Red Dwarf Mafia: The Smeggening [Game Thread - Concluded]

[Zack]

Bother. I was hoping to avoid this, but I set myself up for it by answering that way the first time.

I did not get a kill as part of my role. I said I did because otherwise you would be "Well why not? It's a typical Jack of all Trades role, isn't it?" I was trying to avoid it, but I didn't realize Zack would freak out as much about bladescape. I considered saying MartinLuther, but I thought I wouldn't be able to defend that as well.

 

[choxorn]

Bother. I was hoping to avoid this, but I set myself up for it by answering that way the first time.

I did not get a kill as part of my role. I said I did because otherwise you would be "Well why not? It's a typical Jack of all Trades role, isn't it?" I was trying to avoid it, but I didn't realize Zack would freak out as much about bladescape. I considered saying MartinLuther, but I thought I wouldn't be able to defend that as well.

Now that's just the biggest heap of BS. If you were really town, you'd tell the truth about what your role can do, defensibility be damned. You'd just say "I had a slightly atypical jack-of-all-trades role without a vig-kill." You wouldn't pretend you killed someone when you didn't even have a kill to begin with, just because you somehow thought that would make it easier to save your own skin. That's just completely ridiculous and all claiming something like that would do is hurt and confuse the town.

You're a colossally scummy scumbag, and even on the off-chance this post is actually true, we should policy-lynch you just for lying and pretending to kill someone like that.

 

[Pouter Pigeon]

Cuthillis obviously

 

[Zack]

Going off Visor's last tally.

8 Cuthillius (Choxorn, Al Sips, Internet, Murska, Zack, Winston, KingMorgan, Pouter Pigeon)

2 Winston (BSmith, Double A)
2 Remake (landlubber, Auto)

1 Al Sips (Jarrema)
1 Jarrema (remake)
1 BSmith (Cuthill)

 

[Murska]

The Todhunter claim stinks as well. He was an officer on the ship who was killed off (along with the rest of the crew) in the very first episode and never seen again. His only notable actions (iirc) were calling Rimmer a smeghead and walking Lister to the cryopod that saved him from the disaster. There's no justification for him having the claimed powers.

I have reason to believe that minor characters who're killed off in the very first episode can have interesting powers.

 

[landlubber]

Uh... yeah.
unvote, vote: Cuth

 

[Double A]

I don't normally do this, but I want there to be no chance in hell this guy gets out of this lynch, counterwagon be damned.
unvote
vote: Cthulhuhills

 

[spaceman98]

Here's the thing:

Why did Luiz vote for Takhisis, rather than Cuth or Jarrema?

In other words, why didn't Luiz try to save himself from the lynch as Jarrema did?

The only explanation I can think of is that one of Cuthillius or Jarrema is Luiz's scumpartner, and Luiz didn't want to incriminate them by voting for their rival, or potentially push them into the lead by voting for them.

Jarrema's last-minute switch to Luiz pushed him into the lead (though confirmed-by-death townie Xym finished it off). However, that could just as easily be bussing.

Cuthillius has contributed more overall, even if his analysis has been rather vague at times.

Regardless, at least one of them is the scum we are looking for.

I find vote: Jarrema's overall record to be more questionable. So I say we lynch him today, and if he flips town, we lynch Cuthillius tomorrow.

I'd also be fine with lynching Cuthillius today, and if he flips town, Jarrema tomorrow.

Ok guys I'm back.

I've looked through the thread, and I'm inclined to revert to my original argument: One of Cuth or Jarrema has to be scum due to Luiz's last vote. HAS TO. I know its not Jarrema, so it has to be vote: Cuthillius

 

[spaceman98]

Oh wow there's more stuff here. Responding to it

You and Mursk seem to me to be the only ones that are almost definitely not scum.

This interaction is really wierd. Murska is one of the scummiest people in the thread (aside from yourself Cuth). Looks like PIS to me.

Claiming to choxorn is fine with me.


Why?

Why Chox?

 

[Sprig]

No Brainer. Cuthillis

 

[spaceman98]

I'm Frank Todhunter, Jack of All Trades. I used a kill on bladescape N2, thinking him a scum town-leader, and scried Jarrema as Talia Garret, vanillager, last night. I have a bane, busdrive, and roleblock left.

As for Murska? Like I said, this is similar how he acts all the time. Normally when scum, he's a bit more outspoken and pushy. In this case, he's reading to me as town and he's posted nothing really that could make me suspect him as scum. Unlike everyone else.

Also, sorry if a wolf or two sneaks into my posts, I usually have to go back and paste in scum, as I'm less used to the term.

Well this has nothing to do with my Jarrema-result so IDK what this is about

 

[Sprig]

Outta curiosity, was there any more information about the inquisitor? I am curious about whether it is a mechanic rather than a person.

 

[Zack]

Why Chox?

He suggested choxorn, which I was fine with. Someone already claimed something to you (and Murska), I'd rather not put all the eggs in one basket like that.

In the end, publicly claiming (as I suggested) was clearly the correct choice.

 

[Autolycus]

Yeah, cuthilius has sealed his fate.

 

[Zack]

A wagon of this size indicates bussing, I think.

 

[Internet Flea]

A wagon of this size indicates bussing, I think.

Cuthilius' claim indicates bussing.

 

[Zack]

You think his teammates told him to make that claim as part of the bus?

 

[Internet Flea]

I sure hope so; I'd hate to think he thought it was a legitimately good idea.

 

[Cuthillius]

Cuthilius' claim indicates bussing.

my face indicates bussing

 

[Cuthillius]

Heh. If you go out, may as well do so with a bang.