Simpsons Mafia (Game Thread)

I like the theory. It does explain why it takes three days...

Hmm. Why the false results? Is there a role in this game which causes that?

If that role died, perhaps we could get correct results from the jail.
 
Also, to whom it may concern, I saw what you posted before you changed it.

I'd love to know more...
 
I have an addition to that idea:

Who among those we jailed actually seems the most scummy? That turned out "innocent"?

Hospitalize that one. Let's see if any of our hunches were actually correct.


Nominations?

Hospitalize: Mayor

I can't fight this feeling anymore. In my gut, there's something wrong with mayor.
 
Perhaps jailing is the final tactic?

I shall explain my theory.

Jailing tells us that they are innocent. Everyone so far who has gone to jail is innocent.
Now, it is possible this could be true. But you would think that we would have gotten at least one scum/third-party/whatever.
Hospitalization could perhaps after a while, tell us the true faction, role, etc. because of the doctor's checking up on one's background. Maybe jailing doesn't cover that. Perhaps because Wiggum left town, that makes everyone who goes to jail auto-innocent. I'm just theorizing here.

Perhaps what we need to do, is, instead of jailing people, we need to hospitalize them. This will, after a while, let us know their true identities. If we find someone (as we found DaveShack), we then Jail them the next day.

Of course, that may be too slow, and we have just been completely missing our scum. Remember TheBake. We jailed him, and he turned out neutral, which throws a major kink into my above theory.

Anyway, I believe that instead of jailing, we should begin hospitalization. Note how in the tallies, there is also a vote on whether to Jail or Hospitalize.

Those are my thoughts.
 
well we have a very specific accusation of hospitalize autolycus, so let's see where that goes.
 
Kennigit, I've responded to both Winston and Mayor privately, as they can confirm. Given that hospitalization removes people close to permanently from the game, I'd rather not be hospitalized

Now also consider that there don't appear to be any mafia kills at night.

What do you call the deaths and hospitalizations last night, Zack? Also, I'm skeptical of the idea that the groups we've seen so far aren't mafia, since neutrals seem to have been labeled as such.
 
Zack's talking a lot now, contributing to conversation, and no longer in the running really for today's target so I'll unvote:Zack. Let's test the hospital theory by Hospitalize: ninjacow

Vote Tally

Turquoiside: 1 Zack(H)

Zack: 2: Turquoiside (H) autolycus (J)

autolycus:2 Kennigit (H) Winston Hughes (H)

Mayor: atpg (H) (if unvotes not required)

kennigit: ninjacow (J) Gone 3 (??) BSmith (J)

ninjacow: landlubber (H), civgeneral (J), atpg (J) (if unvotes required) mayor (J)
 
Let's see if hospitalise: NinjaCow tells us anything different.
 
Voting deadline was past on that vote General Olaf, update is actually almost out now. Sorry - guess I could've posted to the same effect that the voting was closed.
 
EVENING NINE

One thing was for sure, people were growing more suspicious of each other. Theories of what was going on and who was responsible multiplied, and the decision making process would hang on a delicate balance today.

Many citizens once again demanded more people be released from jail on their own recognizance. However, it would not be Verarde's lucky day as there were not enough in support. Others had argued that criminals were going in and out freely as through revolving door and the jail wasn't serving much use.

Both Kennigit and NinjaCow64 were at the top of the list of suspects, and it seems the decision would be made by chance, large portions of the mob eyeing both of them.

"Hey now, let's not resort to violence."

"WE'RE TAKING THIS ONE INTO CUSTODY. PLEASE REMAIN CALM." An officer's voice came screeching on a megaphone, which had been set to a high volume without his awareness.

They would be in for a surprise as Kennigit took off and dropped his coat to reveal a gruesome figure underneath, but assented to going along with the cops.

Spoiler :
Rich Uncle Skeleton (Kennigit) was jailed
Spoiler :
He is a Scratchyian!


*******************​

Summary
Kennigit was lynched and jailed

Spoiler tallies :


Lynch

The results in the writeup are accurate. Votes cast are below

Kennigit - 4 (johnhughthom, NinjaCow64, Gone 3 the Celt, BSmith1068)
(jail: 3 hospital: 0)

NinjaCow64 - 4 (Autolycus, landlubber, CivGeneral, mayor)
(jail: 2 hospital: 2)

Autolycus - 2 (Kennigit, Winston Hughes)

Mayor - 1 (askthepizzaguy)

Turquoiside - 1 (Zack)

Zack - 1 (Turquoiside)


Abstain - 0

Not Voting: 7 (classical_hero, mechaerik, Mergle, Red_Spy, RRRaskolnikov, SouthernKing, Yoshiegg737)

Release From Jail

No one has enough votes to be released


Verarde - 8 (landlubber, GamezRule, NinjaCow64, Gone 3 the Celt, BSmith1068, askthepizzaguy, mayor, General Olaf)



Spoiler player list :

List of Players

LIVING (21)
Askthepizzaguy
Autolycus
BSmith1068
CivGeneral
classical_hero
GamezRule
General Olaf
Gone 3 the Celt
johnhughthom
landlubber
mayor
mechaerik
Mergle
NinjaCow64
Red_Spy
RRRaskolnikov
SouthernKing
Turquoiside
Winston Hughes
Yoshiegg737
Zack

JAILED (5)
Jarrema
BigTin
Verarde
The Bake
Kennigit

HOSPITALIZED (8)
choxorn
sirtommygunn
DaveShack
bestrfcplayer
Takhisis
Skwink - (replaced taillesskangaru)
Visorslash
TheLastDays

PERMANENTLY KILLED (1)
paulwhoisaghost (Scratchy)

LEFT TOWN (1)
civplayah (Chief Wiggum)




BEGIN NIGHT NINE

Please send Ability Orders by PM.
Be sure to copy Earthling too for now for availability purposes
.

Orders due in ~24 hours, (23:59 US Eastern)

 
ANNOUNCEMENT:

I have vital information that I must give directly to any town DOCTOR in this game.

I volunteer to be the hospitalization tomorrow in exchange for the risk you're taking in revealing to me. You will see that I am innocent.

You need this information before night phase is over. It is worth my death.
 
Note: if two people contact me claiming to be the doctor, I will assume one is mafia and reveal you both. Don't even try it.
 
Anyways may as well write all this up:
This is what I see in the rules, so I can speak freely in the thread here: By default, players in jail may post on the game thread during both Day and Night with the full posting privileges of living players. They may not communicate privately with other players by any means, cannot place any votes including lynch votes, and cannot use abilities.

So, I began as a stonecutter (carl) and was converted night 4 by the scratchians; the scratchians don't even have a goal to eliminate itchians; all that a scratchian has is to survive the itchians.

This indicates the itchians are scum, or at least should speak up as well.

The stonecutters are a secret society that I am still a part of; they are townies (presumably) and can do an action as a group (need a certain amount of members to do so). Nothing changed for me when I became a scratchian, and in fact I never learned the identities of any other scratchian nor was given their quicktopic. I still function as a full on stonecutter, and my PG is still related to the stonecutters.

For the people who knew my identity in the past, jailing does accurately reflect role (I will confirm this now).

The scratchyians are not bad. The stonecutters are not bad. Itchians are bad, or at least may be trying to eliminate scratchyians. No scratchyian ever contacted me, despite the fact that they knew they converted me (I was actually given the option if I wanted to convert or not; I did so). Another stonecutter has been hospitalised before and showed up as simply innocent.

Any doctor should not listen to ATPG, as a lot of townies seem to be organised into a group of some sort. Anything ATPG, or anyone else may want, can be done through group organisation. Information does not need to be hidden around.

I do not really need to be broken out of jail or need to get out of jail; I am not under any danger nor does my individual action really matter too much (the stonecutters need a collective group to do actions).

I cannot discuss in private naturally; wish I could. But I have nothing to hide, so I can post everything publicly.
 
This somewhat corroborates what Paulwhoisaghost told me before he was killed. His main goal was to get into the hospital or jail so that he could avoid getting killed by itchy. He didn’t mention anything about a faction though, so that is certainly news.

You are right that staying in jail is probably the safest for you, given that your identity is now known and you would be an instant target for Itchy.
 
Back
Top Bottom