Learning the Lessons of Tiananmen Square

Dann said:
Uhh... is that the only function of a railroad? How about as a means of transporting people and materials more efficently? I suppose the US built all those railroads last century just for the purpose of better control over California, eh?
Nope, it isn't. It does have the practical usages. But it also makes it much easier for the government to exert control (or force) on a land that had some degree of autonomy...just because of geographic isolation. Well, all but Lhasa. It looks like bringing those villages into the fold would be the next move. This is in addition to diluting the Tibetan influence in the land by moving families and discouraging Tibetan-Tibetan marriages and so forth.
 
Dann said:
But then again, what do you expect the police to do?

I've prayed in public areas before, and have never been arrested for it. If a police officer here were to try and arrest someone for praying there is very little chance that he'd make it back to his car alive.

Growing up in a totalitarian state you may not have realized this, Dann, but the purpose of the police is to protect the people, not oppress them.
 
@Hundegesicht
Oh really? Wat about the America's "Patriot" Act? The police here all starting to oppress...
 
Dann said:
I share with you the same disaffection with communism, and the same long range goal, that is for China to eventually become a democracy. But I find some people's calls and wishes for an immediate anarchic revolution, or even worse, overthrow by an foreign nation (ala Iraq) disturbing, to say the least. People here put nationalism and culture BEFORE ideology.

We're already changing, though maybe not fast enough. Give the country some time. ;)

---------{ 300th Post }---------

This, I agree with. If it is possible to make the transition, in China, from a Communist system to Democracy, without bloodshed, then it is worth it. I am not totally convinced that this is possible, but surely it is worth a shot.

---------{ 300th Post }---------
 
I think Dann is Filipino...so there's a chance he spent his years in the Philipines. I still don't agree that someone was taken into custody for prayer, even if the person did get to finish the prayer.

On another matter, I've heard a few dozen have been arrested at the Square today. Any confirmations?
 
Dann said:
Alas, that is precisely why that 1989 movement failed. :( If the military of any nation saw that an overwhelming majority of the people are against their government, they will cross over and join the people instead, for their own interests.

In theory, yes. But, I thought the Chinese government had brought in troops from Mongolia who had no loyalty or allegiance to the folks at Tiananmen Square. I could be mistaken, but I thought they were kind of considered "shock" troops at the time.


andrewgprv said:
The same could probably be said for the USA, always remeber we live on conquered land.

But with that logic, andrewgprv, just about all nations could be considered living on conquered land. There was always someone living somewhere before being invaded, correct?

At some point, I do believe that we no longer bear the guilt of our forefathers, as I had absolutely nothing to do with conquering anyone. ;)
 
Dann said:
@Mescalhead
But then again, what do you expect the police to do? At least the man was allowed to finish his prayer. Not shot on the spot.
Hey man, I just posted the article.


Dann said:
Uhh... is that the only function of a railroad? How about as a means of transporting people and materials more efficently? I suppose the US built all those railroads last century just for the purpose of better control over California, eh?

It's also quite ironic that many railroads in the American West were made by exploitative Chinese labor.
 
Well like Mao himself said: "Change will only come at the barrel of a smoking gun." Or something to that effect. The fact of the matter is China is an oppressive, fascist state that controls 1/6 of the world's population brutally and frankly looks to be gearing up for a world takeover, and they're not going to stop unless someone, internally or externally, stops them. I don't want to offend anyone, but thems the facts, people.

Also Mescalhead, everyone knows the U.S. has treated people poorly in the past, no need to rehash it when those days are long past us, we need to focus on the present here.
 
emm...they control 1/4 of the world pop. just to let u know...
 
Uncle Sam said:
Also Mescalhead, everyone knows the U.S. has treated people poorly in the past, no need to rehash it when those days are long past us, we need to focus on the present here.
Don't accuse me of being a bleeding heart. I was merely stating an fact. It seems as though you're the one with the emotional involvement in this issue.
 
microbe said:
I agree China doesn't have an optimal government and it needs changing, but keep in mind how big a country it is. You cannot teach the concept of Democracy to everybody in one day while the country just came out of a thounsands-of-year Feudalism not very long ago. Nowadays at least China is stable and growing, and people aren't starving and are being educated. Its political environment is becoming more and more transparent and relaxed too.
Yep. Even today, there are two mindsets here. That of the cities and coastal provinces - individualistic, economy-centered, liberal, free of historical baggage, and eager to interact with the world; and that of the rural areas - politically conservative, society-centered, carrying a huge grudge against past foreign oppressors, and perhaps even slightly xenophobic. If the 1989 movement had succeeded then, the communists would have simply turned guerilla just like the Khmer Rouge, and probably gain power again by using the rural masses (just like 1949). Then there would be another Cultural revolution all over again... :(

However, there is hope. Millions of rural young people now come to work in the industrial towns along the periphery of cities. While here, they get exposed to new ideas, concepts and thoughts (along with fashion, McDonalds and MTV :D ). When their contracts are over after a few years, a lot go back
to their provinces and raise families. In a few generations, we should be able to see a significant change in people's mindsets throughout the country.
The Yankee said:
This is in addition to diluting the Tibetan influence in the land by moving families and discouraging Tibetan-Tibetan marriages and so forth.
Some Han families are moving there, but they're doing it on their own. Nobody's forcing them to.

And how could you discourage Tibetan-Tibetan marriages when being a minority here actually means more priviledges? If anything Han families are looking for any loophole to claim to be an ethnic minority, just so they can be exempt from the one-child policy. :lol: I'm sure the Tibetans would NOT want to share this priviledge with others.

Actually the joke is that Tibetan girls prefer Han boys because Tibetan blokes take a bath only 3 times in their entire lives: upon being born, just before the wedding day, and in preparation for burial. :D I know, I know, very un-PC but I just need to share it with you guys, surely you people won't take it against little ol' moi? :) <--- *trying to be cute*
Hundegesicht said:
Growing up in a totalitarian state you may not have realized this, Dann, but the purpose of the police is to protect the people, not oppress them.
The Yankee got 3/4 of it right. I'm 50% Chinese, 50% Filipino, and grew up in the Philippines. Even in a democracy, the police can become the oppressors if corrupt enough. During the 1980s, if you're walking the streets of Manila at night, and you see some cops in the distance, better find another route to walk, and fast! They just might stop you, frisk you, and conveniently "find" drugs on you. :eek: Thankfully such horror stories don't happen anymore now.
Hundegesicht said:
The fact of the matter is China is an oppressive, fascist state that controls 1/6 of the world's population brutally and frankly looks to be gearing up for a world takeover, and they're not going to stop unless someone, internally or externally, stops them.
No we're not. Too much trouble... Thankless task... You wind up being hated by everyone... :ack: Hmm, sound familiar?

And like alex994 said, it's 1/4! :p
Plexus said:
I kinda wish I was Chinese... then I could be an insurgent. :D
Uh... You realize you could be slowly and agonizingly tortured to death if you really were one? :evil:
 
Back
Top Bottom