Stairway to Heaven

[BSmith1068]

Yes, I think that vote: MartinLuther is a good alternative to Dave. And if either one does indeed show up as cult, we know where to go next.

 

[Takhisis]

I find a lot of easy voters who just say 'case already presented, vote: whoever is on the lead' very scummy indeed.

 

[JohannaK]

I say that we should go for the cult, not the Mafia. since Mafia can't get new members and the Cult does.

 

[Takhisis]

In the meantime, kill the mafia who've already been outed. Could we have a list of dying(a.k.a. living)/Heaven/Hell players with the next update, Zack?

 

[Zack]

Check the front page.

 

[johnhughthom]

Like, you know, anyone with a modicum of intelligence would have already done.

 

[Jarrema]

In the meantime, kill the mafia who've already been outed.

No.
If there is a cult that can recruit every night, we must refrain from killing last mafia - mafia kill in conjunction with lynch is the only way to cut number of cultist down. And known mafia can be killed at any time later.

 

[Takhisis]

Check the front page.

I do check it, but with the forum outages sometimes I get stuck with just the latest page.

No.
If there is a cult that can recruit every night, we must refrain from killing last mafia - mafia kill in conjunction with lynch is the only way to cut number of cultist down. And known mafia can be killed at any time later.

Aaahhh… so you say that basically the mafia cannot win once we peg them. They're immune to conversion and all that, but we'd better not just let them live… riiight?
There's at least Elijah still alive.

 

[Buddhafish]

And Elijah is it. Abraham and Moses are already dead.

 

[dragonprobably]

Yes, I think that vote: MartinLuther is a good alternative to Dave. And if either one does indeed show up as cult, we know where to go next.

There is a good argument for Dave, but it's already to band wagoned. Vote: Martinluther

That's some pretty good explanation. FoS: BSmith1068 and Xenoneb.

 

[Buddhafish]

Still haven't denied being Elijah, MartinLuther.

 

[dragonprobably]

Still haven't denied being Elijah, MartinLuther.

I've denied being Mafia, that's close enough.

 

[dragonprobably]

You want proof I'm not Mafia? Here's my vote from Day 5. If you remember correctly, Kennigit was Mafia.

AAAAAH! I'm sorry, man. Random Vote! Help Me Out! Unvote; Vote: Kennigit

 

[johnhughthom]

What a curious post by Jarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrema. A lot of assumptions in there. Firstly that there are a lot of cultists. Secondly that each lynch and mafia kill will actually hit a cultist. In your scenario each lynch and nightkill of a townie will strengthen the cult. Then there is the mention of "known mafia". What "known mafia" would that be? The "known mafia" named by the dead cult leader who would in no way be trying to manipulate things to his advantage? The dead cult leader who is sooo trustworthy? Seems like you would like the idea of there being this "known mafia" and his being kept alive and only killed at the last minute, only for him to be innocent and suddenly the real last mafia guy wins.

None of that could be true though, as MartinLuther is the last scum.

 

[Zack]

Day Seven ends in 43 hours and 59 minutes.​

Day extended 24 hours due to the forums being absurdly slow yesterday.





DaveShack: 4.5 (choxorn, Takhisis, Jarrema, SamSniped, Verarde)

MartinLuther: 3.5 (johnhughthom, Buddhafish, Xenoneb, BSmith1068)

topsecret: 1 (MartinLuther)
Mat93: 1 (mgsmuhammad)
Jarrema: 1 (topsecret)


Abstaining: 1 (classical_hero [edited vote])

Not Voting: 6 + 6 Heavenites (Autolycus, DaveShack, Double A, Mat93, Visorslash, wideyedwanderer; Mergle, CivCube, dcmort93, Kennigit, Dreadnought, JoanK)

 

[dragonprobably]

None of that could be true though, as MartinLuther is the last scum.

I voted for a Mafioso! I'm not Mafia!

 

[Buddhafish]

Anyone besides me ever heard of bussing? Or am I the only one?

Nice try, but I'm not buying it.

 

[choxorn]

I would like to thank BSmith, Xenoneb and maybe Buddhafish for so kindly revealing themselves as cultists. Now we know who to kill the next few rounds.

 

[dragonprobably]

Anyone besides me ever heard of bussing?

No, I haven't.

 

[Mergle]

I would like to thank BSmith, Xenoneb and maybe Buddhafish for so kindly revealing themselves as cultists. Now we know who to kill the next few rounds.

Being dead, my head can't asplode, but having read through this, I think this is correct. The cult is insanely dangerous whereas there's presumably just one mafia left, who's not a threat till we're down to 4ish alive. The cult must be priority one. So... voteaveShack.