[Game thread] Smurf Mafia

[Turquoiside]

Unvote, Vote: Turquoiside And why did you start the game with such a ticket, exactly?

 

[choxorn]

No, really. Having the ability to get Smurfette back seems like something the mafia would have.

 

[Turquoiside]

No, really. Having the ability to get Smurfette back seems like something the mafia would have.

Back? Are you confirming that the Mafia controlled Smurfette? And now you're saying they lost her?

 

[Zack]

Back? Are you confirming that the Mafia controlled Smurfette? And now you're saying they lost her?

Yes, it would appear that choxorn has read the thread. Any other nuggets of wisdom you'd like to dispense?

 

[choxorn]

I have no idea where Smurfette is right now. Maybe the mafia have her, or had and lost her. The mafia certainly started with Smurfette, because Kennigit said that in the Day 1 Update.

But you seem to think they have her and can lose her, so why couldn't they get her back?

Why so jumpy, Turquoiside?

 

[Turquoiside]

IBut you seem to think they have her and can lose her, so why couldn't they get her back?

loolwut. I never said anything like that.

 

[dragonprobably]

Sorry for inactivity, I've been busy and can't access the computer that much.

Turq for PIS.

 

[Turquoiside]

Sorry for inactivity, I've been busy and can't access the computer that much.

Turq for PIS.

You spelled "'cuz it makes me safe" wrong.

 

[CivCube]

Vote: Turquoiside

 

[azzaman333]

Let's lynch azzaman333, because you can't pass a test by not taking it. Yesterday, I asked him what ability or benefit the opera ticket gave him. He said he didn't want to reveal what it did for now, which might have been fine if I myself hadn't started with an identical opera ticket or if I didn't know what it did. His ticket allows him, after Day 3 when the opera arrives, to take control of Smurfette.

You might think at this point, that there's nothing wrong with not wanting to reveal to any and every random person that asks that you have the ability to take control of Smurfette. But there is, because there are three other types of tickets in the game, and if any of them are used the same night as his is, the other person will take precedent and gain control of Smurfette. And since I was given that information with my ticket, I sincerely doubt azzaman didn’t know this either. Why be so secretive on one of the weakest items? The only reason if would be useful then, is for it to be used further in to the game when the other tickets are probably gone. I assume the Mafia has some reason/desire to control Smurfette just like the townies do; and if it factors into the Mafia end-game I think that ticket would be a great item for the Mafia to have in the final days, and that plan works best without the Town knowing its function. Unfortunately, with this game's setup lynching azzaman probably won't get rid of the ticket since he can simply give it to one of his teammates (not sure if that has to be public or not?). Nevertheless, I think the only reason you'd want to have the ticket is for decidedly un-Townie reasons so azzaman should be the lynch and that could be at least one down.

At any rate, as bad as bangwagons usually are, with this setup I’m not sure were doing ourselves any favors by slightly damaging different people each day; it’s not like we can win by letting the Mafia be the only ones killing.

If someone asks what my item does, and I have no read on whether they're mafia, town or other, I'm not going to just give that information away for free. Especially when it's a rather weak item, so I have little bargaining power when what it does is fully known. Since other tickets are out there already, there is no advantage to me keeping it private any longer, so I can confirm that Turquoiside's description of the function of the opera ticket is correct.

Before I make up my mind on whether to lynch you or not, which ticket do you have?

 

[Dreadnought]

My gut tells me Turquoside is not scum -- based on the information in the thread thus far -- and that one between MartinLuther and CivCube are attempting to hide in the lynch for insidious reasons.

I'll go with Vote: MartinLuther for now, seeing as he didn't have the decency to admit to a vote for purposes of his own survival (and the fact that he`s the other lynch target today).

 

[Mat93]

vote: Turquoiside, for PIS, and a bad case on azzaman. You also say that the only reason you would want the ticket is for 'un-Townie reasons' yet you haven't given any reasoning at all as to why you started with one, and why you would be immune from wanting it for 'un-Townie reasons'.

 

[NinjaCow64]

The case on Martin was very weak, so I will Unvote; Vote: Turquoisidd as his post back there was über scummy.

 

[Autolycus]

vote:turquoiside.

 

[johnhughthom]

Vote: azzaman

 

[johnhughthom]

Seeing as nobody else has voted for berries, I wonder if voting them all to me would allow me to attempt to overdose on fruit.

 

[topsecret]

I think we should have two options for the lynch, not one. vote: Azzaman333

As for the berries, JHT for the first 3, Me for the other 2. No greedy eating allowed.

 

[Zack]

Vote: azzaman

I think we should have two options for the lynch, not one. vote: Azzaman333

As for the berries, JHT for the first 3, Me for the other 2. No greedy eating allowed.

What, exactly, has azzaman done that deems him worthy of a lynch?

 

[johnhughthom]

What, exactly, has azzaman done that deems him worthy of a lynch?

His choice of phrasing annoyed me.

 

[topsecret]

What, exactly, has azzaman done that deems him worthy of a lynch?

What has he done that proves he is a townie? Besides, the lynch will almost certainly hit Turquoiside, and I'd rather vote for someone with some votes as opposed to the bandwagon so there are more options. Even a lynch doesn't mean a kill; it means less HP.