The Set Game II: Members Only

[Souron]

No to the guess.

Member: Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, Liam Neeson, Matt Damon, Nicole Kidman, Hatshepsut, Dr. Seuss, Sid Meier, Cleopatra, Alexander the Great
Non Member: Wilt Chamberlain, Stephen Fry, Hayden Christensen, John Smith (explorer), Optical, Rick Riordan
Unknown: NinjaCow64

Optical actually has his bio filled out, so I was able put him in the non-member list.

 

[Optical]

Hm...

People who never visited the Southern Hamisphere? (In which case, NC would be in the non-member list)

 

[Catharsis]

People whose primary residence is not in a city?

Member: the Unabomber
Non-member: Jay-Z

 

[JohannaK]

Nicole Kidman is Aussie, so I doubt she has not vidited the Southern Hemisphere.

 

[Optical]

I knew that! Um, whoops.

 

[Nintz]

Confusion

Member: Antarctica

Non-Member: My Cat

 

[Souron]

Member: Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, Liam Neeson, Matt Damon, Nicole Kidman, Hatshepsut, Dr. Seuss, Sid Meier, Cleopatra, Alexander the Great, Jay-Z
Non Member: Wilt Chamberlain, Stephen Fry, Hayden Christensen, John Smith (explorer), Optical, Rick Riordan, the Unabomber, Antarctica, Nintz's cat.
Unknown: NinjaCow64

EDIT: A closer look at Jay-Z's wiki says that he is in fact a member.

Hm...

People who never visited the Southern Hamisphere? (In which case, NC would be in the non-member list)

Where NinjaCow64 is from is not in his "about me," so it's not something I could use to determine whether to put as a member of non-member. That's the only information I looked at to decide to put him as unknown. His bio is empty.

By contrast your bio is not empty, so I was able to deduce from it that you are not a member.

 

[KaiserElectric]

That's interesting. What do we know about Nintz's cat that we don't know about Ninja himself?

 

[JohannaK]

We know he's a cat. We don't know what NinjaCow is. Presumably human, but that is yet to be proved

 

[Nintz]

People that have been on multiple continents?

Member: Christopher Columbus

Non-Member: Louis XIV

 

[JohannaK]

Because Liam Neeson has never been to America... and Nicole Kidman hasn't been in two different continents either, and Johnny Depp and Tom Cruise and Matt Damon have never shot in Europe, right?

 

[hoplitejoe]

My guess is the thing which informed Optical's placement was the bit where he said he was a highschool student.
People who have had more than one job?

Member:Susan Boyle
Non-member: Adele

 

[Souron]

Member: Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, Liam Neeson, Matt Damon, Nicole Kidman, Hatshepsut, Dr. Seuss, Sid Meier, Cleopatra, Alexander the Great, Jay-Z, Christopher Columbus, Louis XIV
Non Member: Wilt Chamberlain, Stephen Fry, Hayden Christensen, John Smith (explorer), Optical, Rick Riordan, the Unabomber, Antarctica, Nintz's cat, Susan Boyle, Adele
Unknown: NinjaCow64

 

[Nintz]

People that had tutors at one point? Maybe?

Member: Plato

Non-Member: Arnold Schwarzenegger (I think)

 

[Souron]

Member: Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, Liam Neeson, Matt Damon, Nicole Kidman, Hatshepsut, Dr. Seuss, Sid Meier, Cleopatra, Alexander the Great, Jay-Z, Christopher Columbus, Louis XIV, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rick Riordan
Non Member: Wilt Chamberlain, Stephen Fry, Hayden Christensen, John Smith (explorer), Optical, the Unabomber, Antarctica, Nintz's cat, Susan Boyle, Adele, Plato
Unknown: NinjaCow64

 

[Souron]

Upon further research, I found that Rick Riordan is a member.

 

[Nintz]

People who began their line of work (practically or in training) in their teens?

Member: Chuck Norris (barely)

Non-member: Julia Child

 

[Souron]

No.

Member: Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, Liam Neeson, Matt Damon, Nicole Kidman, Hatshepsut, Dr. Seuss, Sid Meier, Cleopatra, Alexander the Great, Jay-Z, Christopher Columbus, Louis XIV, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rick Riordan, Chuck Norris, Julia Child
Non Member: Wilt Chamberlain, Stephen Fry, Hayden Christensen, John Smith (explorer), Optical, the Unabomber, Antarctica, Nintz's cat, Susan Boyle, Adele, Plato
Unknown: NinjaCow64

 

[Catharsis]

People who are married, or have been married.

Member: Queen Elizabeth II
Non-member: the Wicked Witch of the West

 

[Optical]

I think that's it!

Member: Queen Victoria
Non-member: Queen Elizabeth I