The Future of The Olympics

I see no difference. It's not like Arizona, LA or any of the Florida teams ever have any ice outside of their arenas.
They need the same non-conflict as basketball.

You can play it in warmer climates or in the summer due to refrigeration but you still need ice to play it which is the crucial factor in determining winter vs summer Olympics.

It's a winter sport because colleges and high schools play it in the winter, when multi-sport athletes aren't playing outdoor sports.

Perhaps but that doesn't make it a winter Olympics sport.
 
It's a winter sport because colleges and high schools play it in the winter, when multi-sport athletes aren't playing outdoor sports.
Right and the reason it works as a Winter Sport is because it originated as, and remains (at the professional level) an indoor sport. So like you said, it synergizes with the outdoor sports in Fall and Spring. The snow/cold sends everyone indoors, so we break out the basketballs and play an indoor sport. Once it warms up we go back outside for more outdoor sports. It makes no sense to put the basketball season in spring, summer or fall, because you don't need the warm weather to play since you're playing indoors. You save basketball for the winter when you can't play outdoors.
You can play it in warmer climates or in the summer due to refrigeration but you still need ice to play it which is the crucial factor in determining winter vs summer Olympics.
As @Valka D'Ur has already pointed out, you don't need ice to play hockey. You can play field hockey, floor hockey,and street hockey with no ice whatsoever. But like basketball, hockey is a convenient winter sport, because while other sports, particularly at the youth and High School level must be played outdoors, hockey can be played indoors. So when the cold season rolls in and you're limited in the sports you can do, that is the time to do hockey, rather than in the fall or spring when there are so many other sports for your athletes to do and for your spectators to attend.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps but that doesn't make it a winter Olympics sport.

I agree. I was just pointing out why it is (generally speaking) a winter sport, not going along with the people who seem to be saying "let's move basketball to the winter Olympics just to screw with the NBA and see if they handle it better than the NHL does."
 
Right and the reason it works as a Winter Sport is because it originated as, and remains (at the professional level) an indoor sport. So like you said, it synergizes with the outdoor sports in Fall and Spring. The snow/cold sends everyone indoors, so we break out the basketballs and play an indoor sport. Once it warms up we go back outside for more outdoor sports. It makes no sense to put the basketball season in spring, summer or fall, because you don't need the warm weather to play since you're playing indoors. You save basketball for the winter when you can't play outdoors.As @Valka D'Ur has already pointed out, you don't need ice to play hockey. You can play field hockey, floor hockey,and street hockey with no ice whatsoever. But like basketball, hockey is a convenient winter sport, because while other sports, particularly at the youth and High School level must be played outdoors, hockey can be played indoors. So when the cold season rolls in and you're limited in the sports you can do, that is the time to do hockey, rather than in the fall or spring when there are so many other sports for your athletes to do and for your spectators to attend.
Yes, there are many ways to play hockey. I played a lot of floor hockey in school (and wasn't bad at it). But hockey began as an outdoor sport that didn't need a fancy venue to play in, and the kids get excited when the time of year comes to make backyard rinks or neighborhood rinks in green spaces - or if they're lucky enough to live near a pond that has ice thick enough to skate on. The kids are all about hockey, and on the days when it's too slushy on the rinks, they play on the street. My dad used to make homemade hockey pucks for the kids when he and I lived with his girlfriend and her kids... just find a plastic mold of the approximate right size, fill it with water, add some food coloring, and stick it in the freezer. When one puck gets worn down, breaks, or starts to melt, you've got a dozen more.
 
I'm watching a curling semi-final between Great Britain and Sweden and laughing my tail off. They have everyone wired so you can here the discussions, and I understand the Swedish team better than the GB team...which is actually the Scottish national champions. Where is @Traitorfish when I need an interpreter?
 
Yeah it's a bit weird reading this discussion of hockey being in the sumner Olympics when hockey is in the summer Olympics. (India has 8 golds, the Netherlands 5, Australia Britain and Germany 4 and Pakistan 3)
 
Yeah it's a bit weird reading this discussion of hockey being in the sumner Olympics when hockey is in the summer Olympics. (India has 8 golds, the Netherlands 5, Australia Britain and Germany 4)

The tuning of the conversational inverter is the responsibility of the party who lives upside down.
 
Yeah it's a bit weird reading this discussion of hockey being in the sumner Olympics when hockey is in the summer Olympics. (India has 8 golds, the Netherlands 5, Australia Britain and Germany 4 and Pakistan 3)
That's field hockey, which is very different from ice hockey. I've never played field hockey, and have basically zero interest in watching it.
 
Then there's the "slinging posts over heads" competition, which could be held in any season. @Arwon is currently in the lead, though there must be some sort of scoring modification based on the difficulty level of various heads.

If someone wants to chance explaining to @Valka D'Ur I'll be impressed. She'd just get mad at me.
 
Gold medal match, men's Curling, T-60 minutes.

That is all.
 
USA's 5 point stone was impressive. The Swedes are completely broken
 
That's field hockey, which is very different from ice hockey. I've never played field hockey, and have basically zero interest in watching it.

Yeah that's my point though, someone suggested moving ice hockey to the summer Olympics as though there's not already summer hockey there.

(I also suspect regular hockey is the more globally popular sport, so it makes sense it being the hockey at the default Olympics lol)
 
I'm watching a curling semi-final between Great Britain and Sweden and laughing my tail off. They have everyone wired so you can here the discussions, and I understand the Swedish team better than the GB team...which is actually the Scottish national champions. Where is @Traitorfish when I need an interpreter?
Do you know what kind of teuchters play curling? I'd need Kan to interpret for me, then pass the gist on to you.
 
Do you know what kind of teuchters play curling? I'd need Kan to interpret for me, then pass the gist on to you.

The funniest part is that I watch enough curling that I pretty much know the gist of what they are saying already, even when they are saying it in Swedish. It's actually distracting that in some corner of my mind there's a voice screaming "but that's English, why can't I understand it?"
 
If they can do basketball as part of the Summer Olympics, they can do Hockey then also. At least for the Men.

I'd switch it around. They could put Indoor Sports like Fencing or the mentioned Basketball with the Winter Olympics to even out the number of sports and categories over the two.
 
Last edited:
I'd switch it around. They could put Indoor Sports like Fencing or the mentioned Baseball with the Winter Olympics to even out the number of sports and categories over the two.

Fencing should be a winter sport. The urge to skewer people with a sword probably originated when they were all cooped up for the winter in the first place.
 
I want to try curling. It looks fun if you could organise a match between people who've never played it before. I've been told we've got a curling rink/field/place in town but I'm not sure if you can't rent it or something. Hmm.
Our heroes the Muricans are now only 3 medals behind the naughty Canadians and 4 medals behind the even naughtier Germans. There's probably no catching the evil Norwegians, sadly, who must be cheating somehow :mad:
We force our kids into winter sports before they're old enough to refuse. Which is kind of cheating.
 
I want to try curling. It looks fun if you could organise a match between people who've never played it before. I've been told we've got a curling rink/field/place in town but I'm not sure if you can't rent it or something. Hmm.

We force our kids into winter sports before they're old enough to refuse. Which is kind of cheating.

I'm making an only slightly informed guess, but I think they operate somewhat like a bowling alley. You can get your peeps and go get a "lane" (actually the term is sheet) for a game or two for some fee. Or you could trundle in and join a beginner league, which would probably be more fun.
 
I'm making an only slightly informed guess, but I think they operate somewhat like a bowling alley. You can get your peeps and go get a "lane" (actually the term is sheet) for a game or two for some fee. Or you could trundle in and join a beginner league, which would probably be more fun.
You probably have to scale that down quite a bit, as curling is very much a niche sport here (though it's popular on the telly during championships). In fact, in northern Norway all ice sports are pretty niche.
Anyway, I did a google and the curling here takes place in the (one) ice-hockey rink in town. It has curling markers in the ice just like an indoor sports hall can have different markings on the floor for different sports. We have one club, and they have the ice two hours a week. So I imagine it might be tricky for a group of curious amateurs to get the ice for a curling session.
 
Back
Top Bottom