NOTW LV: The Underground (Game Thread)

[Zack]

Or at least provide adequate rebuttals to the two major points I brought up.

I think you're struggling to come up with someone to make a case against because you know you're the orc and no one else is.

 

[Sprig]

it you Zack.

I may be on late to back it up. but probably not.

You arguments are forced, you reacted in Scum Zack manner when pressures. And your ability is a clear fabrication.

But grats on the win when you kill tonight.

 

[Sprig]

my pg is to reduce a scums str to 0

Mechanically that doesn't make any sense.

 

[Zack]

it you Zack.

I may be on late to back it up. but probably not.

You arguments are forced, you reacted in Scum Zack manner when pressures. And your ability is a clear fabrication.

But grats on the win when you kill tonight.

yawn

gotta come harder than that

 

[Zack]

What does any of that even mean? It's so vague and unsubstantiated.

 

[Zack]

Why would I push so strongly for a Kennigit lynch yesterday? There was support for a choxorn lynch in Visor and BL that was waiting for the proper nudge, yet I pushed hard in the opposite direction.

Why did you not vote for Kennigit yesterday? [Because he's your orc partner.]

Why have you dropped the choxorn case so suddenly? Why have you stopped going after BL? [Because no one is going to follow you there.]

 

[Visorslash]

Ypuve hosyed and pkayed notw

Scums have 1 str kennigiy claimed 1st

 

[Zack]

For the record, I had 0 strength Night 4, when the throttler and axe-killer were both actively murdering people (and BL tracked me do nothing). And the poisoner targeted me with the spores N3, so I can't be the poisoner.

And I've claimed an unverifiable ability that I haven't used, so there's no reason I wouldn't be killing.

 

[Visorslash]

I mean we're basically polarised to Zack/sprig at this point so it doesn't really matter

if choxorn is a wolf we lose basically 100% of the time

I'll do some rereading later

 

[Visorslash]

I'm such an idiot

i should've hit zack like i wanted to last night so that the game was locked

 

[Sprig]

I'm such an idiot

i should've hit zack like i wanted to last night so that the game was locked

yeah you should have.

 

[Visorslash]

i mean the game is basically locked now if choxorn is town

im going to go out on a limb and say certain people are resistant to fire and others to poison

 

[Visorslash]

we lynch sprig

he flips town

zack has to kill backwards logic

leave me/choxorn/zack

where i should be able to vote choxorn and he vengeful lynches zack which leaves me sole survivor and town victorious

if sprig is not the final orc of course

 

[Visorslash]

no

choxorn is never COE here

and if he wins as SK because we all overlooked him to fight Coe then that hurts but its okay

 

[Visorslash]

sprig

will you have any free time to discuss itt or on skype? (for like half an hour or so?)

 

[Visorslash]

Here is the voting record:

Spoiler :

blue = dead townie

red = dead mafia

italics/underline = lynched

grayed out = dead, can't vote

• TFA (aka Double A the orc) was replaced first despite others being inactive (ostensibly because he had not been online since July). EQandCivfanatic was replaced by Snerk even though Kennigit was just as inactive. Why has Autolycus not announced that KingMorgan is in danger of replacement, and why did he not say Kennigit was in danger of replacement?

• Backwards Logic, choxorn, and Jarrema were all on both the bladescape and spaceman wagons. The latter two gave little reasoning. This is exactly how they acted as scum partners in A Tale of Two Cities. Backwards Logic explained his votes and pushed others to follow him - he wasn't really jumping on a bandwagon, although IIRC he was not the first to vote either candidate.

• choxorn and Jarrema are also both the only living players to vote for a different confirmed townie each Day. (Takhisis also did this, but he's dead; I have voted for all confirmed townies, but two of those were for the same person.)

• The kills seem random. There's not anything really connecting them and some of the choices are odd.

Now to Double A's posts:


Basically confirms that the mafia blocked Riedquat's vote. This post is horrifyingly lame.




Defends jht.


Also did this with jht. Worth noting Double A also voted spaceman at some point and advocated his lynch even after switching off (the spaceman who was gung-ho about lynching jht). Possible connection there.


Randomly switches to Kennigit for no particular reason. Possibly calling his inactive teammate to action.


TL ; DR

My favorite candidates: choxorn, Jarrema, johnhughthom

this post is really good

 

[choxorn]

Ahem:

Only because I've played 30 more games than anyone else on that Top 20 list.

My survival rate is 20/92, or about .217 (Okay, fine, it's actually 21/93 - or .226 - but I haven't gotten around to putting in that Dethy game yet). You're at .211 (8 out of 38), Zack's at .286 (18 out of 63), and Backwards is at .269 (7 out of 26)

 

[Visorslash]

for the record sprig

if choxorn is town we win anyway by lynching you because we just lynch zack afterwards

 

[Zack]

Only because I've played 30 more games than anyone else on that Top 20 list.

My survival rate is 20/92, or about .217 (Okay, fine, it's actually 21/93 - or .226 - but I haven't gotten around to putting in that Dethy game yet). You're at .211 (8 out of 38), Zack's at .286 (18 out of 63), and Backwards is at .269 (7 out of 26)

Do you have survival rates as mafia/town?

Also vote Sprig already.

 

[choxorn]

I'm pretty sure I did, but just in case I didn't, Vote: Sprig

Backwards: 3/18 as town, 1/3 as mafia (or 2/4 if you count him as mafia in It's a Long Story, which Backwards does).

Me: 14/67 as town (15/68 including I'm Not Crazy), 5/18 as mafia

Visor: 6/32 as town, 1/5 as mafia

You: 10/43 as town, 8/18 as mafia