[Game thread] Smurf Mafia

[johnhughthom]

Bloody hell, topsecret. I told you in the QT not to post immediately after me...

 

[topsecret]

I'm sorry, but I stink as Mafia... Why do I always get picked as one?

 

[Zack]

What has he done that proves he is a townie?

What have you done?

Unvote, Vote: topsecret

 

[Zack]

Remember who I used to quote in my signature as saying "Let's kill Zack, he has a way of sneakily winning :/"?

If you guessed topsecret, you're right.

Remember who died Night 1?

 

[topsecret]

What have you done?

Unvote, Vote: topsecret

Nothing, apart from offering a second lynch as opposed to a major bandwagon, and waiting for a chance to use an ability that requires 3 items, yet I start with 2.

Remember who died Night 1?

I believe this post includes Metagaming, correct?

 

[Zack]

Nothing, apart from offering a second lynch as opposed to a major bandwagon, and waiting for a chance to use an ability that requires 3 items, yet I start with 2.

That's good practice. Accuse someone for mirroring your own faults. Are you suggesting you be lynched as well?

I believe this post includes Metagaming, correct?

So?

 

[topsecret]

That's good practice. Accuse someone for mirroring your own faults. Are you suggesting you be lynched as well?

It's called sarcasm... you use it all the time, so I thought you might recognize it. Though I'd rather azzaman and I both be lynched, if it means less mafia. It's risk I think we should take, even if it means azzaman isn't Mafia, I tried to find a scum.

So?

It proves nothing (I wouldn't have attacked you until Night 2 ).

 

[Zack]

It's called sarcasm... you use it all the time, so I thought you might recognize it. Though I'd rather azzaman and I both be lynched, if it means less mafia. It's risk I think we should take, even if it means azzaman isn't Mafia, I tried to find a scum.

lolwut

It proves nothing (I wouldn't have attacked you until Night 2 ).

Nothing proves anything. Lynches are based off of circumstantial evidence 95% of the time.

 

[JohannaK]

And since 90% of the times they're wrong, that's why circumstantial evidence isn't enough in Real Life.

 

[Verarde]

Oh, that's right Zack. You replaced DaveShack. Right.

Um, wow vote: topsecret. Your reasoning is crap. Scummy if I ever saw it.

 

[robbiecon]

First two berries to Zack 2.

Second two berries to Dreadnought

Vote: MartinLuther, I'm not convinced by the whole Turqoiside saga. Mafia very very rarely provide any insider info, they prefer to keep their cards much closer to their chest.

 

[Dreadnought]

Unvote; vote: topsecret, his post reeks of a scum trying to "fit in" and provide town discussion.

Mat93 can have three berries and I will take the two berries

 

[NinjaCow64]

And I'm sticking with Turquoiside. Because I am lazy.

 

[Kennigit]

Mat93 can have three berries and I will take the two berries

there's 4 up for vote

I'll post a tally in a little bit, to make sure I get the numbers right

 

[azzaman333]

First 2 berries to Zack, the rest to Choxorn.

Turquoiside

 

[Kennigit]

Tuesday October 9 10:00 PM EDT

[TIMER=10/9/2012 10:00 PM EDT; Day Phase Over][/TIMER]​

similarly topsecret voted for 5 berry votes; but it seems each want to split the berries between a voter and themselves. So at the moment put a ? but otherwise I will change it to 2-2

lynch- 7 turq, 3 topsecret, 3 azzaman, 1 martin, 1 ninjacow
berries
berry 1: jht (2) zack (2) atpg (1) mat93 (1)
berry 2*: jht (1 + 1) zack (2) atpg (1) mat93 (0 + 1)
berry 3*: dreadnought (1 + 1), atpg (1), jht (1), topsecret (0+1), choxorn (1)
berry 4: dreadnought (2), atpg (1) jht (1) topsecret (1), choxorn (1)

azzaman votes not show atm in print screen
*berry votes 2-3 with options for topsecret and dreadnought under considerations

votes:

Spoiler :

+azzaman votes

tally

Spoiler :

+azzaman votes

 

[Kennigit]

also a replacement is likely on xenoneb or optical (both inactive).

 

[choxorn]

Okay, topsecret's last few posts are uberscummy.

Unvote, Vote: topsecret

 

[Kennigit]

I'll add an addendum to the rules that smurf berries (consumable anytime) are also transferable any time. Other items are transferable at end-of-phase, which I believe is the norm for item games (and has obvious implications in this game, where mafia or town could transfer smurfette if being lynched)

i.e. smurfberries can be traded and consumed in same phase

 

[Zack]

All berries to Zack2