Zack
99% hot gas
Should have voted me the ammo. I can actually use it. Also, abstaining is bad.
Vote: NinjaCow
Vote: NinjaCow
NOTW XLIII - The Walkingdead!
- Thread starter Takhisis
- Start date
Gone 3 the Celt
MunchieMobile
Police Station
abstain for now, as I need to think this over.
abstain for now, as I need to think this over.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
If we need to go to the radio station, I strongly suggest we get that done today.
classical_hero
In whom I trust
I am formerly of the company and I know what to do with those pieces of paper, so they should be voted to me so i can do with them. So I classical_hero, so be given the papers. My personal feeling is that we should not trust those in authority too much since they are bumbling fools, otherwise we would not be in this situation. I don't really care too much for coffee, my drink is tea, so I say that General Olaf can have a nice cup of coffee. Considering I don't trust the Authorities too much I think we should go to City Hall too see if their is any evidence of a potential cover up.
I want the Coffee. I don't really know anything about the papers, so NinjaCow, classical_hero, and Zack.
Retirement Home, cause I might have left my pills there. And you won't like me without my pills. Actually, I don't have any idea where they are. What are pills? Who are you people? Who am I?
Retirement Home, cause I might have left my pills there. And you won't like me without my pills. Actually, I don't have any idea where they are. What are pills? Who are you people? Who am I?
SouthernKing
crickety cricket
Abstain
Bad Player
Deity
You're the only person to have voted against someone - do you think there are mafia night attacks occurring?
Also that means someone will be lynched today because of your single and now powerful vote.
Bad Player
Deity
If the thief is like the thief from NotW Return of the Baron, they need to know the item and the person holding it. So getting an item publically can cause its loss.
Bad Player
Deity
(double post)
Bad Player
Deity
Another possibility that occurred to me is that noone turns zombie until we are attacked by zombies. But as usual with NotW games I suspect there are 2 mafia teams - so I reckon the zombie creator person is amongst us. And if so, they may become a SK with a gun???
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
THEN WHY DIDN'T YOU SAY SO SIR!? THAT SEEMS AWFULLY SUSPICIOUS SIR! AND OTHER PEOPLE ARE ABSTAINING AS WELL SIR! WHY ARE YOU PICKING ON ME SIR!?
bloody caps.
Bad Player
Deity
Yeah, why is abstaining bad when we have no evidence of mafia amongst us as yet?
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
Interesting statement, considering unless Tak did an entirely unorthodox game and put in no bad guys at all, there's definitely bad guys here present. Just in a public way they haven't made their presence felt as of yet.
I have a theory which I'm going to throw out there. Since we're likely looking at one of two things: either a completely inactive mafia/zombie team or a slow conversion over time of various players at night, I'm inclined to believe the later. Also, we need to look at the updates closely - there's clues in here I think:
Night one - says zombies broke in. Probably did something to one of us.
Night two - does not suggest zombie activity happened at this location. Seems like it actually was an uneventful night.
Night three - Zombies clearly followed us here, though it would seem we stopped them from entering. Hard to say though.
It all could be red-herrings, but then again it could indicate whether or not the zombies were actually up to something. Given that we started at Hannibal's apartment by default and that zombies broke in, I'm inclined to believe it is an indication of something. In other words, the night one zombie moves were scripted by the host and supposed to happen, as we had zero control of the starting location.
Since there has to be at least one zombie among us at the start, I would also think to prevent game balance from being upset early with a lucky guess, this person would have to be unlynchable, maybe permanently, perhaps temporarily until he could gather a few more zombies. We clearly have one unlynchable - TFA which gives some merit to the theory. What also bothers me is the timing of his reveal - If you're townie, why allow the town to waste the lynch by following through with the votes. If you're a zombie, letting the town waste the lynch on you, only to reveal later, only makes sense if there was another zombie within spitting distance of getting the vote lead. During night one, something zombie-ish happened to someone as given by the writeup indicating the break-in.
With no kills, abstaining is the dumbest thing the town can do. Period. Putting pressure on people, seeing how they react and who also reacts is going to be the only way to really tell who's with who. Going back to my theory, we have Bad Player insisting we abstain since there's no evidence bad things are going on, who also happened to push the unlynchable TFA into the lead on day two when he was partially under some fire as well. My guess? TFA is the ringleader, and Bad Player is the night one convert.
If TFA is unlynchable, then I'd go after Bad Player on his moves throughout the game and his most recent posts now. In any event, I think TFA should be vig'd - I doubt he can avoid the lynch and have a pro-town power also. I don't think we can risk lynching him again and having the day wasted. That's what I have thus far. It ain't perfect, but it's better than nothing.
I also think abstaining is silly today. General Olaf. Too many attempts before at what seem like safe votes and wanting to avoid controversy, and other proposals today including the farm vote with no explanation bother me. We're too far along for this sort of blend-into-the-crowd attitude.
I'd say Radio Station now. The Police Station sounds ok, I guess as far as we know not particularly swarming with zombies. Though if you all are not thinking anything other than that it might also have some more weapons, that's not what I think should be top priority now.
It makes little sense to split up and give the papers to multiple people. Well, classical_hero claims he knows a specific purpose but wants them all himself. He hasn't shared his compelling reasons and I personally have given him enough passes already for me knowing absolutely nothing about him. If the papers just have information written on them, it all needs to be known at once, not letting something go to one of several people who could decide they want to hide it and we could lose an important piece of a puzzle. True, one person could decide not to share the information or any other purpose but we'll know it's all on that person's shoulders.
Zack's been really thinking straight plus I think it's unlikely he'd abuse our trust anyway so I'm going with all papers to Zack
Lastly I don't know or care much about the coffee nor has anyone given a reason it matters, so no vote on the coffee from me.
I'd say Radio Station now. The Police Station sounds ok, I guess as far as we know not particularly swarming with zombies. Though if you all are not thinking anything other than that it might also have some more weapons, that's not what I think should be top priority now.
It makes little sense to split up and give the papers to multiple people. Well, classical_hero claims he knows a specific purpose but wants them all himself. He hasn't shared his compelling reasons and I personally have given him enough passes already for me knowing absolutely nothing about him. If the papers just have information written on them, it all needs to be known at once, not letting something go to one of several people who could decide they want to hide it and we could lose an important piece of a puzzle. True, one person could decide not to share the information or any other purpose but we'll know it's all on that person's shoulders.
Zack's been really thinking straight plus I think it's unlikely he'd abuse our trust anyway so I'm going with all papers to Zack
Lastly I don't know or care much about the coffee nor has anyone given a reason it matters, so no vote on the coffee from me.
landlubber
Scottish Nationalist
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2010
- Messages
- 1,534
Bad Player's quadruple post up there is... odd, to say the least. It doesn't seem like his townie mode from what I've seen of him.
Papers to Zack.
Coffee to whoever.
Papers to Zack.
Coffee to whoever.
TheForestAuro
Whisper in the Trees
That really does sound like something I would like to be the mastermind of. Unfortunately, I can't claim to be pulling strings and setting up this massive front of badassery. I assure you that I am not a zombie (I'm a little kid), but any and all further information I would prefer to discuss in private.
I believe we should head for the Gentleman's Club so I can see my first set of boobies. -drool-
I believe we should head for the Gentleman's Club so I can see my first set of boobies. -drool-
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
I've said it before and I'll say it again, sniffing around hannibal's apartment lacked the distinct smell of rotting flesh at the start. I'm not sure anyone was a zombie for the first night, but there's probably a carrier of the Z virus who'd be starting to manifest by now.
Backwards logic has displayed the best logic I have seen yet so bad player.
Also following his logic I am guessing we need to get a fully working gun in order to have a vig kill and be able to defeat the zombies, I have a broken m16 (i thought the others had working ones or I would have lobbied harder for some ammo) which needs tools to repair so hardware store although I am not sure that will be the right kind of tools to repair a m16.
as for the papers, I am just a simple guard, and not all that good at reading, so Zack can have them
I am not a big coffee drinker so Choxorn can have it because he is the last one to have asked for it
Also following his logic I am guessing we need to get a fully working gun in order to have a vig kill and be able to defeat the zombies, I have a broken m16 (i thought the others had working ones or I would have lobbied harder for some ammo) which needs tools to repair so hardware store although I am not sure that will be the right kind of tools to repair a m16.
as for the papers, I am just a simple guard, and not all that good at reading, so Zack can have them
I am not a big coffee drinker so Choxorn can have it because he is the last one to have asked for it
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
Also, classical hero has been a bit bizarre but I can say consistent. It's strange that he voted for the radio station yesterday--when presumably the item he wants (and knows what to do with) are up for vote today.....yes, quite strange.
Now he proposes a fairly worthless location (city hall) on the premise of uncovering a conspiracy....quite strange.
If he knew what the papers did and didn't feel the need to actually go to the location, then I'll let someone who really is looking at whats going on take a gander at those geese. Which would be me,Sam Hammer Kennigit
But before we start panicking and before little timmy's stomach can't be satisfied without human flesh, we need to keep a level head. Classical hero, you got something fishy with you--good that it smells like fish as opposed to rotting flesh though.
Now he proposes a fairly worthless location (city hall) on the premise of uncovering a conspiracy....quite strange.
If he knew what the papers did and didn't feel the need to actually go to the location, then I'll let someone who really is looking at whats going on take a gander at those geese. Which would be me,
But before we start panicking and before little timmy's stomach can't be satisfied without human flesh, we need to keep a level head. Classical hero, you got something fishy with you--good that it smells like fish as opposed to rotting flesh though.
