Zack
99% hot gas
Do you have anything better, Dreadnought? Who are your top suspects? Who is worth pressuring? Who is worth voting?
Pick Your Poison: N20
- Thread starter NinjaCow64
- Start date
Dreadnought
Deity
I find this post a bit odd. Anyone else?
Visorslash fishing for roles seems too much of a scum tell to be worthwhile.
Besides sorting through all the RNG votes, Buddhafish does seem like the first player to "flinch" per say in this game.
and some one already wants me dead
Vote: Samsniped
Random.org told me to vote for the 15th guy :|
Visorslash fishing for roles seems too much of a scum tell to be worthwhile.
Besides sorting through all the RNG votes, Buddhafish does seem like the first player to "flinch" per say in this game.
Mat93
Emperor
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,104
Looks like your trying to take both sides here.
I agree with Zack on Buddha being odd at best, however vote: MartinLuther looks more scummy to me atm.
I noticed the same thing, but held off a bit to see who else would notice it. There are townie reasons for asking that question to an early and no-reason vote, but the scum reasons for asking it are more important. If we're lucky, we can net two scum off the same flinch.
Unvote; Vote: Buddhafish.
Unvote; Vote: Buddhafish.
dragonprobably
The Poster Formerly Known as MartinLuther
And why would that be?
Zack
99% hot gas
Not at all.
He's dead and a proven innocent, anyways.
It seems like you're grasping at straws to try and come up with an alternate suspect to Buddhafish.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Wow. I ask for some reasoning and I get all of this dropped on my head?
He voted first, with no discussion in front of him, and no bandwagon started. D1 is over, so RNG shouldn't be the deciding factor in a vote.
So he must have a reason for voting Sonereal. I was simply wondering what that reasoning was.
I have no information from last night, so I wanted to see what other people thought.
A vote with nothing else doesn't help us catch scum at all.
He voted first, with no discussion in front of him, and no bandwagon started. D1 is over, so RNG shouldn't be the deciding factor in a vote.
So he must have a reason for voting Sonereal. I was simply wondering what that reasoning was.
I have no information from last night, so I wanted to see what other people thought.
A vote with nothing else doesn't help us catch scum at all.
Zack
99% hot gas
Then make a vote with reasoning, Buddhafish. If you are such a bad candidate for the lynch, enlighten us and point the way towards a better suspect(s).
Turquoiside
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2008
- Messages
- 1,552
Well, it is for the same reason, Sonereal's complete absence from the game, though this is even worse since the first phase lasted an entire week. Honestly, what else could the reasoning be when the person in question hasn't posted in this thread at all since he signed up?
Though, I find Zack's case to have some merit. Vote: Buddhafish. A roleclaim wouldn't hurt you at this point, Buddha.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
My analysis so far:
Jarrema followed the wagon. He tends to do this, so it's not out of the ordinary.
Zack. I can't really blame him. He saw something odd and acted on it. At least he had reasoning.
MartinLuther hopped on the wagon early, but Mat93 voted against the wagon to vote ML with no clear motives. Either he knows something about me or ML I would venture to guess.
Dreadnought is on the fence, and I don't believe he's voted for me yet. Interesting, but I have nothing pinging about him yet.
DaveShack. Nothing there, he followed the wagon with a reason. He does that. Ordinary play.
No one else has really posted much of anything today that would make me cast a vote their way.
So vote:MartinLuther. Mat93 seems to think something's up, otherwise he would've voted for me. That leads me to believe that he has outside information that could be useful.
Jarrema followed the wagon. He tends to do this, so it's not out of the ordinary.
Zack. I can't really blame him. He saw something odd and acted on it. At least he had reasoning.
MartinLuther hopped on the wagon early, but Mat93 voted against the wagon to vote ML with no clear motives. Either he knows something about me or ML I would venture to guess.
Dreadnought is on the fence, and I don't believe he's voted for me yet. Interesting, but I have nothing pinging about him yet.
DaveShack. Nothing there, he followed the wagon with a reason. He does that. Ordinary play.
No one else has really posted much of anything today that would make me cast a vote their way.
So vote:MartinLuther. Mat93 seems to think something's up, otherwise he would've voted for me. That leads me to believe that he has outside information that could be useful.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
And Turquoiside, I wanted a cocktail and I got a beer, There's your roleclaim.
Zack
99% hot gas
Good to see your analysis, although I'm not sure why MartinLuther merits a vote over Jarrema.
Yeah, that's part of what seemed weird about it. The reasoning for Turquoiside's vote was obvious; he was voting for a complete inactive. Demanding a reason for voting a complete inactive at the beginning of Day 2 is a weird thing to do.Well, it is for the same reason, Sonereal's complete absence from the game, though this is even worse since the first phase lasted an entire week. Honestly, what else could the reasoning be when the person in question hasn't posted in this thread at all since he signed up?
Why would you want to be a vengeful lynchee? Like I've said earlier, that's an ability mafia tend to want more than townies.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
MartinLuther does follow the wagon a lot, but he just seems more off to me than Jarrema. I've seen Jarrema follow a wagon with no reasoning before, so even though I'd like to see even an 'I voted for you because Zack said your scum' reason, it doesn't bother me enough to give him a vote.
And after I voted I really didn't pay attention to the thread for the whole week. I couldn't tell you who was active and who wasn't.
It seemed like an interesting role. I figured I should go for one like that instead of getting something like bodyguard. And since NinjaCow said that people weren't sending in requests, I figured I'd have an ok shot at getting it.
And after I voted I really didn't pay attention to the thread for the whole week. I couldn't tell you who was active and who wasn't.
It seemed like an interesting role. I figured I should go for one like that instead of getting something like bodyguard. And since NinjaCow said that people weren't sending in requests, I figured I'd have an ok shot at getting it.
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
Dreadnought
Deity
My comment about Visorslash was a slip of memory. Long day at work.
As for the other things, to be fair, you did ask me to find other potential suspects, so I glanced at the thread and posted my ideas.
I'm surprised Buddhafish got a role; I was about to post that lynching him is probably the safest path to take today.
Zack
99% hot gas
I know I asked you for other potential suspects. You gave me one post from a newbie and an accusation against a dead guy. Hence, grasping at straws.
You criticized my case, so I asked you to find a better alternative. You found none.
You criticized my case, so I asked you to find a better alternative. You found none.
Dreadnought
Deity
Very true.
I don't quite understand Buddhafish's role claim (still one month to 21
) thus I defer to your decision.
Dreadnought
Deity
I retract the last line of my previous statement, I just reread the role rules.
Zack
99% hot gas
He's saying he picked Vengeful Lynchee, but someone had already picked it, so he's a vanilla townie.
(If you look at the OP, "cocktail" = vengeful lynchee, "beer" = vanilla townie.)
EDIT: x-post
(If you look at the OP, "cocktail" = vengeful lynchee, "beer" = vanilla townie.)
EDIT: x-post
