- Joined
- Mar 14, 2011
- Messages
- 4,131
Tried to cut the fluff on this, but the last line was untouchable. In any case, what is the point of government manpower on industry? It'd be easier for everyone just to assume pop can work government-owned industries anyway.
It is a separate thing in the economic equation itself. The use of manpower in the economy gives a modifier based on how much is being done. And it's only called manpower because I don't know what else to call it; I could just differentiate between the two as "Private" and "Public" or something to that effect, but then I'd have to find a way to split the two for military recruitment, though I suppose I could just keep the current system of "all military personnel comes from the government one."
But manpower is essentially just a name given to people directed by the government rather than people who work for private organizations, but it is necessary to make that distinction due to the current economic equation.
Not quite sure where this is coming from on the realism front. There are studies on how centrally-planned economies not only ran afoul of growth, but also actually effectiveness during peace time. In any case, this goes back to why not just assume that unused manpower and population work in factories and on farms? In Hears of Iron 3, manpower was largely just that, the amount of men available for recruitment.
The idea is that planned economies are not as liable to dramatic changes. They can steadily grow or steadily decline, where as the growth and declines of free markets are much more dramatic. It should be noted that Industry does have a decay, and because economies that are heavily planned don't grow passively as well as free market economies (or at all in some cases), not investing in industrial growth itself is liable to industrial degradation. On top of infrastructure and stability, that is a lot to handle. Hell, there can be cases where a chain of events can have large economic investment into industrial growth still not match up to how much an economy is declining. Of course that would be an extreme case, but it is very much possible.