aneeshm
Deity
This is astounding, nay, shocking beyond words. That advanced-level students of History in the original land of the English would now know two words which I knew at a much earlier age in spite of not being a native speaker, and that they have the shameless gall to attempt to justify this outrage, is a marker of a say day for the language.
Eh-Level History
Some of our countrys advanced-level students of history have been complaining about a question which appeared in an examination: How far do you agree that Hitlers role 1933-45 was one of despotic tyranny?. [1] The phrase despotic tyranny has caused some upset:
t is elitist . . . to assume every history student is going to have come across such a term. [2]
The use of the term despotic tyranny excludes students of a lower ability. [3]
At least it seems that some of our advanced students have learnt the egalitarian ideology well, if nothing else.
I have been offered a place at Cambridge to study English literature and I was not familiar with the word despotic at all despite intensive revision and reading around the topic. [4]
I understand that to be an A level history student you need to have a wide grasp of specialised vocabulary but can i realy be blamed for never hearing the word despotic before? I have never read it, let alone had it taught to me and i was under the impression that exams should be based on a students knowledge of a topic not on their knowedge of a word. [5]
One unhappy mother summed up the complaint rather well:
This was an exam on Hitler and history . . . not on swallowing a dictionary. [6]
Doubtless it is sometimes difficult to determine the meaning of the various usages of words and phrases. I, for instance, have trouble understanding what advanced means.
[1] As reported by Alexis Thompson, History students confused by Hitler despotic tyranny exam question, News Shopper Online, 19th June 2009. (H/T: Laban Tall, The Best Educated Generation in History, UK Commentators (weblog), 26th June 2009.)
[2]-[6] HistoryStudent, JohnS, Bexleystudent09, cmarie, Mother Sidcup, commenting on Alexis Thompsons report. (I have spared the reader a rash of sic-ness.)