no one ever uses because it guarantees a team wipe.

My role is also that of a roleblocker. I find it interesting that town would have two roleblockers.
 
Okay.

Why? Can't BSmith verify he's been blocked?

If he lies for robbiecon, they're both mafia and therefore both dead. If you're voting him, thats basically what you're saying they're doing. one of those mafia tactics that no one ever uses because it guarantees a team wipe.

I'm going to wait til I see what Dreadnought has to say about this, but I think there is a reasonable explanation that doesn't require both robbie and Bsmith to be mafia.
 
Azzaman had possession of Smurfette and gave her to me because he had no use for her, and asked if I wanted it; I replied that yeah, Smurfette actually boosts my killing power.
Okay, this was all that needed to be said, and I would have moved on.

But you are clearly desperate, and so far your "analysis" of who is townie and who is scum consists of who agrees with you and who doesn't. I went from townie to a vig-kill target because I raised concerns over your claimed possession of Smurfette?

I'm not the one with my head in my Smurf.
 
Anyone else seeing a possible scum team of ATPG, Robbiecon, azzaman and someone else staying quiet?
 
I find it dubious that he would claim roleblocker if he wasn't a roleblocker, after what ATPG said about claiming roleblocker.
 
Two roleblocker claims mean, by definition, one of them is scum.

All votes should be on one of the roleblockers today.

And if you lynch the wrong one, guess what? I kill the other one.

Simple as smurf.
 
Anyone else seeing a possible scum team of ATPG, Robbiecon, azzaman and someone else staying quiet?

Oh you are so dead.

You keep accusing me of being scum when I killed one of them.

You are demonstrating exactly zero actual scum-finding logic. You're saying I'm on a team of five, with two kills, and I used a kill on my own teammate?

If you're a townie, you're the worst townie ever.
 
That was my point. Everyone that ATPG likes is the people who are agreeing with him. Everyone that he doesn't are disagreeing. That's not town leadership. That's a dictatorship.
 
Okay.

Why? Can't BSmith verify he's been blocked?

If he lies for robbiecon, they're both mafia and therefore both dead. If you're voting him, thats basically what you're saying they're doing. one of those mafia tactics that no one ever uses because it guarantees a team wipe.

I did verify I was blocked in the second post of the day, before Robbie claimed he blocked me.
 
When did azzaman get Smurfette, and why the hell did he give her to you, Pizzaman? How could he possibly have "no use of her," it's pretty much host-confirmed that Smurfette boosts everyone's abilities.

I deliberately did not kill anyone on night one. I wanted to be able to establish that I was a vigilante, and N1 is the poorest odds of hitting a scum.
I just want to make sure everyone read this, since it goes against everything askthepizzaguy has ever said.
 
When did azzaman get Smurfette, and why the hell did he give her to you, Pizzaman? How could he possibly have "no use of her," it's pretty much host-confirmed that Smurfette boosts everyone's abilities.

I got Smurfette (in bed :groucho:) on Night 4. I gave her away because I have no abilities, none, nada, zilch. I'm boring old vanilla. :(
 
How'd you bed her with no abilities? And why'd you give her to askthepizzaguy?

Opera ticket. Chicks love the opera.

I gave it to ATPG because I knew he had an ability, so he'd be helped by Smurfette. He's also a very strong presence in the village, which leads me to believe he's town.
 
Back
Top Bottom