China should definetly be split into Communist China and Nationalists China and should start at war with each other
I agree with Fanatic Demon, China should be divided in communist- (Mao ?) and nationalist-china (Chiang Kaishek), since it was quiet an important part of the war in Asia and has still consequences today.
I think also that Red Door has a good point when asking to unite Austria & Germany and Ireland & GB. It is historically not correct, but it will make a more realistic Gameplay I guess.
I am playing the add-on pack 1, here are my comments :
- the tank buster doesn't seem to me very useful in his actual configuration. It is less strong than a medium tank (even with anti-tank bonus) and of no use against other units - it should perhaps have a higher bonus against tanks (100% or even higher ?). During the war, especially some russian tank busters such as SU-152 gave a real hard live to the german tanks, so it doesn't seem exaggerated having a strong tank buster - it can cost as much as a heavy tank.
- medium tanks costs exactly the same as light tanks - there should be a difference
- where are all the food resources ? Having no wheat, rice, banana etc. gives heavy health problems and cities cannot grow. Especially since some cities are quiet close together, a bunch of resources would allow them to develop a bit more. There are no cities above 12 and only with a lack of health - that reduces gameplay in my view (even if I understand that cities shouldn't have several industries in order to be specialized)
- Paratroopers cannot jump from Forts or cities, except having an airport, but then we come back to the health problem. I think in BTS Paratroopers can jump from each city or fortress, that would be good in RTW too.
- Think about adding motorized / mechanized infantry. It must not be stronger than normal infantry, just faster. This type of unit was quite an important aspect of the "Blitzkrieg" during the first years of war. Panzers weren't that abundant...
Well, it is always easy to critisize. Thank you very much for this mod, I love playing the scenarios and am thankful that it exists for Civ4. Hopefully, one or two of my comments may help improving your work.