[Game thread] Smurf Mafia

[johnhughthom]

I think it refers to no quoting your initial role PM or any GM-player privy information.

I presume we're allowed to tell each other the results of night actions.

Yes, I don't dispute that, it's whether faking such results would be 'reasonable' I'm unsure of.

 

[johnhughthom]

The cult was eliminated, that's mod-confirmed data.

I cannot be cult otherwise the cult would not be eliminated.

Sigh.

I said two mafia team universe. Two two player mafia teams and a cult with restricted recruiting in a twenty player game isn't so far fetched.

 

[Autolycus]

two mafia teams doesn't make sense. We had a cult that died, and we had a mafia listed as just mafia. However, killing one of your own to establish townie cred is a highly gutsy move that just might work. Ninjacow might not have asked for your signoff before admitting to being scum.
I think you're probably town, pizza, but my plan covers the possibility that you're not, just in case.

Give me the berries.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yes, I don't dispute that, it's whether faking such results would be 'reasonable' I'm unsure of.

If quoting the GM is allowed in any part, but faking quoting the GM is disallowed, the game would be broken by a simple truth-telling exercise.

Hey, ATPG, quote what the GM told you last night.

-Ok

(quotes GM)

Gm doesn't wog me, I've told the truth.

As such, that's going to be an absurd extrapolation. Obviously we can forge PMs from the GM or else we can't quote him at all.

Watch:

Everyone else is a farty pants except askthepizzaguy

askthepizzaguy number one.

Johnhughthom number two. Smells like it too! Uppercase!

 

[azzaman333]

A two mafia team universe?

If Pizza is mafia, he's undertaken one of the most brazen, outlandish attempts at getting cover that you'd ever see.

This does not rule him out from being an anti-town third party, but it does make it extremely likely that he's not a member of the mafia.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sigh.

I said two mafia team universe. Two two player mafia teams and a cult with restricted recruiting in a twenty player game isn't so far fetched.

Yeah it's pretty farfetched.

Also, it means town loses the game because 2 versus 1 versus 3 means 2 murders.

Basically, if there were 2 mafia remaining, they could vote with Ninjacow and simply tie up the entire round, forcing a town loss.

Even if Ninjacow gets voted in a tie, he dies, and that other mafia team wins.

So, it's silly to contemplate because we're past the event horizon where it mattered.

 

[johnhughthom]

Most games don't have such an ambiguous rule when it comes to host pms, they are either quotable or not.


Anyway, I've decided you've been too grumpy and whiny to be scum, and if you are, and you win, it's a lame and hollow victory.

Unvote; Vote: NinjaCow

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Most games don't have such an ambiguous rule when it comes to host pms, they are either quotable or not.


Anyway, I've decided you've been too grumpy and whiny to be scum, and if you are, and you win, it's a lame and hollow victory.

Unvote; Vote: NinjaCow

I don't do lame and hollow victories.

Capo nonwithstanding. But really, you guys let it happen, so you're just as lame.

 

[johnhughthom]

I take absolutely no responsibility for Capo IV, my life went tits up for the two months around it and I barely participated. Rumour is it was all Zack's fault.

 

[azzaman333]

I'd really like to know what exactly the chocolate does, and how that compares to robbie's role.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'd really like to know what exactly the chocolate does, and how that compares to robbie's role.

I see no reason why you can't be shown the item.

I've never held one or seen one, so it's worth exploring.

 

[johnhughthom]

I've never held one or seen one, so it's worth exploring.

Giggity.

 

[Kennigit]

mm apologies for ambiguous rules I guess on the quoting; it's basically just anti-screenshot.

I've never really seen a problem with rules broken on cfc (including games where there is no private communication, which is the easiest to break) except by 1 troll. So "be reasonable" just covers all bases instead of making a list of 20 rules. and I believe every person in the game played games of mafia before, so it isn't a surprise what is standard mafia behavior.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I just want to point out to people in this thread that there's a-doings a-transpirin elsewhere.

 

[JohannaK]

I'd really like to know what exactly the chocolate does, and how that compares to robbie's role.

 

[azzaman333]

Before I go to bed, I have the following thoughts.

Whoever the most suspected of being mafia has to die today. I get the impression that person is Ninjacow.

Regardless of whether you beleive Pizza is suspect, he must not die today unless someone has evidence that he's is scummier that Ninjacow, and on the mafia team.


If my suspicions are correct on remaining faction numbers, the town is in an extremely precarious position. But I need to think this over some more, when I'm not ridiculously tired and battling to stay awake.

 

[johnhughthom]

Yes azzaman, you really do need to sleep. You surely couldn't be any scummier then, even if you dream you are Al Capone, appearing as a guest star in a remake of the Godfather, wearing a t-shirt saying 'azzaman is scum'.

 

[robbiecon]

Vote: NinjaCow

All berries to Autolycus

I think that's my work for today.

 

[NinjaCow64]

Vote: askthepizzaguy

I have evidence that he is more scummy! While I was eating my lucky cows, I found this PM in my INBOX!!!

Originally Posted By askthepizzaguy

Herp derp I am Mafia.

THAT IS CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE THAT HE IS REALLY THE LAST MAFIOSO!!!

Also my admission that I was scum was a clever ruse to trick the last remaining Mafioso into being silly because I am actually a bulletproof/cop/doctor/roleblocker who is immune from the lynch!!! IT IS THE ONLY EXPLANATION!!!

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Tell us who your partner is, NinjaCow.