Mafia: The League of EEEEEVIL!!! [Game Thread - Concluded]

[choxorn]

Vote Tally:

Gone 3 the Celt: 5 (Autolycus, KingMorgan, azzaman333, topsecret, spaceman98)
robbiecon: 3 (Zack, BSmith1068, Neverwonagame3)
parts: 3 (dcmort93, Darth Feather, SamSniped)
spaceman98: 2 (Kennigit, taillesskangaru)
Neverwonagame3: 1 (sprig)
topsecret: 1 (edse)
Abstain: 2 (Takhisis, Jarrema)

Not Voting: 8 (Buddhafish, CivGeneral, classical hero, Gone 3 the Celt, Mat93, parts, robbiecon, sirtommygunn)

Can you extend the day until after Christmas?

We still have lots of non-voters and little discussion, so this seems like a good idea to me.

Day extended 24 hours, I might extend it more if everyone is still busy.

[TIMER="12/26/2013 12:00 AM PST"][/TIMER]

 

[BSmith1068]

unvote; vote: sprig. Something is not adding up with last night and I need to get to the bottom of it. If we want a counter-wagon this is a good one for now. Should I get suitable explanation for what happened last night, then I will change my vote.

 

[dcmort93]

unvote; vote: sprig. Something is not adding up with last night and I need to get to the bottom of it. If we want a counter-wagon this is a good one for now. Should I get suitable explanation for what happened last night, then I will change my vote.

Could you perhaps elaborate on this? What isn't adding up?

 

[BSmith1068]

Night actions and results of said night actions.

 

[Neverwonagame3]

BSmith1068, could you please elaborate further? Remember, most of us aren't following your chain of reasoning- it's best if you spell it out for us.

 

[Mat93]

vote: sprig I'm sure theres a reason for BSmith being suspicious of him, and I can understand his reluctance to say in thread why...but before being sprig is (if he is) actually lynched I would like to hear that reasoning. But until then...to me its the best lead out there.

FoS: Neverwonagame3. Some of the things hes said in thread seem very much like info fishing, and I have a bad feeling there.


Also everyone voting for Gone 3 the celt and parts, why? choxorn said they have 'vanished off the face of the earth', or in other words haven't even read their role PMs and be replaced shortly...they could have good abilities, but are no more likely to be scum than picking someone at random unless I'm missing something. Lurkers sure, but complete inactives...seems a waste to me.

 

[Kennigit]

Also everyone voting for Gone 3 the celt and parts.

Cuz they [voters] are scum

 

[spaceman98]

Two things: I am voting for Celt because in the end, lurkers help the mafia (could also be mafia) and we have very little to go off of. But now that the lead with BSmith has emerged, I am willing to unvote: vote: Sprig. Defend thyself

 

[Buddhafish]

Vote: spaceman98

You have been lynch hopping all day trying to start wagons on just about everybody and nothing is sticking.

Why such the enthusiasm?

 

[Sprig]

Lol, bsmith it's you that needs to explain himself. He tried to do something to me last night (probably bus drive maybe) and it seems it didn't work maybe. Either way till he says more there is nothing I can do.

 

[Neverwonagame3]

I say we test it. Vote: spaceman98

 

[dcmort93]

Seeing as how a day has passed and parts still hasn't shown himself, I'll Unvote him.

Sprig seems like a good candidate if Bsmith is telling the truth, but since he is refusing to elaborate on his reasoning, I'm rather hesitant to follow him.

For now I will go with Vote: Spaceman due to his constant lynch hopping. Could be town tactics, but it isn't really helping things too much at the moment, and it honestly is the best case we have so far until Bsmith elaborates more

 

[spaceman98]

Vote: spaceman98

You have been lynch hopping all day trying to start wagons on just about everybody and nothing is sticking.

Why such the enthusiasm?

This seems like a week case, to me at least. We have little to go on right now, so I'm changing my vote as new evidence and new information comes up. What's scummy about that?

 

[Jarrema]

I am waiting for a word from BSmith about what he did to Sprig.
Then, best thing would be to vote for one of them IMO.

 

[Sprig]

This seems like a week case, to me at least. We have little to go on right now, so I'm changing my vote as new evidence and new information comes up. What's scummy about that?

That there has been no evidence for your changes... FOS...

 

[spaceman98]

That there has been no evidence for your changes... FOS...

Really? When I initially voted for Celt, it was because he was a lurker. As I had stated the night before, at that point in time, that was IMO, the best vote possible. Then, Neverwon said something utterly bizarre, when he assumed that each Mafiosi had their own kill. Such an assumption (from my limited knowledge of the genre) could only be jumped to with such confidence, if you have direct knowledge of the mafia's behind the scenes workings, i.e. PIS> As it turned out, there is a type of mafia, where each Mafiosi does indeed have their own, individual kill, and Neverwon is from there. With my previous case de-bunked, I returned to Celt, for the same reasons as the ones which motivated me to initially vote for him. Then BSmith came out with accusations against you. Since Celt, while a lurker (so someone helping the scum through inaction, if nothing else), is still the equivalent of a random vote in terms of likelihood-to-be-scum, while BSmith's claims seem like a somewhat plausible lead (the best we have on the second day), I changed my vote to Sprig. I might change it again, depending on how good the case against you seems after BSmith has had a chance to respond.

 

[robbiecon]

Vote Gone 3 the Celt, spaceman is not a good lynch for now. His reasoning of his actions today is logical.

 

[azzaman333]

unvote; vote:BSmith I'd love to know what it was that inspired the Sprig wagon.

 

[Neverwonagame3]

unvote, vote: Sprig.

 

[Zack]

Lol, bsmith it's you that needs to explain himself. He tried to do something to me last night (probably bus drive maybe) and it seems it didn't work maybe. Either way till he says more there is nothing I can do.

Maybe he's suspicious because it didn't work? And "it didn't work maybe," really? It worked or it didn't.