MOST OVER rated game ever!!!!

[Lozzy_Ozzy]

Starcraft
Diablo 2
FF Series
Halo 2
Civilization 4 (played it for a day)
GTA: San Andreas, I liked Vice City more then this

Starcraft is pretty awesome, when you get into it.

Agree with Halo 2 and San Andreas.

But FF... those games are AWESOME. It takes a bit of getting into though... Everyone that I know that put the effort into it thinks that they are amazing.

 

[diablodelmar]

half life 2. it has a very small range of appeal. Everyone says its so awesome but the only real good thing about it is the graphics.

sure it was a decent game, but it was way too hyped up...

 

[Oruc]

Nope!

 

[conquer_dude]

Battlefield 2 for PS2 it doesnt even have skirmish like the original.

 

[sealboy6]

Battlefield 2 for PS2 it doesnt even have skirmish like the original.

See. A game has to be rated well for it to be overrated. Battlefield 2 on ps2 wasn't, so it can't be overrated.

The most overrated game, I think, would have to be Half Life 2. It looked fantastic, but it didn't have that quality that made me want to play more. Just not good enough.

 

[MjM]

Starcraft is cool. What you smoking emo?

^
Also I noticed you quoted me in your sig. Nice job!

 

[Heretic_Cata]

refering to starcraft

I played the game when it was kinda old, so it always seems subpar to me

BLASPHEMY - how can you judge a game by it's GRAPHICS. Gameplay and story are ENORMOUSLY more important ...
I am not saying we should all start playing only pre'90s stuff but to say starcraft has bad graphics :shakehead you don't know what bad/old graphics is my friend ...

You should be punished - 1 week playing ONLY text-based games should do the trick

 

[Oruc]

Nope!

 

[Haarbal]

Never lagged for me, and i tought it was scary as hell

well, i wouldn't refer to it as scary, but it definitly gave me some adrenaline rushes

 

[conquer_dude]

See. A game has to be rated well for it to be overrated. Battlefield 2 on ps2 wasn't, so it can't be overrated.

The most overrated game, I think, would have to be Half Life 2. It looked fantastic, but it didn't have that quality that made me want to play more. Just not good enough.

Oh it wasnt? I thought it got good ratings (not that I looked to see or anything)

 

[RameNoodle]

Most overrated game ever has to be warcraft three. I played it once, and I swore to never play it again. It was so boring, and I really didn't care what the hell happened to any of the characters. It sucked.

 

[Heretic_Cata]

I didnt even mention graphics in my post, I said I played it when it was old and because it was old when I played it I would have judged it agaisnt newer games which have improved upon the genre.

EDIT: well didnt say exactly that but that what i meant

Well that is preety much the same story with how old it is ... you must still be punished

 

[sealboy6]

Most overrated game ever has to be warcraft three. I played it once, and I swore to never play it again. It was so boring, and I really didn't care what the hell happened to any of the characters. It sucked.

You're so wrong. That game is so amazing. The online is great, as the different gametypes that people have created rock, and the ranked matches are excellent. Each race plays differently, and as usual, blizzard has created a good story. Excellent game.

 

[Dr. Yoshi]

Any 2D fighting game on the Dreamcast. That controller is evil I tell you! Evil!

 

[puglover]

Nationstates is way overrated. It's repetitive even for a free online game.

 

[Thisnameislame]

Need for Speed Underground 2 seems overrated, although I can't really judge becuase I've only played a demo, but from everything I can tell it seems pretty bad compared to Hot Pursuit 2 or Most Wanted.

 

[Heretic_Cata]

Need for Speed Underground 2 is overrated by GAMERS, in the magazines i looked it was rated mediocre.

 

[CornMaster]

Myst
Diakatana (probably spelled wrong)

I actually like Halo...but at the same time...I don't understand the hype around it.

 

[Heretic_Cata]

Diakatana (probably spelled wrong)

Dikatana (probably spelled wrong also ) was EXTREMELY badly rated ... i didn't even play it because every magasine said it SUCKED.
But you are probably reffering to the previews - before the release ... they called the game revolutionary and bla bla , the best game in known history. Those were just previews ...

 

[azzaman333]

Civ 4. Its not really that good. Its always rated 9+/10, when i would give it a 6 at best.