Leader depiction elimination thread

[Weraptor]

Amanitore - 15
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 15
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 14
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 24
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I - 5 - 3 = 2 BEGONE AZTEC
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 20
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 18 + 1 = 19 Her angry looks are priceless.
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[Katakanja]

All hail @Weraptor, restorer of balance and the correct scores.

 

[nzcamel]

Amanitore - 15
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 15
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 14
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 24
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I - 5 - 3 = 2 BEGONE AZTEC
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 20
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 18 + 1 = 19 Her angry looks are priceless.
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

All hail @Weraptor, restorer of balance and the correct scores.

So we're good with the assumption that Timodelphia's post was meant to be identical to the one they copied? (Choosing Wihimenia over Gorgo) Cos that is what has been assumed. I'd rather the whole post was discounted... surely.

 

[Katakanja]

So we're good with the assumption that Timodelphia's post was meant to be identical to the one they copied? (Choosing Wihimenia over Gorgo) Cos that is what has been assumed. I'd rather the whole post was discounted... surely.

Wilhelmina was already on 22 for a while. It's easiest to disregard Timodelphia's vote for now, and they can come back if they like and try again

 

[SammyKhalifa]

I must be the only one that thinks Alex's model is fun. A caricature sure, but so what?

 

[Katakanja]

Their vote is yet to be disregarded, Gorgo aside.

Gorgo was the only change they made, which has been reverted. Cleo was already at 15 and Wilhelmina was already at 22. I'm not sure what you're getting at tbh

 

[nzcamel]

Apologies, I miscounted.

 

[Timodelphia]

Sorry for the mess up. Got called away from my desk mid-post. For that matter, I don't even know how it got posted, as I didn't finish it.

 

[Katakanja]

Sorry for the mess up. Got called away from my desk mid-post. For that matter, I don't even know how it got posted, as I didn't finish it.

We got to play detectives unravelling the mystery anyways. Have another go if you like

 

[Japper007]

Amanitore - 15
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 15-3=12 Still a fake, plastic, (word I can't use due to family friendly forums)
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 14+1=15 Gilgabro is such an icon for this game, he should get more love than this!
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 24
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I -2
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 20
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[conorbebe]

Amanitore - 12 (15 - 3) I really, really hate how her idle expression has one eye closed more than the other. It makes her look really dopey.
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 12
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16 (15 + 1) Just a really awesome, charismatic model.
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 24
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I -2
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 20
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[Morningcalm]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 12
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 24 + 1 = 25 (While he likely didn't look like this in real life, he embodies Japan rather well, and is animated nicely. Also, one of the best leader models ingame, his VA isn't over the top, and his selection as Japan's leader for VI was both surprising and excellent.)
Jadwiga - 21
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I -2
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 20 - 3 = 17 (Looks like Solon, not Pericles, and that ridiculous helmet of his, ugh. Also, weak arms despite being a general even in the last year of his life. Pericles in Civ VI looks 80, not Pericles' actual age).
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[LMT]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 12
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 21 + 1 = 23. Unlike Victoria, she seems very mature for her age.
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 22
Montezuma I -2
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 15 - 3 = 12. As others have said, he's way too dramatic. If you hate me so much for converting your cities, then stop whining and do something about it!
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[JonyDrake]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 12
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 20
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - (22 + 1)= 23 / Love his backstory and leader model
Montezuma I - (2 - 3)= 0 / I like the Aztecs, but BEGONE THOT
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Pericles - 20
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[kaspergm]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9 (12-3) I think her model is horribly cartoonish and very bad compared to most of the others.
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 21 (20+1) Upvote for Gorgo, I like her model, it's well made in an unimposing manner.
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22 (fixed)
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

Edit for simultaneous post.

 

[LMT]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9 (12-3) I think her model is horribly cartoonish and very bad compared to most of the others.
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 22
Gorgo - 21 (20+1) Upvote for Gorgo, I like her model, it's well made in an unimposing manner.
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22 (fixed)
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 14
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

Edit for simultaneous post.

Thanks for fixing my error.

 

[Guandao]

Amanitore - 12 I don't really mind her being overweight, but her clothing/jewelry design is a little bland.
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - (22+1)=23 I like her appearance in general (any historical inaccuracies in her garb are forgivable), and her voice.
Gorgo - 21
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - (14-3)=11 Wallace and Gromit style face, and an Agenda which doesn't seem to suit the real life Pedro. He probably would have liked leaders who interacted with "great people".
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 23
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[WillowBrook]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 18
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 23
Gorgo - 21
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune - 25
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 11
Pericles - 17
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 23 + 1 = 24 He's so handsome
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 17 - 3 = 14 Too emaciated to be at all intimidating
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[Sagax]

The three overused, dead-horse, never well-depicted Civ mainstays have been eliminated first. Surprise-surprise.

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 19 I may disapprove the choice of CdM as the leader pick for France, but I gotta admit that she is well-portrayed for what they wanted her to represent. Semi-drunk aloof queen? Check. Meddles with your personal affairs? Check. Speaks broken Frentalian? That's the whole point!
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9
Cyrus the Great - 23
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 23
Gorgo - 21
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 17
Pedro II - 11
Pericles - 14 Nope, it's Solon wearing a bronze spit jar.
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 24
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 14
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22

 

[MantaRevan]

Amanitore - 12
Catherine de' Medici - 19
Chandragupta Maurya - 21
Cleopatra - 9
Cyrus the Great - 21 (23-2)
I'm not crazy about Firaxis' more cynical take on Cyrus. Why have such a cool historical leader if you're just going to get his agenda wrong? So much is wrong with it.... plus I miss Darius's Babylonian Beard.
Frederick Barbarossa - 17
Genghis Khan - 22
Gilgamesh - 16
Gitarja - 23
Gorgo - 21
Harald Hardrada - 17
Hojo Tokimune 25
Jadwiga - 22
Jayavarman VII - 21
John Curtin - 23
Lautaro - 23
Mvemba a Nzinga - 18 (17+1)
About as good a depiction of Alfonzo as we could expect given what we have. Even if his AI's crazy tech is annoying, the character model is good looking with an agenda that fits him historically, and is not too obnoxious to comply with.
Pedro II - 11
Pericles - 14
Peter the Great - 22
Philip II - 12
Poundmaker - 24
Qin Shi Huang - 11
Robert the Bruce - 21
Saladin - 17
Seondeok - 19
Shaka - 18
Tamar - 19
Teddy Roosevelt - 24
Tomyris - 17
Trajan - 14
Victoria - 19
Wilhelmina - 22