Spongebob Squarepants Mafia Game Thread.

[Darth Caesar]

Also Thank Your for your words of encouragement, this was really fun to host.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well done mafia, of course.

Game seems weighted toward a mafia victory, given how many of them there are.

That said, it is still possible for town to win. GG

 

[Love]

It seemed like there was few innocent abilities.

 

[robbiecon]

Totally forgot my PG was to have Mr. Krabs Night Killed. Even though I knew it was ATPG for the last two night phases maybe. Oops!

I enjoyed the game, glad I choose choxorn as the kill last night. Spongebob could have been a tougher kill. But obviously should have chosen ATPG really. Oh well. Championes!

 

[choxorn]

Well done mafia, of course.

Game seems weighted toward a mafia victory, given how many of them there are.

That said, it is still possible for town to win. GG

4 mafia in a game of this size probably was excessive unless there were a lot of innocent abilities to counter-balance it.

For the record, who had what abilities? I know Catharsis was a Cop, but that's all.

Oh, BTW, DarthCaesar, just a note for future GMing, do not tell people their action results until the night is already over. It often won't matter, but it also often does matter- like in this game, we wouldn't have known DS was mafia if Catharsis hadn't gotten his scan results before he died.

 

[robbiecon]

DaveShack was a protector. We tried killing Catharsis and DaveShack in one night, but DaveShack had protected Catharsis.

And although it meant we had to sacrifice DrumStudent when the info came out early, it actually played to my advantage, because I was able to gain the trust of most of those remaining, by passing on the info.

 

[classical_hero]

How many points do I get for finding Spoongebob?

There were that many mafia in this game, I never realised that. I must say that robbie played a good game to get everyone thinking he was innocent by turning on one of his own, or at least relaying that info.

 

[DaveShack]

Was robbiecon scan-immune? Catharsis told me that choxorn, robbie, and johnhughthom were innocent.

I panicked on day 1 thinking the highest vote total could be lynched, and started asking advice on whether someone with an ability should reveal. My first PM to johnhughthom actually claimed a pro-town role (don't remember if I specified protector or not), and a separate PM to robbiecon implied a role without saying what it was.

If the plankton role was scan immune, that was a huge difference, since the scan must have been on night 1 or 2. I'm also curious, who roleblocked me?

 

[GenMarshall]

It appears that many have tried to catch a peak behind the panel. I can say, I almost launched the portal turrets when ATPG got a bit too close to the curtin. Anyway, there will be cake.

Link to video.​

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I kept voting for CivGeneral because he was scummy, that's why.

*smacks forehead, indicating how stupid I am*

 

[Darth Caesar]

4 mafia in a game of this size probably was excessive unless there were a lot of innocent abilities to counter-balance it.

For the record, who had what abilities? I know Catharsis was a Cop, but that's all.

Oh, BTW, DarthCaesar, just a note for future GMing, do not tell people their action results until the night is already over. It often won't matter, but it also often does matter- like in this game, we wouldn't have known DS was mafia if Catharsis hadn't gotten his scan results before he died.

Well this game was mostly set up due to the balance advice from Zack.

How many points do I get for finding Spoongebob?

There were that many mafia in this game, I never realised that. I must say that robbie played a good game to get everyone thinking he was innocent by turning on one of his own, or at least relaying that info.

20 which is the amount for accomplishing your PG.

Was robbiecon scan-immune? Catharsis told me that choxorn, robbie, and johnhughthom were innocent.

I panicked on day 1 thinking the highest vote total could be lynched, and started asking advice on whether someone with an ability should reveal. My first PM to johnhughthom actually claimed a pro-town role (don't remember if I specified protector or not), and a separate PM to robbiecon implied a role without saying what it was.

If the plankton role was scan immune, that was a huge difference, since the scan must have been on night 1 or 2. I'm also curious, who roleblocked me?

Yes he was a Godfather.

 

[robbiecon]

How many points do I get for finding Spoongebob?

There were that many mafia in this game, I never realised that. I must say that robbie played a good game to get everyone thinking he was innocent by turning on one of his own, or at least relaying that info.

Thanks classical.

Was robbiecon scan-immune? Catharsis told me that choxorn, robbie, and johnhughthom were innocent.

I panicked on day 1 thinking the highest vote total could be lynched, and started asking advice on whether someone with an ability should reveal. My first PM to johnhughthom actually claimed a pro-town role (don't remember if I specified protector or not), and a separate PM to robbiecon implied a role without saying what it was.

If the plankton role was scan immune, that was a huge difference, since the scan must have been on night 1 or 2. I'm also curious, who roleblocked me?

Yes, I was scan-immune. And it was the mafia who kept blocking you. Once you came to me stating you had a power role such as cop/doctor, I decided it was best to keep you at arm's reach. We blocked you first two nights. Then we decided to lay off you. ATPG became our new roleblocked person (as far as I remember).

When Catharsis came to me Day 2 (or possibly 3), saying he'd scanned me, I decided not to block him. I told him to scan you DaveShack. Then the night we killed DaveShack, we also tried to kill Catharsis, but DaveShack had protected him, before DrumStudent used his one-off extra kill ability on DaveShack. I had been afraid that DrumStudent might be lynched in the future and had wanted to use his ability.